List Mgmt. 2024 List Management Part 2 📃

[Arr0w]

Either would be a good pick up as a DFA.

I'd be shocked if Foster doesn't get picked up by another club. Cats have a good crop of young talls coming through. They of course picked up Mitch Edwards in last year's draft, so I reckon Foster has been squeezed out. Still only 20yo and looked good at times at VFL level as a forward, but can play forward/ruck.

I agree, Foster will get another gig

 

[Red_man2008]

1 good finals win is a very very narrow view! However, I’d also say that they were a Max Holmes hamstring away from another GF and, every chance, another flag… on top of that I’d say they were nowhere near their best on Saturday night and still got within two goals of the GF.

They also brought in NSM Isaac Smith as a free agent and picked up a top 10 in comp player at pick 40. Close and Dempsey via Rookie and Miers with a very late selection in the draft. They do many things well.

Considering how long we’ve been rebuilding, their performance shits all over us. Their small-medium forwards are miles ahead of us and they have very few players who flinch (unlike our Gov, among others).

Selling Bruhn and O Henry short imo. Both projecting to be guns.

10 years (20+ years?) into a rebuild, we should be smoking the Cats by now and yet, here we are.

Im pretty sure we did smoke them at the G this year. Coaching masterclass.

 

[carlton_99]

Jon Ralph reporting on Carlton/North Melbourne chase for Houston

https://archive.is/kXFWY

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

If we are able to secure Gold Coast’s pick 12 for our future first and get Houston I think that’s a great result for us!! Really want us to keep our pick 11

 

[carlton_99]

If we are able to secure Gold Coast’s pick 12 for our future first and get Houston I think that’s a great result for us!! Really want us to keep our pick 11

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

 

[Robbo's my hero]

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

Do you think that would be North Melbourne’s pitch to Dan Houston and Port Adelaide? You can rely on us being shite again.

 

[carlton_99]

Do you think that would be North Melbourne’s pitch to Dan Houston and Port Adelaide? You can rely on us being shite again.

Not the best strategy ofc but in the end Houston hasn't nominated a club of choice and has said he is happy to stay with Port if a deal can't get done. Could all just be talk but gives Port all the power to get the best possible deal.

 

[manang magoos]

Membrey is an unrestricted free agent
I’d be all for grabbing him for 1-2 years, provides a contest and is great over head. More durable than JMartin (recognise not the same player)

Membreys uncle was and still might be a Blues supporter so getting Tim would make a heap of sense according to some previous comments about players on here

 

[Robbo's my hero]

Not the best strategy ofc but in the end Houston hasn't nominated a club of choice and has said he is happy to stay with Port if a deal can't get done. Could all just be talk but gives Port all the power to get the best possible deal.

Yeah but it’s funny thinking North could be that bad again.

 

[JJBagger]

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

He could still nominate Carlton if he can guarantee a deal gets done

 

[manang magoos]

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

Why in the hell would he want to go to the Roos

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

Membreys uncle was and still might be a Blues supporter so getting Tim would make a heap of sense according to some previous comments about players on here

Riley Beveridge was saying on gettable a few weeks ago, that we was interested in Membrey at the end of last year.

 

[DEliades]

Lol - playing at marvel and Tassie over the famous navy blue. You’d have to have rocks in your head

 

[Arr0w]

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

Surely it would be a swap of 1st rounders. Can't see North giving up a top 6-8 pick

 

[4flagsin5yrs]

Riley Beveridge was saying on gettable a few weeks ago, that we was interested in Membrey at the end of last year.

Prefer this guy...

Struggling to get a game at Port...

Ollie Lord | AFL

Follow Ollie Lord's progress through AFL

www.portadelaidefc.com.au

 

[carlton_99]

Surely it would be a swap of 1st rounders. Can't see North giving up a top 6-8 pick

Does say a trade including their future first so you may be right

 

[Benaly28]

North offering their future first which could be a top 3 pick. Going to be hard to beat that offer

North ain’t finishing bottom 3 next year.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[reubsblues]

I'd rather take a punt on Joel smith than membery 2 yrs younger and accurate kick for goal

 

[manang magoos]

I'd rather take a punt on Joel smith than membery 2 yrs younger and accurate kick for goal

Joel Smith’s future in game still to be decided I hope we stay well away from this

 

[branedotorg]

I'd rather take a punt on Joel smith than membery 2 yrs younger and accurate kick for goal

Hmm, may not be free to play for 18-24 months, toxic family, involved in WADA and WorkSafe investigations at Melbourne.

Hard no from me

 

[HarryFlashman]

Why in the hell would he want to go to the Roos

they aren’t going to be shit forever, top tier coach, contract length, $$$, some great young talent, given they may pay overs he looks after the club he’s leaving too.
Theres plenty of reasons, god only knows which ones matter to him.

 

[Michael Jezz]

If we are able to secure Gold Coast’s pick 12 for our future first and get Houston I think that’s a great result for us!! Really want us to keep our pick 11

Houston for next years first is a disaster. A HBF we don't need.

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

Houston for next years first is a disaster. A HBF we don't need.

A disaster?

 

[Beyond Blue]

Ryan is 27 and an electric player. The most I’d give up is a future 2nd rounder for him.

Membrey no more than 4th rounder. He could be a solid medium fwd.

The time to pick Liam Ryan was 7 years ago when he was kicking goals for fun playing for Subiaco but alas SOS and his team didn’t really bother looking further than the local underage competitions, and still managed to fcuk up most of their high draft picks. That said if we did pick up Ryan he would immediately be the best small forward we’ve had since Eddie Betts. I’ve said it a few but I’m not sure he’d enjoy living in Melbourne playing for high profile club.

Membrey works his arse off and would support Harry and Charlie. That said I’d rather have Jack SOS doing that role.