Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Was about to say, TDK is still a goer for those who think Keeler and heath are either out the door or our of favour for any particular reason.

List would be unbalanced if we got rid of talls and didn't replace some of them, and we've not really had a CHF since Roo left us.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I don’t mind keeping Ro and all the off field stuff etc included. But it then makes me question the TDK offer. Two rucks just don’t work we have seen it with Melbourne and Freo. We were lucky that Paddy Ryder was an elite footballer that made it work I don’t think Ro and TDK combo has the same dynamic they both are number 1 ruck types.
Roma's drop in form this season is one of the reasons our midfield is probably the least effective in the league. If he is carrying an injury, then they need to get him right over summer, but we need an extra ruck who can do forward work- either get TDK, or put work into Heath or Dodson
 
I shouldn't have to explain this, but tony is clearly a port plant, it's their MO. Jason Cripps ring a bell? when this is all said and done they better release the milera files
 

Remove this Banner Ad

The reason we have to move Steele and Marshall is so we can recoup draft assets - if we roll out the same team as this year with inclusions being TDK (being less useful alongside Marshall), a questionable King and an even more questionable Philipou (who has had maybe if we're being very very honest - 3 great games and was playing seconds for a portion of 2024) - we'll get similar results and push for 10th - 12th.

We have to go all in on the rebuild and it starts with moving out more veteran players that could fetch us picks. Back our recruiting and do this properly. No half measures or we won't get to where we need to go.
 
The reason we have to move Steele and Marshall is so we can recoup draft assets - if we roll out the same team as this year with inclusions being TDK (being less useful alongside Marshall), a questionable King and an even more questionable Philipou (who has had maybe if we're being very very honest - 3 great games and was playing seconds for a portion of 2024) - we'll get similar results and push for 10th - 12th.

We have to go all in on the rebuild and it starts with moving out more veteran players that could fetch us a picks.
Only sane take on this forum
 
Tony is a Saintsational legend been on there for years …probably too long like a lot of us 😆
Hope he keeps working at the club….very handy to have an insider.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Apparently we have a 2 year offer on the table for Windy.

Personally would be offering him at least 3 years.
I don’t mind it.
Can’t afford to let any of our kids get too comfortable.
 
Our rebuild is a mess. NWM will.leave in 2 years, what's the point.
Nah all too obvious.
Let's start, how are we going to play TDK and Roh in the same team? How do we develop Heath and Dodson?
How do we get draft capital to land Aleer if we don't flick Roh?
Should keep us going until end of August.
How do we get an extra 1st RDP to also draft Jevan Phillipou?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top