Prediction 2019 Hypothetical Trades Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

MadMundy

Premiership Player
Mar 29, 2019
3,397
6,049
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Arsenal, Glory, Bulls
If Fremantle and Geelong come to the table for Tim Kelly how would Geelong fans feel about

Geelong receives: Pick 7 + Blakely or Langdon

Fremantle receives: Kelly
 

mezaire

Club Legend
Aug 11, 2009
2,203
1,223
Hobart
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Launceston FC
I still have a feeling Gaff will go back to Vic this trade period.
Would love WC to make a play for Constable with Kelly.

Gaff + 14
For
Kelly + Constable
 

Log in to remove this ad.

THE_GUN

R.I.P Shane Tuck 21
Dec 28, 2007
29,742
56,334
3121
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Richmond 2019 Premiers
Looking likely Richmond get #21 for Ellis

Pick #19 + #21
for North's / Carlton's 1st rounder (if Papley decides to stay)
 

Mister M

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 16, 2016
6,585
8,475
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Fighting Furies
Looking likely Richmond get #21 for Ellis

Pick #19 + #21
for North's / Carlton's 1st rounder (if Papley decides to stay)
If Richmond are going to package up Pick #19 + #21, and move up to the first round; I'd be more interested if we did something like

Pick #19 (948pts), Pick #21 (878), Pick #72 (19) & Pick #74 (0) (Total points 1845)

FOR

St. Kilda's Pick #6 ( 1751).

Richmond probably only need to use 3 draft picks this year once we promote rookies as there will be minimal list changes this year.

Picks 6, 38 & 39 would be a pretty good starting point for a premiership team.

Plus St. Kilda will probably be better off splitting up their first round pick into two as they are aiming to get B. Hill, Z. Jones & Ryder.
 

THE_GUN

R.I.P Shane Tuck 21
Dec 28, 2007
29,742
56,334
3121
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Richmond 2019 Premiers
If Richmond are going to package up Pick #19 + #21, and move up to the first round; I'd be more interested if we did something like

Pick #19 (948pts), Pick #21 (878), Pick #72 (19) & Pick #74 (0) (Total points 1845)

FOR

St. Kilda's Pick #6 ( 1751).

Richmond probably only need to use 3 draft picks this year once we promote rookies as there will be minimal list changes this year.

Picks 6, 38 & 39 would be a pretty good starting point for a premiership team.

Plus St. Kilda will probably be better off splitting up their first round pick into two as they are aiming to get B. Hill, Z. Jones & Ryder.
* Pick #72 & Pick #74 are no good to St Kilda as they dont need points or will use them
* St Kilda wont trade pick #6 as they need it to trade for Brad Hill
 

Mister M

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 16, 2016
6,585
8,475
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Fighting Furies
* Pick #72 & Pick #74 are no good to St Kilda as they dont need points or will use them
* St Kilda wont trade pick #6 as they need it to trade for Brad Hill
With upcoming trades, retirements, injuries, etc. it is very likely that St. Kilda are going to use more than 4 draft picks in the 2019 drafts. St. Kilda's current picks are 6, 57, 69 & 79 and they'll need to trade at least some of them out to get in Hill, Jones, Ryder, etc. Therefore they will need picks to fill their list; therefore I believe St. Kilda are more likely to use Picks 72 & 74 than Richmond will.

Richmond will only use three picks in the 2019 draft as we've got four rookies we need to promote to the main list (Chol, Stack, Baker & Pickett); then fill the rookie list with speculative mature age players like we did at the end of last year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

THE_GUN

R.I.P Shane Tuck 21
Dec 28, 2007
29,742
56,334
3121
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Richmond 2019 Premiers
St Kilda will also be trading out players and will get picks for them which will be better than 70's but doesnt mean that much as there wont be many picks used after 70 anyway
 

Mikevk123

Club Legend
Jun 25, 2019
1,375
1,164
AFL Club
Essendon
I’ll go with the Saints to start.

Fremantle Receive: Pick 6 and Blake Acres
St Kilda Receive: Brad Hill and Pick 26

Geelong Receive: Jack Steven and Pick 56
St Kilda Receive: Pick 34

Sydney Receive: Daniel Mackenzie and a future Third Round Pick
St Kilda Receive: Zak Jones and a future Fourth Round Pick

Western Bulldogs Receive: Josh Bruce
St Kilda Receive: 32 and 50

Port Adelaide Receive: Pick 50 and 79
St Kilda Receive: Paddy Ryder and Sam Gray.


