Teams 2019 Rate My Team (Pre JLT)

[Tyruddanaut]

It's worth mentioning there are some over-rated first round picks (AFL Fantasy Scores):
Tarryn Thomas, Senior avg. 31. 175k.
Nick Blakey, U18 Champs avg. 67. 167k
Jye Caldwell, U18 Champs avg. 33 (I know, injury), State Junior League U18s (2018), 76 avg. 162k
Connor Rozee, SANFL avg. 70 (Decreases significantly at AFL), 189k
Isaac Quaynor, U18s avg. 74, 153,300

Meanwhile, the most underrated is Bailey Smith, 125 avg. U18 Champs, 176 avg. TAC 2018, 118 avg. TAC 2017. 180,300. Big body translates well into AFL scoring
Walsh and Ely Smith should be looked at, too.
Walsh, U18s 142 avg. TAC 151 avg. TAC (2017) 121 avg. 207k
Ely Smith, U18s 122 avg. State Junior 114 avg 117k (Worth mentioning a senior avg. of 73)

Bewley should be a lock (104 senior avg.)
Foley high (115 U18s, 139 TAC, 99 TAC 2017)
Valente high (118 U18s, 159 SANFL U18s)
Hayes (98 senior avg.)
Fort (125 VFL)

TL;DR: What's in bold

 

[Andrew Birch]

Some rookie choices questionable
Mid-Price MADNESS

Questioning rookie place holders in December should be a banworthy offence.
Just some of the mid pricers or all 6 of them? Keeping in mind I started with 8 mid pricers in 2018 & finished top500

 

[toxic]

Some rookie choices questionable
Mid-Price MADNESS

As a bigfooty SC rule,

All teams posted, their rookies are place holders only. Most will include 1 or 2 expensive rookies so their structure remains in place

 

[zoomba23]

V1 completed today, albeit on the poor man's team picker. You privileged Gold campaigners should consider yourselves lucky.

I'm continuing the midprice madness bonanza that has contaminated this forum with a fair few sketchy picks. I tell myself every year after my midpricers s**t the bed spectacularly that I'll take a pure Guns n Roses approach next season, but by January I'm always drooling over all the juicy 300 400k campaigners that turned from decent to horseshit ages back, in the completely irrational hope that they remember how to play football.

Midpricers:
Williams: Hasn't got a dicky ticker and knows the reason the word foot is in football.
Roberton: Has got a dicky ticker and knows the reason the word foot is in football.
Brouch: Solid set of skills, hoping he puts younger bro back in his place.
Ex-Million Dollar Man: Clarko'll do some juju on him and he'll come out next season able to outrun entire teams.
Punchable: As long as I avoid looking at his face, he's a lock. Just wish CD gave points out for kung fu kicks.

Thoughts much appreciated.

 

[Andrew Birch]

As a bigfooty SC rule,

All teams posted, there rookies are place holders only. Most will include 1 or 2 expensive rookies so their structure remains in place

BF rookie place holder template

 

[Hai_Newman]

BF rookie place holder template

View attachment 595815

Chol left...hamummmm...I mean cash left?

 

[Test Tickle]

Version 1.2.1

 

[Test Tickle]

BF rookie place holder template

View attachment 595815

I see what you've done there
Like the Bombers famous centre line of, Kickett Long Dick.

 

[Sir Skid]

I see what you've done there
Like the Bombers famous centre line of, Kickett Long Dick.

Lolz @ classic BF username

 

[Kadog]

Very, very solid team across all lines brother. Love the Grundy/Gawn combo. Ballsy.

Here’s my current team - Version 1.3

Would love your thoughts
View attachment 595785
View attachment 595783
View attachment 595784

Like the Blakely Witherden picks. Midfield solid AF. Question marks on Kruezer and Billings. Otherwise very good team. You’re always on point bud.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Very, very solid team across all lines brother. Love the Grundy/Gawn combo. Ballsy.

Here’s my current team - Version 1.3

Would love your thoughts
View attachment 595785
View attachment 595783
View attachment 595784

Billings equals.......

