Opinion 2024 and Beyond

[Kiama Chris]

Jamarra would fit in beautifully in that photo

Sadly if he did one of those would be missing.

 

[Dan87]

No he wouldn’t

And why would that be?

 

[Millky95]

And why would that be?

Sadly if he did one of those would be missing.

And it would be McDonald

 

[blackbelair]

And why would that be?

1. He is not even a good player.
2. He is young. We already have many young forwards WHO are even better than this flog.
3. Our team is already solid without him - have some faith.
4. He definitely is not a “blood”.
5. I don’t know why we would even need him in the first place?!
6. Waste of money.
7. Now that bud is gone, our boys can step up.
8. Why is he even leaving his club where he got chosen / drafted - to me that is alarm bells in its self.

 

[Dan87]

1. He is not even a good player.
2. He is young. We already have many young forwards WHO are even better than this flog.
3. Our team is already solid without him - have some faith.
4. He definitely is not a “blood”.
5. I don’t know why we would even need him in the first place?!
6. Waste of money.
7. Now that bud is gone, our boys can step up.
8. Why is he even leaving his club where he got chosen / drafted - to me that is alarm bells in its self.

He's be our best forward why couldn't he be a blood?

Why's he a flog?

 

[blackbelair]

He's be our best forward why couldn't he be a blood?

Why's he a flog?

1. You think he’s better than what we have?
And on that, we’ve been good (clearly) making the GF plus close last year without him. How are you so fascinated by this “flog” - honestly?

2. Look at him. How come he wants to leave dogs?

3. Do you even follow the swans?

 

[Dan87]

1. You think he’s better than what we have?
And on that, we’ve been good (clearly) making the GF plus close last year without him. How are you so fascinated by this “flog” - honestly?

2. Look at him. How come he wants to leave dogs?

3. Do you even follow the swans?

Sounds like you have a lot of irrational dislike of a young player and it's making you hostile

Maybe you should be honest about why

Cheerio

 

[blackbelair]

Sounds like you have a lot of irrational dislike of a young player and it's making you hostile

Maybe you should be honest about why

Cheerio

Bruh. Read everything I’ve said.

I’ve listed more than enough to complete your poor attuide to your beloved swans - well you never answered that Q, maybe you do go for the dogs you “flog”.

GL in 2024 mate

 

[Bloods86]

Bruh. Read everything I’ve said.

I’ve listed more than enough to complete your poor attuide to your beloved swans - well you never answered that Q, maybe you do go for the dogs you “flog”.

GL in 2024 mate

I'm not sure following/supporting the Swans equates to believing that all of our players are better than every other player in the league. There's objectively better players out there, it's not disloyalty.

If that were the case, we should be calling for the entire coaching staff and management to be sacked, because we don't win every flag.

 

[blackbelair]

I'm not sure following/supporting the Swans equates to believing that all of our players are better than every other player in the league. There's objectively better players out there, it's not disloyalty.

If that were the case, we should be calling for the entire coaching staff and management to be sacked, because we don't win every flag.

Not another one.

So the bigger picture here is that we are not perfect but compared to alot of other teams we are and tbh, you should, well I am proud of our team for who we are and what we are… the world ain’t perfect but yet again after everything we are always in the top 8 yet better top 4.

Don’t tell me you’re chasing a “flog” too who thinks will win us a flag.

 

[caesar88]

Not another one.

So the bigger picture here is that we are not perfect but compared to alot of other teams we are and tbh, you should, well I am proud of our team for who we are and what we are… the world ain’t perfect but yet again after everything we are always in the top 8 yet better top 4.

Don’t tell me you’re chasing a “flog” too who thinks will win us a flag.

I don't want Ugle-Hagan but you can't be questioning other people's allegiance to the club and calling them flogs when they express an opinion you don't share or they ask you simple questions. Keep it civil.

 

[anotherletdown]

Bruh. Read everything I’ve said.

