2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[enobrien]

Changed structure slightly.. reasonably happy outside of Higgins at F4.

Will need to revisit and figure out a way to strengthen that.

View attachment 465204

Not sure you need to spend that cash on Menegola for rd1. His scoring may also plummet with GAJ in the mix now

 

[atlas1]

Does anyone know if theyre going to rectify this shit show? i just had a look on my supercoach site but couldnt find anyway to contact them and whinge, hopefully its like sportsbet and ill have a whinge and instead of getting a bonus bet ill get a free gold subscription.

Looks like it has been fixed now Baz, the scroll bar thing is back

 

[ROOINYOU]

team 2View attachment 465076

It looks like you don't know a lot about the rookies, which is okay...not a lot do(me included). But you will need to take the time to read the Rookies thread and see which rooks are likely to play and go from there. the BF community has some very switched on posters with a lot of knowledge of the young guys and share it with the community.
with the current rookies you have i see most of them not getting a game this year.take some time and read the threads and you'll be in much better shape with your team.
rookies give the cash generation needed to upgrade through the year.
good luck!

oh yeah....Buzza?? he gotta go...NOW!

 

[Unknown Identity]

How much coin left?

$20k, not enough to do anything with.

And you didn't pay out on my team, it must be ok!

 

[Changa10]

That's all i want ......the 20 ppg differential hoping to pickup with a decent F4

I'm not comfortable with Curnow as my D3 .....trying to find a way to push him to F4

I'm not convinced on this strategy at all. What happens if Simpson/Lycett get injured in round 1-3 say? If you have spent the cash you save somewhere else, you will have limited Ruck options to trade to, possibly only Simpson/Lycett.

If the one you chose plays until Round 10, perfect. Lycett has NicNat/Vardy breathing down his neck. Does Simpson play if Lobb is fit?

So many what if's.....

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

$20k, not enough to do anything with.

And you didn't pay out on my team, it must be ok!

Seems like you should have more money left over.

Structures are OK but If you go a straight GNR approach you'll be thankful in the end.

I think you should be looking for value in your starting team. With that in mind, are Menegola, Mitchell, Laird & Oliver actually value picks? Sure, they'll be top 10 by year end but you're not missing out on much by bringing them in later and you might squeeze another premium in to start.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Seems like you should have more money left over.

Structures are OK but If you go a straight GNR approach you'll be thankful in the end.

I think you should be looking for value in your starting team. With that in mind, are Menegola, Mitchell, Laird & Oliver actually value picks? Sure, they'll be top 10 by year end but you're not missing out on much by bringing them in later and you might squeeze another premium in to start.

Haha.. you bastard!

Cheers CC!..

Shall have another Tinker!

 

[JRyan23]

Pretty happy with the structure. Fitted Danger in. F2 and F3 will be those two in the pic or Walters/Smith/Billings. Any changes?

 

[Suma Magic]

Seems like there may be a lot of rookie and mid price options in the midfield, not so many good rookies elsewhere.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Seems like you should have more money left over.

Structures are OK but If you go a straight GNR approach you'll be thankful in the end.

I think you should be looking for value in your starting team. With that in mind, are Menegola, Mitchell, Laird & Oliver actually value picks? Sure, they'll be top 10 by year end but you're not missing out on much by bringing them in later and you might squeeze another premium in to start.

What are your thoughts on Danger?
Must start?

 

[Flandersss]

What are your thoughts on Danger?
Must start?

Yes.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Yes.

Nobody asked you BOB! God damnit..

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

v1.1

Having a look with a budget R2 and Armitage in instead of a rookie.

Still not decided on Armitage or O'Meara, but the former has always been a beast.

Rookies still not set.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

What are your thoughts on Danger?
Must start?

Yes. Those massive captaincy scores will kill you if you don’t have him.

Maybe dusty or Gawn going big could help a little but if he goes bang with 3 big scores, ur absolutely copulated.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Yes. Those massive captaincy scores will kill you if you don’t have him.

Maybe dusty or Gawn going big could help a little but if he goes bang with 3 big scores, ur absolutely copulated.

I enjoy copulation as much as the next guy but point made!..

I'm pretty keen on your boy Luke Parker for some value, 540ish and had a really solid finish to 2017 (9 tonnes from final 12 games) and a 125 in the first final.

How's he travelling?

 

[JRyan23]

Yes I'm back. I just am second guessing going with Simpson/Lycett at R2. The first option is with mid price ruck and the second option is a high priced ruck. Which option?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

I enjoy copulation as much as the next guy but point made!..

I'm pretty keen on your boy Luke Parker for some value, 540ish and had a really solid finish to 2017 (9 tonnes from final 12 games) and a 125 in the first final.

How's he travelling?

Good i understand. I saw him Tuesday and he looked good. But he usually comes home strong. Him & JPK do the same. Work into the season before they really crack in.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I'm not convinced on this strategy at all. What happens if Simpson/Lycett get injured in round 1-3 say? If you have spent the cash you save somewhere else, you will have limited Ruck options to trade to, possibly only Simpson/Lycett.

If the one you chose plays until Round 10, perfect. Lycett has NicNat/Vardy breathing down his neck. Does Simpson play if Lobb is fit?

So many what if's.....

Oh i don't disagree with what your saying, that's also been my defense of not going Lycett ......but also Gawn could do a hammy in rounds 1-3 as well

I'm slowly coming around to "potentially" taking a risk IF i cannot find more meaningful forward Rookies by rnd 1 .....all i'm saying now is that it's a realistic option to be considered

 

[Conca Cuddle]

Changed this a few times and not sure if I'm satisfied. My concerns are running 3 rookies in the middle - dow, brayshaw and brodie.
Also unsure of Lloyd at D3 and Curnow at F4. Thoughts and suggested swaps would be handy.

 

[Red Syrah]

Thoughts on starting danger (perma capt) but not dusty or titch. Thinking that by having m2 and m3 sub 600k then i can afford set and forget rucks and dusty and titch unlikely to increase so will be good upgrade targets.
Currently have fyfe, sloane, cripps and ? Conoglio

 

[JDavey]

Oh i don't disagree with what your saying, that's also been my defense of not going Lycett ......but also Gawn could do a hammy in rounds 1-3 as well

I'm slowly coming around to "potentially" taking a risk IF i cannot find more meaningful forward Rookies by rnd 1 .....all i'm saying now is that it's a realistic option to be considered

Gawn can be sideways traded to another ruck - you can't do the same with Lycett.....

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

A very vanilla side, but whose isn't. 9 players to upgrade, will be going Coniglio to Dangerfield as soon as Cogs orbits $550k.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

It had been decided.
I'm going Dangerless

Ok I'm outta here now.
Later campaigners

 

[Maddog4]

Nothing I was just ******* with him, look at the team. Its probably the worst ive ever seen

gee thanks

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

What are your thoughts on Danger?
Must start?

No

Yes.

No

Nobody asked you BOB! God damnit..

Yes