2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[Flandersss]

ATM the only player you'd have confidence of continuous games, would be Doedee ......the others, 3-4 games stints averaging 50's ....

Maybe Murray ......but haven't seen him play ?

Fair call. We say it every year & they show up everytime come lockout.

JLT will be the one.

 

[Turly]

Really not understanding the hype around this guy:

View attachment 461618

Am I missing something? 8 scores below 60, including 4 below 40... Averaged less than 75 last season, which is FAR from keeper status. Why all the hype?

It’s quite clear why you aren’t understanding the hype. You clearly didn’t watch his switch to defence.

Forget the season average and focus on his switch to defence in round 14.

93, 87, 109, 104, 97, 130, 107 and 116 with a couple of rubbish scores to lower the average.

He’s only going to improve and he has had a massive pre season. I’ve got him locked as a keeper.

 

[Flandersss]

It’s quite clear why you aren’t understanding the hype. You clearly didn’t watch his switch to defence.

Forget the season average and focus on his switch to defence in round 14.

93, 87, 109, 104, 97, 130, 107 and 116 with a couple of rubbish scores to lower the average.

He’s only going to improve and he has had a massive pre season. I’ve got him locked as a keeper.

Can’t handle a tag though.. major turnoff. If he kills it he’ll get the hard tag no doubt.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Well i've got both... BUT i prefer Neale because he's quality and POD.

Fyfes ownership is currently at 41% Might jump off him before lockout, if he implodes everyone is going to look like a dickhead whilst i really won't lose much if he comes out firing, can always jump on later.

That's the reason i've been yo-yoing between Fyfe and Neale .......Neales ownership IIRC was about 3%

 

[Turly]

Can’t handle a tag though.. major turnoff. If he kills it he’ll get the hard tag no doubt.

So he can’t handle a tag based on 1 game? In all honesty the umps destroyed him that night.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

It’s quite clear why you aren’t understanding the hype. You clearly didn’t watch his switch to defence.

Forget the season average and focus on his switch to defence in round 14.

93, 87, 109, 104, 97, 130, 107 and 116 with a couple of rubbish scores to lower the average.

He’s only going to improve and he has had a massive pre season. I’ve got him locked as a keeper.

Yes Sicily's improvement SC wise in the last half of the season, was dramatic & sustained .....was one of my first picked, and i haven't wavered since

 

[atlas1]

Interesting, you went Neale over Fyfe .......rationale ?

I've done the same - better injury history, less chance of being played forward, similar numbers. Racks it up

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Can’t handle a tag though.. major turnoff. If he kills it he’ll get the hard tag no doubt.

Isn't that a massive tick for what Sicily was doing ? .....HAW with be better prepared for the tag this year

 

[Turly]

Yes Sicily's improvement SC wise in the last half of the season, was dramatic & sustained .....was one of my first picked, and i haven't wavered since

I’m the same mate. And at that price I cannot resist.

 

[Marlowe]

Post AFLX. Yeah baby.

7k left over

Thoughts Here2tellyouwhy

View attachment 461663
View attachment 461664
View attachment 461666

I like it... except for Barlow.

Gold Coast players should all be wait and see prospects until JLT.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I've done the same - better injury history, less chance of being played forward, similar numbers. Racks it up

Yep ......was going to have both, but i've also got Brayshaw ......so three FREO players in mids ?

So went Neal to Sloane to maintain a POD ........that could be a masterstroke, or ....

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I’m the same mate. And at that price I cannot resist.

AND ....i can rotate him between DEF & FWD .....how cool is that

 

[atlas1]

Post AFLX. Yeah baby.

7k left over

Thoughts Here2tellyouwhy

View attachment 461663
View attachment 461664
View attachment 461666

Very solid lineup, Hurley would be the only one I'd have queries over. Does he go back to playing a true full back role and let Saad/McKenna/McGrath do the rebounding?

 

[atlas1]

Yep ......was going to have both, but i've also got Brayshaw ......so three FREO players in mids ?

So went Neal to Sloane to maintain a POD ........that could be a masterstroke, or ....

Not many teams with Sloane so he would be a huge POD. Usually starts the year well and is im his prime.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Sicily has quite a high ceiling. It's one of the reasons why i'm attracted to him sexually.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Not many teams with Sloane so he would be a huge POD. Usually starts the year well and is im his prime.

This is my thinking !

I often look at players who start seasons on fire, or come home with a bang

I looked at Steph Martin because he starts seasons on fire ...then appears to drift away

Young players, i like to see strong finishes ....Sicily Curnow Billings

 

[Double the Fist]

View attachment 461379 Ok.
Want to try with a heavy starting midfield but not totally sold on D4 set up.
Not fully sold on NicNat and Christensen.

No Toby McLean? Good squad tho

 

[vanders]

Not sure if i will start Sicily at D4 or F4.

Also not sold on Roberton Billings or Heeney. I want to pick Greene but I dont trust him to not miss a month for punching someone.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Not sure if i will start Sicily at D4 or F4.

Also not sold on LMac Billings or Heeney.

View attachment 461682

Link's not working for me ?

 

[GT619]

Too deep in the midfield and too weak up forward I reckon. If Sicily scores a few of those 40s its like playing 4 rookies in you forward line but only 1 in your mids where they are usually better scorers.
Id consider downgrading one of JOM or Coniglio and upgrading Sicily
OR move Sicily down back for Yeo and getting two decent forwards.

All under control . Name a good fwd. I’m waiting to watch the jlt games and I’ll go from there

 

[jack powell]

Nice POD team.
No Danger, no worries as your bating 6 deep in the MIDS.
Gotta keep an eye on NicNat
Touhy and Smith are reasonably safe picks.
Only breakout risk is C.Curnow but the forward line is the place to take risks this year IMO.

Thanks mate appreciate the feedback, danger is just a little to much for my liking, question mark is on nic nat
Who would you recommend to replace curnow still got a lot in the salary cap

 

[Glorin]

Sicily has quite a high ceiling. It's one of the reasons why i'm attracted to him sexually.

Mirror above his bed makes the ceiling appear lower...

 

[Hai_Newman]

Not a fan of the Mitch Robinson or Rich picks but great rucks and Mids.
Some nice ballsy picks too.

You reckon Shuey breaks out a bit with Priddis gone and NicNat back?

Still won't be a top 10 mid and pretty expensive too...cash could be used else where.

 

[Flandersss]

I love him more than he loves himself. Biggest ****** at Hawthorn for a generation.

I love him & Toby.

Good for the game.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Mirror above his bed makes the ceiling appear lower...

I vote Glordawgz for POTY...Classic kenty!!!


TheBeardAmigos make it so lolz....