I’ve listed more than enough to complete your poor attuide to your beloved swans - well you never answered that Q, maybe you do go for the dogs you “flog”.

GL in 2024 mate

joeyjojo, is that you? Which pub this time?

 

[Bloods86]

Not another one.

So the bigger picture here is that we are not perfect but compared to alot of other teams we are and tbh, you should, well I am proud of our team for who we are and what we are… the world ain’t perfect but yet again after everything we are always in the top 8 yet better top 4.

Don’t tell me you’re chasing a “flog” too who thinks will win us a flag.

If JUH is available, I'd certainly be thinking about it. Though we have this year to see if Logan can take another step, McLean can maintain his good form, and Amartey can play out most of a season.

If players are "flogs" for leaving the club that drafted them, then JPK is a "flog", Ted Richards, Buddy, Paul Williams, Jolly, Ball, Nick Davis, Shaw, Mattner etc are all "flogs" (most of whom played key roles in Swans flags). Then we've just brought in a bunch of "flogs" in the off season.

Trading is part of the game, players decide to leave clubs for various reasons, that's it.

 

[blackbelair]

I don't want Ugle-Hagan but you can't be questioning other people's allegiance to the club and calling them flogs when they express an opinion you don't share or they ask you simple questions. Keep it civil.

I have been civil. I’ve answered all questions directed at myself after expressing my thoughts with little to nothing from the other guy. Not sure how this is directed at me, is it because I’m talking the truth and actually believing in what we have and what I strongly belief. Instead maybe see what I’m saying after stating positive things about our club instead of “wanting” to sign another player who in my opinion (may be wrong) that we do not need. If we needed him we would have chased him. Don’t you see what we have or are you too not happy in what we have. Everyone is now attacking me for nothing but love for my club and believing in what we have is good enough. Like wtf. Let’s sign daicos then. Maybe I should change my ways and just say to sign every good player. Bruh you guys lol

 

[blackbelair]

If JUH is available, I'd certainly be thinking about it. Though we have this year to see if Logan can take another step, McLean can maintain his good form, and Amartey can play out most of a season.

If players are "flogs" for leaving the club that drafted them, then JPK is a "flog", Ted Richards, Buddy, Paul Williams, Jolly, Ball, Nick Davis, Shaw, Mattner etc are all "flogs" (most of whom played key roles in Swans flags). Then we've just brought in a bunch of "flogs" in the off season.

Trading is part of the game, players decide to leave clubs for various reasons, that's it.

So you’ve missed the point. My Q to you is do we need this “flog”? Are you not happy with what we got? Like where is the faith from our swanny supporters. I’m honestly confused. How 1 bloke asks 2 stupid Q’s with no answers / input and I’m being targeted here for not wanting a shit player in my eyes. Gees let’s add blue to our strip colours and just be the dogs lmao

 

[blackbelair]

joeyjojo, is that you? Which pub this time?

Not him, but I wish. Let’s have a drink?

 

[blackbelair]

Also

If JUH is available, I'd certainly be thinking about it. Though we have this year to see if Logan can take another step, McLean can maintain his good form, and Amartey can play out most of a season.

If players are "flogs" for leaving the club that drafted them, then JPK is a "flog", Ted Richards, Buddy, Paul Williams, Jolly, Ball, Nick Davis, Shaw, Mattner etc are all "flogs" (most of whom played key roles in Swans flags). Then we've just brought in a bunch of "flogs" in the off season.

Trading is part of the game, players decide to leave clubs for various reasons, that's it.

Also not “players” we are talking about one person here so don’t change my words. Obs teams trade etc so this is just invalid. YOURE missing the point.

 

[Bloods86]

So you’ve missed the point. My Q to you is do we need this “flog”? Are you not happy with what we got? Like where is the faith from our swanny supporters. I’m honestly confused. How 1 bloke asks 2 stupid Q’s with no answers / input and I’m being targeted here for not wanting a s**t player in my eyes. Gees let’s add blue to our strip colours and just be the dogs lmao

I don't think JUH is a flog, he's a good young player on the rise, there's nothing to suggest he's of poor character as far as I know.

