List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

[Aphrodite]

 

[Bfevola]

Will we sign Flynn Young. I hope so.

 

[JoeyPBLUES]

Will we sign Flynn Young. I hope so.

I want to see Flynn after a full pre-season on the list & another pre-season into Willy White - love these kids. Have made it the hard way & done well.

 

[ferrisb]

McGovern has been on our list for 7 years? Wow!

It's like that famous saying goes.... Time flies when you're playing inconsistent, often injured football...

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

There's almost no body of evidence to support this view.

His limited success at the stoppage kicked in as a replacement for Cerra.

We hope, but need to be realistic about his impact being late season when games slow down.

While he finally improved his field kicking, his injury history is not great, and I question his value in defensive read and transition despite putting the kilometres in.

Hopefully the club have identified how to help with that in terms of training loads and squad and role rotation in the tougher runs of games that now crop up in the fixture.

Agree on Lord and Evans, still a wait and see for now despite promising signs.

Cottrell however was one of our best players in our 2023 finals series. You don't star in big games like that and not be 'AFL quality'.

 

[dangertroy]

Wonder if Billy Dowling from Adelaide will look for more opportunities, or if he’s content as the Crow’s >24th player.

What will become of Thomson Dow (waiting to see from RFC)?

I haven’t seen much of either of them, but both would be coming to us as midfield depth. Not sure why Dowling would want to leave the minor premiers to become depth for us. Not sure why we would want a player who is depth for a bottom 2 side to come to us. Not to mention the thought of us having a Dow back on the list…

 

[The Bighouse]

I haven’t seen much of either of them, but both would be coming to us as midfield depth. Not sure why Dowling would want to leave the minor premiers to become depth for us. Not sure why we would want a player who is depth for a bottom 2 side to come to us. Not to mention the thought of us having a Dow back on the list…

Dowling has kicked goals and can play up forward. Spot where EH used to be (?).

We are looking for better depth as well..plug & play when/if needed.
TD seems to be very inconsistent, not sure if on output or opportunity (or poor disposal).

 

[JimmyRabbit49]

Agree on Lord and Evans, still a wait and see for now despite promising signs.

Cottrell however was one of our best players in our 2023 finals series. You don't star in big games like that and not be 'AFL quality'.

He started this year really well too and was one of our few players who could lace out a leading forward - really missed

 

[Big Delut]

He started this year really well too and was one of our few players who could lace out a leading forward - really missed

That lowering of the eyes 15-20 metre kick going inside 50 is something we don't have nearly enough of but he has added it into his game brilliantly.

 

[Dramoth]

That lowering of the eyes 15-20 metre kick going inside 50 is something we don't have nearly enough of but he has added it into his game brilliantly.

And he is so tireless.

 

[ctwenty1]

McGovern has been on our list for 7 years? Wow!

It's like that famous saying goes.... Time flies when you're playing inconsistent, often injured football...

I recentgly came across some footage from that game in 2019 against Brisbane when we came back from way back to win it

A lot of familiar names were mentioned eg Brackets, Crippa, Curnow etc

Its been a long time with the core of that list...

 

[TheThunderboltKid]

Thoughts on something like:
Curnow to Sydney
Warner to West Coast
Pick 1 and Silvagni compo to Port
Butters to Blues

With some pick swaps added in.

 

[Jimmae]

He started this year really well too and was one of our few players who could lace out a leading forward - really missed

I wasn't happy with his start at all and his kicking was horrible, another player who was given too much latitude in terms of securing a senior appearance when resuming from injury.

 

[ctwenty1]

Thoughts on something like:
Curnow to Sydney
Warner to West Coast
Pick 1 and Silvagni compo to Port
Butters to Blues

With some pick swaps added in.

I cant see how PA wont match any bid for Butters next year to force a trade

I reckon PA think they can keep him, and if not, will match any offer for him to force the trade

The offer form us this year would need to be more compelling that Pick 1 and an end of Fisrt round - maintain that Butters will be a 3 first round offer, or at least two with a good player maybe a second coming back

In that instance, we would need to throw in a Cerra type

 

[Carltonfc9]

Agree on Lord and Evans, still a wait and see for now despite promising signs.

Cottrell however was one of our best players in our 2023 finals series. You don't star in big games like that and not be 'AFL quality'.

Blake acres says hello. One of our most clutch players yes had a bad year but seems everyone wants him gone, when we are already struggling for "depth"

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Blake acres says hello. One of our most clutch players yes had a bad year but seems everyone wants him gone, when we are already struggling for "depth"

All depends on how his shoulders are imo.

 

[Carltonfc9]

All depends on how his shoulders are imo.

Either way he stays on our list i reckon. He's not on the biggest contract and hes as good as a depth player you could ask for

 

[Aphrodite]

Hi Guys...can you let me know if JSOS and TDK did a lot of ruck work teaming together whilst at Carlton?

Are you in the 'right forum/thread for all the tears' - your words!

 

[Aphrodite]

Kemp has signed a new 2 year contract.

Nothing official from the Club.

 

[The Bighouse]

All depends on how his shoulders are imo.

Reckon the back was more of a hindrance this year.

His kicking got worse, which was hard to fathom as being possible.

 

[DangerousD]

They might have to walk ah chee if that don’t get their assistance package

Not a free agent, West Coast aren’t really that way inclined either, they traded for Brockman when they had pick 1 in the PSD

 

[bigblueboy]

Conflicting information regarding ison some people don't have him in there top 40 then you hear reports he could be a early 2nd rounder, don't think we are going to have a problem with Gresham he looks like a late 3rd rounder

Gresham is rookie material. Doubt he gets selected in the national draft.

 

[Blue and Silver]

Thoughts on something like:
Curnow to Sydney
Warner to West Coast
Pick 1 and Silvagni compo to Port
Butters to Blues

With some pick swaps added in.

In the same way we need to get way overpaid for Curnow, Port need to be way overpaid for Butters.

I just don't see Port accepting anything less than a quality player and two first rounders

 

[sweethoney]

Not a free agent, West Coast aren’t really that way inclined either, they traded for Brockman when they had pick 1 in the PSD

Starcevich I meant got it mixed up

 

[CoachB]

In the same way we need to get way overpaid for Curnow, Port need to be way overpaid for Butters.

I just don't see Port accepting anything less than a quality player and two first rounders

Butters not going anywhere this season, new coach / new head of football trading out their best player??? As has been said elsewhere, groundwork for free agency is all we can hope for atm.

 

[The Bighouse]

Starcevich I meant got it mixed up

And could be fine for both clubs as FA compo will be diluted.