Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[DaveyBoy123]

Risky picks...

Gawn v Darcy

Dawson v Short

Your post has been designated the Weet-Bix Big Hitter question of the week... Your answer is:

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Perkins looks good though.....

2nd year players are "rarely" consistent ....as you correctly said, Piggy an exception, rather than the rule

 

[A Bit Dusty]

2nd year players are "rarely" consistent ....as you correctly said, Piggy an exception, rather than the rule

Perkins is a trap 100% both preseason games tons up from nowhere with senior players rested.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Caldwell vs Berry

This is so 50/50 for me

 

[kananooks]

Caldwell vs Berry

This is so 50/50 for me

berry. more proven. bigger question would be to chuck jhf in that mix

 

[JuddgementDay]

berry. more proven. bigger question would be to chuck jhf in that mix

True that’s my fallback
I’m leaning towards Caldwell for some reasons - I don’t even know why

 

[kananooks]

True that’s my fallback
I’m leaning towards Caldwell for some reasons - I don’t even know why

potential for a breakout. thats why. low ownership. plenty of upside at that price.

would still choose berry. good for an 80 avg at least. caldwell i dont think will be able to manage much more than that.

ridley vs short vs whitfield?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Who to drop for Touk. Steele or Oliver? Macrae is non negotiable.

 

[Northernsoul74]

potential for a breakout. thats why. low ownership. plenty of upside at that price.

would still choose berry. good for an 80 avg at least. caldwell i dont think will be able to manage much more than that.

ridley vs short vs whitfield?

I have Whitfield and Short. At his price I’d say Whitfield.

 

[kananooks]

I have Whitfield and Short. At his price I’d say Whitfield.

for 30k its not much of a saving to say for the price.

 

[Northernsoul74]

for 30k its not much of a saving to say for the price.

Every $ helps with these expensive rookies.

 

[JuddgementDay]

potential for a breakout. thats why. low ownership. plenty of upside at that price.

would still choose berry. good for an 80 avg at least. caldwell i dont think will be able to manage much more than that.

ridley vs short vs whitfield?

Whitfield for me

I would go Ridley if I can be assured he takes most kick-ins and allowed to play 3rd tall/ interceptor - but, it his role will likely change from game to game

 

[Ingy]

Who to drop for Touk. Steele or Oliver? Macrae is non negotiable.

Did you really learn something new about Touk tonight?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Did you really learn something new about Touk tonight?

Nothing new about any of the 4 but can only take 3. I wondered if Rowell might impact his scoring a little but now think Rowell plus Witts probably helps him. His lower ownership makes it a no brainer to pick him ahead of the others.

 

[Lord De Goey]

JHF M6 and Stephens M9 (Sydney)

Or

Berry M6 and Hough M9

 

[timbo3195]

My final decision, pending rookies... Parish & Xerri vs Miller & McEntee

 

[Northernsoul74]

My final decision, pending rookies... Parish & Xerri vs Miller & McEntee

Parish and Xerri if you trust Xerri role.

 

[buttox]

JHF M6 and Stephens M9 (Sydney)

Or

Berry M6 and Hough M9

JHF M6 (80ish) and Stephens M9 (60ish) (Sydney) =140
or
Berry M6 (85ish) and Hough M9 (50ish) = 135.
Very close. Hard to answer before teams are announced.
That is my best guess.

 

[Lord De Goey]

JHF M6 (80ish) and Stephens M9 (60ish) (Sydney) =140
or
Berry M6 (85ish) and Hough M9 (50ish) = 135.
Very close. Hard to answer before teams are announced.
That is my best guess.

Yep it’s close. Could make a case that Rowell M5 and Berry M6 is a bit overkill too?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Yep it’s close. Could make a case that Rowell M5 and Berry M6 is a bit overkill too?

Really hard to answer that without seeing the whole team and where you’ve taken a haircut by having both Rowell and Berry.

 

[buttox]

Yep it’s close. Could make a case that Rowell M5 and Berry M6 is a bit overkill too?

I'm running 6 rookies on field.
Hinge d5 + McCartin d6
JHF m6 + Daicos m7 + Ward m8
Rachele f6
Hinge is the one I want to move on.
I'm comfortable with all the others being on the field.

 

[Lord De Goey]

Really hard to answer that without seeing the whole team and where you’ve taken a haircut by having both Rowell and Berry.

Hewett D4 is probably what’s allowed me to do it

 

[Lord De Goey]

I'm running 6 rookies on field.
Hinge d5 + McCartin d6
JHF m6 + Daicos m7 + Ward m8
Rachele f6
Hinge is the one I want to move on.
I'm comfortable with all the others being on the field.

I have the same rookies on field but also Xerri F5 if he counts

 

[Northernsoul74]

Hewett D4 is probably what’s allowed me to do it

Same. I don’t love it but it makes my team better on paper.

 

[Northernsoul74]

I have the same rookies on field but also Xerri F5 if he counts

Same.