It's entirely possible to think we could challenge for a flag with the list we have (which I do), but also think there are areas that could improve, especially given the injury reliability and age of some players, including 2 of the key forwards on our list.

It's entirely possible to say that you don't think our forward line would be improved with JUH, who you don't rate, without calling into question the loyalty of other fans who have different opinions about player quality, calling other fans flogs, or saying they ask dumb questions.

Anyway, Go Swans, I'll leave it there.

 

[Bloods86]

Also

Also not “players” we are talking about one person here so don’t change my words. Obs teams trade etc so this is just invalid. YOURE missing the point.

Fair enough, but you said players leaving clubs raises alarm bells, and you didn't give any other reason as to why you're sledging him.

 

[Dubai Quacker]

Bear & Bandicoot anyone?

 

[Bloods86]

Bear & Bandicoot anyone?

There, will be Bloods(86)

 

[tombomb]

1. He is not even a good player.
2. He is young. We already have many young forwards WHO are even better than this flog.
3. Our team is already solid without him - have some faith.
4. He definitely is not a “blood”.
5. I don’t know why we would even need him in the first place?!
6. Waste of money.
7. Now that bud is gone, our boys can step up.
8. Why is he even leaving his club where he got chosen / drafted - to me that is alarm bells in its self.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but you are so wrong about Ugle-Hagan not being good.

If he isn't good, we don't have any good key forwards on our list because he is better than all of them.

 

[Bloods86]

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but you are so wrong about Ugle-Hagan not being good.

If he isn't good, we don't have any good key forwards on our list because he is better than all of them.

I think he's probably on par for impact with McLean in their good games this year, but he's younger so will pass him. Amartey has talent, but his body holds him back, so we can't really compare. Versus Logan I agree at this point, and he's younger, but without Buddy (as the other guy said), I hope he thrives on being one of the main targets going forward.

 

[rustycrate]

Bear & Bandicoot anyone?

To qualify as another Bear & Bandicoot there are prerequisites
1. The protagonist has to be a non Swan
2. The protagonist has to be seemingly inebriated
3. There has to be threats of physical violence at a named location at a specified time

This is just a Bruh Ha.

 

[caesar88]

I have been civil. I’ve answered all questions directed at myself after expressing my thoughts with little to nothing from the other guy. Not sure how this is directed at me, is it because I’m talking the truth and actually believing in what we have and what I strongly belief. Instead maybe see what I’m saying after stating positive things about our club instead of “wanting” to sign another player who in my opinion (may be wrong) that we do not need. If we needed him we would have chased him. Don’t you see what we have or are you too not happy in what we have. Everyone is now attacking me for nothing but love for my club and believing in what we have is good enough. Like wtf. Let’s sign daicos then. Maybe I should change my ways and just say to sign every good player. Bruh you guys lol

I've bolded the exact point in the exchange where you stopped being civil.

Jamarra would fit in beautifully in that photo

No he wouldn’t

And why would that be?

1. He is not even a good player.
2. He is young. We already have many young forwards WHO are even better than this flog.
3. Our team is already solid without him - have some faith.
4. He definitely is not a “blood”.
5. I don’t know why we would even need him in the first place?!
6. Waste of money.
7. Now that bud is gone, our boys can step up.
8. Why is he even leaving his club where he got chosen / drafted - to me that is alarm bells in its self.

He's be our best forward why couldn't he be a blood?

Why's he a flog?

1. You think he’s better than what we have?
And on that, we’ve been good (clearly) making the GF plus close last year without him. How are you so fascinated by this “flog” - honestly?

2. Look at him. How come he wants to leave dogs?

3. Do you even follow the swans?

As for your views, there's absolutely nothing wrong with landing on either side of the 'trade' debate. It just doesn't need to go from 0 to 100 as soon as someone disagrees with you.