In: Ryder, Gray, Jones, Hill,Pick 26,32,34 future Fourth
Out: Acres,Steven,Bruce,Mackenzie,Pick 6,50,56 future Third
 

Hawks78

Draftee
Oct 3, 2019
2
1
AFL Club
Hawthorn
I still have a feeling Gaff will go back to Vic this trade period.
Would love WC to make a play for Constable with Kelly.

Gaff + 14
For
Kelly + Constable
Geelong aren’t interested in a west coast player, so I would suggest:
Hawks offer pick 11 for gaff, then west coast give picks 11 & 14 for Kelly .
Everyone wins
 

Roadto2018

Club Legend
Oct 9, 2014
1,869
3,421
AFL Club
St Kilda
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur FC
If Richmond are going to package up Pick #19 + #21, and move up to the first round; I'd be more interested if we did something like

Pick #19 (948pts), Pick #21 (878), Pick #72 (19) & Pick #74 (0) (Total points 1845)

FOR

St. Kilda's Pick #6 ( 1751).

Richmond probably only need to use 3 draft picks this year once we promote rookies as there will be minimal list changes this year.

Picks 6, 38 & 39 would be a pretty good starting point for a premiership team.

Plus St. Kilda will probably be better off splitting up their first round pick into two as they are aiming to get B. Hill, Z. Jones & Ryder.
This would be quite possibly the worst trade in history, basically trading 6 for 19 and 21, points are absolutely irrelevant, would rather do the Lovett trade 10 times over before doing this one.
 

Thetrader15

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 16, 2015
20,256
23,984
AFL Club
Adelaide
I’ll go with the Saints to start.

Fremantle Receive: Pick 6 and Blake Acres
St Kilda Receive: Brad Hill and Pick 26

Geelong Receive: Jack Steven and Pick 56
St Kilda Receive: Pick 34

Sydney Receive: Daniel Mackenzie and a future Third Round Pick
St Kilda Receive: Zak Jones and a future Fourth Round Pick

Western Bulldogs Receive: Josh Bruce
St Kilda Receive: 32 and 50

Port Adelaide Receive: Pick 50 and 79
St Kilda Receive: Paddy Ryder and Sam Gray.


In: Ryder, Gray, Jones, Hill,Pick 26,32,34 future Fourth
Out: Acres,Steven,Bruce,Mackenzie,Pick 6,50,56 future Third
I don't do that if I'm Sydney, but it's a good start
 

boncer34

Inaugural Steward
Jul 11, 2005
49,037
53,531
Baghdad
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Melbourne Storm
If Richmond are going to package up Pick #19 + #21, and move up to the first round; I'd be more interested if we did something like

Pick #19 (948pts), Pick #21 (878), Pick #72 (19) & Pick #74 (0) (Total points 1845)

FOR

St. Kilda's Pick #6 ( 1751).

Richmond probably only need to use 3 draft picks this year once we promote rookies as there will be minimal list changes this year.

Picks 6, 38 & 39 would be a pretty good starting point for a premiership team.

Plus St. Kilda will probably be better off splitting up their first round pick into two as they are aiming to get B. Hill, Z. Jones & Ryder.
Absolute no chance.
 

Halloween Jack

All Australian
Aug 13, 2013
721
2,614
AFL Club
Essendon
With upcoming trades, retirements, injuries, etc. it is very likely that St. Kilda are going to use more than 4 draft picks in the 2019 drafts. St. Kilda's current picks are 6, 57, 69 & 79 and they'll need to trade at least some of them out to get in Hill, Jones, Ryder, etc. Therefore they will need picks to fill their list; therefore I believe St. Kilda are more likely to use Picks 72 & 74 than Richmond will.

Richmond will only use three picks in the 2019 draft as we've got four rookies we need to promote to the main list (Chol, Stack, Baker & Pickett); then fill the rookie list with speculative mature age players like we did at the end of last year.
Picks 72 and 74 are useless. If the Saints need extra picks, they will get picks around that mark anyway as other teams finish their drafting. The last 3 drafts had 78, 78 and 77 picks in total. Or they can keep picks for the pre-season draft and/or the period where you sign undrafted players (eg wehre you guys got Stack)

so your trade is essentially 19 and 21 for 6, not a chance.
 

Remove this Banner Ad