 

[Spider Eater]

ITS HERE!!!

View attachment 594728

I actually walked out of a work lunch for this...

I can't believe Docherty was 511k despite missing a whole year.
Are the guys that set petrol prices also handling Supercoach?

 

[Huttabito]

Billings equals.......
View attachment 595823

Final rank yeh?

 

[Sir Skid]

BF rookie place holder template

View attachment 595815

Lolz

 

[freddy mercury]

I dont think I have seen Neale in any sides yet. Am I missing something? He is my M2.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I dont think I have seen Neale in any sides yet. Am I missing something? He is my M2.

Under consideration

Think he's priced at his max though

 

[Blaknight]

I dont think I have seen Neale in any sides yet. Am I missing something? He is my M2.

Locked in mine.

 

[zoomba23]

I dont think I have seen Neale in any sides yet. Am I missing something? He is my M2.

Locked and loaded in mine. Meaning he'll probably do an ACL first JLT game.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

I dont think I have seen Neale in any sides yet. Am I missing something? He is my M2.

Keep your thoughts to yourself please so campaigners don’t copy.. he’s a stud and locked for mine.. but shhhh trying to keep his ownership low

 

[Glorin]

They have no sc relevant ruck
I like baby joe daniher but hes so injury prone
Hepatitis is DT only
Shiel the ultimate underperformer
Hooker doesnt know whether hes Arthur or Martha

So its Zerrett or bust

The consistancy of Smith last year was excellent. Needs to be considered.

 

[toxic]

The consistancy of Smith last year was excellent. Needs to be considered.

Agreed completely, missed little lunchmeat

Altho personally i can't see any improvement from him, but he's a solid pick

 

[SavDog23]

Billings equals.......
View attachment 595823

50000 behinds? Yeah that sounds about right for Billings.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

50000 behinds? Yeah that sounds about right for Billings.

I thought .....and thought ....and thought about including Billings at his price .......but i just can't do it !!

Have to give myself some chance of having a good SC year !

 

[bananatigz]

Alright Kenties, here we go


DEF: Laird never gonna give you up, never gonna let you down. Blakely is just a good footy player, was always gonna pick him with DEF status and news that he's going back into the middle to replace Neale are tasty. Williams, Roberton, Birchall are all no brainers if they are up and running by round 1.

MID: Mitchell, Cripps, Fyfe are the 3 SC big dogs now, just lock them in and enjoy the ride. Dusty is underpriced for what we know he can do. Libba is a contested beast and will always score well when he manages to get on the park.

RUC: Grundy a freak, Westhoff I'm happy to start at R2 and wait and see what happens with Goldy/Gawn/Krooz etc, bring the best one of those guys in and send the Hoff forward.

FWD: Danger DUR, Heeney should just keep getting better. Dunkley's end to last season is too good to ignore, although will have to see whether Libba coming back affects his mid time, Chadwick firmly in the frame there as well. Greene cheap as chips if he gets fit.

 

[freddy mercury]

Alright Kenties, here we go

View attachment 595925
DEF: Laird never gonna give you up, never gonna let you down. Blakely is just a good footy player, was always gonna pick him with DEF status and news that he's going back into the middle to replace Neale are tasty. Williams, Roberton, Birchall are all no brainers if they are up and running by round 1.

MID: Mitchell, Cripps, Fyfe are the 3 SC big dogs now, just lock them in and enjoy the ride. Dusty is underpriced for what we know he can do. Libba is a contested beast and will always score well when he manages to get on the park.

RUC: Grundy a freak, Westhoff I'm happy to start at R2 and wait and see what happens with Goldy/Gawn/Krooz etc, bring the best one of those guys in and send the Hoff forward.

FWD: Danger DUR, Heeney should just keep getting better. Dunkley's end to last season is too good to ignore, although will have to see whether Libba coming back affects his mid time, Chadwick firmly in the frame there as well. Greene cheap as chips if he gets fit.

Interested to see why you've picked Bennell? He is in my side also.