2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[rocker_oz33]

Cliffs.

 

[ROOINYOU]

View attachment 472558
Hey lads and ladets, first year giving this a crack, please give me a hand if you have advice please share with me

solid team.
I would try and upgrade Pierce.

 

[joop]

View attachment 472558
Hey lads and ladets, first year giving this a crack, please give me a hand if you have advice please share with me

I like it, maybe downgrade O’Meara to upgrade Pearce but nice side overall.

 

[pincrusher]

Latest version. Should only have to make another 30 changes between now and the weekend!!

 

[_M_16_]

Hi Guys, I'm a rookie, first team selection ever.... Can you have a look and tell me what you think?
View attachment 472530

Drop Hewitt for another midfield rookie like Banfield or Brayshaw from Fremantle

Use the extra cash to upgrade Papley, Lever, Melican and Rampe, three of those wont score well, Rampe not consistent enough

Supercoach advice, premiums aside, drop your passion for your own team
I have zero Bulldogs in my team at the moment because I know they wont score well, not consistent, or its a lottery to who will stand up this year

 

[Gene Simmons]

Appreciate the feedback and I have made some further tweaks, still holding $177k in the bank for corrections (which can look at adding Danger/or Dusty) or fixing R2 if Cox isn't working out..

Here goes, open to any suggestions.... Cheers

 

[ROOINYOU]

As humans we try and stay away from pain as much as possible. In this case it’s the pain of possibly losing points from a player that no one else will have. So, automatically these people shut down an outside thought as stupid or not thought out, when really it’s their pain that is showing through and their lack of imagination and willingness to accept that pain.

I have a player in my backline that no one has mentioned in 230 pages. The difference is that I am willing to accept that pain if I am wrong. Most people aren’t, that’s why so many teams are the same.

Points for guessing the Defender?
..Dan Houston or Sam Mayes?...be honest!

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Appreciate the feedback and I have made some further tweaks, still holding $177k in the bank for corrections (which can look at adding Danger/or Dusty) or fixing R2 if Cox isn't working out..

Here goes, open to any suggestions.... Cheers

View attachment 472582

different, not bad though

get Langdon over Keeffe though

 

[SavDog23]

I gave in and changed my team again. Lockitty locked, just waiting for teams.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Points for guessing the Defender?
..Dan Houston or Sam Mayes?...be honest!

Harry Taylor

 

[LegendLewis]

Latest version. Should only have to make another 30 changes between now and the weekend!!

View attachment 472573

Good team. I'm worried about Brodie's disposal, seems to be quite inefficient. Think others in the team will get more of a look in at the stoppages.
I've decided to get Armo and if he goes all out blazing great, if not I will drop down to the best of LDU, Brodie etc.

 

[jjsmitty8]

I've been set on this for a few weeks, and today I made some tweaks and now I'm genuinely torn. Thoughts? Coniglio and Sicily vs Greene and high priced rookies essentially.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

I've been set on this for a few weeks, and today I made some tweaks and now I'm genuinely torn. Thoughts? Coniglio and Sicily vs Greene and high priced rookies essentially.

View attachment 472586

View attachment 472585

Coffield not debuting

 

[jjsmitty8]

Coffield not debuting

Is that confirmed? Just read conflicting articles.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Is that confirmed? Just read conflicting articles.

rumour going around only one of Coff/Clark debuting this week and it is Clark

 

[St BKD]

Appreciate the feedback and I have made some further tweaks, still holding $177k in the bank for corrections (which can look at adding Danger/or Dusty) or fixing R2 if Cox isn't working out..

Here goes, open to any suggestions.... Cheers

View attachment 472582

Cox won't work out

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[jjsmitty8]

rumour going around only one of Coff/Clark debuting this week and it is Clark

Yeah I've heard that rumour too, but literally just saw a tweet that Jarryn Geary said they're both ready to go.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Yeah I've heard that rumour too, but literally just saw a tweet that Jarryn Geary said they're both ready to go.

yeah, but only Clark has been confirmed, which tells me that Coff wont debut

they normally do it together

 

[jjsmitty8]

yeah, but only Clark has been confirmed, which tells me that Coff wont debut

they normally do it together

Yeah 100%, I agree.

 

[MrDanggazz]

solid team.
I would try and upgrade Pierce.

Upgrade to who do you think? I have 130k left over, I could use that to upgrade omeara as well :/

 

[ROOINYOU]

Upgrade to who do you think? I have 130k left over, I could use that to upgrade omeara as well :/

I would downgrade JOM to a rookie and use the left over funds to up Pierce.
Saying that, if you like Pierce as a solid point/cash maker then back yaself in. We all need something different to separate us from each other.
I just like to start with proven scorers and jump on the guys moving up with my trades.
each to their own mate!..ya looking good ATM.

 

[Mitchell54]

very Likely to run with this. I like the look of it
Leaves room for rookie adjustments.
Got a couple PODish players in there


thoughts

 

[KardiniaPark]

That's pretty deep mate! You ok?

I'm OK, thanks for asking though. I'm into the psychology of how and why people think a certain way. I could rattle on about cognitive bias and the part it plays in Supercoach but you'd probably fall asleep.

Points for guessing the Defender?
..Dan Houston or Sam Mayes?...be honest!

No points because I'm not saying who, but no it's not those you mentioned. Much cheaper but IMO a stronger option at D4 than someone like Naughton or Cole and only a bit more expensive. But time will tell, you'll find out Sunday after lockout and I'll be a moron or a genius . The other deciding factor is that I have well over $200k in the bank so if I'm not feeling it's working I can go directly to a Sicily type if he starts well and looks like being a keeper. My guy is certainly not a keeper but I think he can make some solid enough money and IMO is assured of playing every week, even though his ceiling may not be great he should be more consistent than others around his price point.

MOUSTACHE.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

I'm OK, thanks for asking though. I'm into the psychology of how and why people think a certain way. I could rattle on about cognitive bias and the part it plays in Supercoach but you'd probably fall asleep.



No points because I'm not saying who, but no it's not those you mentioned. Much cheaper but IMO a stronger option at D4 than someone like Naughton or Cole and only a bit more expensive. But time will tell, you'll find out Sunday after lockout and I'll be a moron or a genius . The other deciding factor is that I have well over $200k in the bank so if I'm not feeling it's working I can go directly to a Sicily type if he starts well and looks like being a keeper. My guy is certainly not a keeper but I think he can make some solid enough money and IMO is assured of playing every week, even though his ceiling may not be great he should be more consistent than others around his price point.

MOUSTACHE.

its my boi Babyface Zach

 

[KardiniaPark]

very Likely to run with this. I like the look of it
Leaves room for rookie adjustments.
Got a couple PODish players in there
View attachment 472598

thoughts

IMO having Nank takes away so much from a team. I'm not saying everyone needs to get Lycett, Cox or Simpson but if you are going to pay $500k you might as well find some more money and get handsome Stef. Nank to me is just a middle tier that you are going to have to upgrade if you want to finish near the pointy end of the competition. I would implore everyone to find another option I just don't think he's the answer.