List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

[Aphrodite]

 

[DangerousD]

People need to stop with the, why would anyone want to come with us garbage.

It appears that Essendon in the massive heap they’re in, will still attract Flanders.

Saints have attracted plenty.

Melbourne who are a mess, seem they have players interested.

If we are refusing to overpay, it’s different to, no good player wants to come

 

[sweethoney]

Voss as a player, or any of his team mates would have 110% done it. Voss as a coach letting one of our boys do it, I'm not sure but I'd like to see it

Maybe Newman that’s all I can think of

 

[katmanblue]

Voss as a player, or any of his team mates would have 110% done it. Voss as a coach letting one of our boys do it, I'm not sure but I'd like to see it

Where's Mitch Robinson when you need him?

 

[COACH25]

Would of love to have a crack at Rowan Marshall

19

Rowan Marshall

Age

30

Ht

201cm

Wt

105kg

Pos.

Ruck

Career

Season

Last 5

D

15.4

4star

K

8.8

3star

HB

6.6

4star

CL

3.4

5star

HO

20.2

5star

D

12.9

3star

K

9.3

4star

HB

3.6

2star

CL

2.8

4star

HO

17.8

5star

D

10.6

3star

K

5.8

3star

HB

4.8

4star

CL

1.0

3star

HO

7.8

5star

Saints will be crazy on trading him
Marhsall 2025. TDK
23 games. 22 games
10 goals. 6 goals
427 disposals. 381 disposals
103 marks. 72 marks
107 tackles. 51 tackles
627 hit outs 512 hit outs
SI 6.4 SI 4.7

 

[macky99]

Would of love to have a crack at Rowan Marshall
Saints will be crazy on trading him
Marhsall 2025. TDK
23 games. 22 games
10 goals. 6 goals
427 disposals. 381 disposals
103 marks. 72 marks
107 tackles. 51 tackles
627 hit outs 512 hit outs
SI 6.4 SI 4.7

Geelong attract good players he will be good for them.

 

[Red Bull]

Sounds like :

Curnow > Sydney 1st + F1 + Hayward.

I’d like to work Dattoli into the trade somehow but concede there are legitimate reasons why Florent may be included despite personally not wanting a bar of him and his 4 year contract.

So then roughly :

Picks 9&10 traded up for a pick to secure Robey.
This guy seriously looks the goods

Pick 19 to mostly secure Dean.

Sydney F1 added to our natural F1 to mostly secure Walker.

Khamis mostly secured with current 2nd we hold.

Chesser, Reidy and Ison mostly secured via future pick upgrades/trades or even some kind of return on Acres and/or McGovern.

Would imagine next season’s trade period we would be armed and dangerous in the FA market

Projecting forward a year or two :

* For the sake of the discussion, let’s put Newman Williams Hewett Saad Haynes Pittonet to the side …

Wilson Weitering Dean
Cowan O’Farrell Chesser
Walsh Cripps Hollands
Robey Kemp Hayward
Moir McKay Motlop

O’Keefe Cerra Smith

Walker Lord Khamis Ison FA?

The forward line has transitioned towards a more modern mobile attack with the possible acquisition of a quality FA to further strengthen this division.

Wilson and Chesser add pace and kicking from defence.

Smith Robey and Walker add the star ️ power !!

Hayward Moir and Ison add polish whilst Khamis plays as a genuine swingman.

Carlton are ready to emerge into a new era … both on and off the field …

 

[marcmurphy3]

Sounds like :

Curnow > Sydney 1st + F1 + Hayward.

I’d like to work Dattoli into the trade somehow but concede there are legitimate reasons why Florent may be included despite personally not wanting a bar of him and his 4 year contract.

So then roughly :

Picks 9&10 traded up for a pick to secure Robey.
This guy seriously looks the goods

Pick 19 to mostly secure Dean.

Sydney F1 added to our natural F1 to mostly secure Walker.

Khamis mostly secured with current 2nd we hold.

Chesser, Reidy and Ison mostly secured via future pick upgrades/trades or even some kind of return on Acres and/or McGovern.

Would imagine next season’s trade period we would be armed and dangerous in the FA market

Projecting forward a year or two :

* For the sake of the discussion, let’s put Newman Williams Hewett Saad Haynes Pittonet to the side …

Wilson Weitering Dean
Cowan O’Farrell Chesser
Walsh Cripps Hollands
Robey Kemp Hayward
Moir McKay Motlop

O’Keefe Cerra Smith

Walker Lord Khamis Ison FA?

The forward line has transitioned towards a more modern mobile attack with the possible acquisition of a quality FA to further strengthen this division.

Wilson and Chesser add pace and kicking from defence.

Smith Robey and Walker add the star ️ power !!

Hayward Moir and Ison add polish whilst Khamis plays as a genuine swingman.

Carlton are ready to emerge into a new era … both on and off the field …

Pretty good.

Only small flaws are, I dont think we can afford to trade 9+10 as a straight swap for a top 3 pick to get Robey. I could see us trading up but need at least a 2nd rounder back for Dean points. Cant rely on pick 20 alone to match bids for Dean and Ison.

Also, not sure we can rely on our F1 and Sydney's F1 alone to match Walker bid. Probably need another one or to swap for a guaranteed top 5 F1 (WestCoast)

 

[Red Bull]

Pretty good.

Only small flaws are, I dont think we can afford to trade 9+10 as a straight swap for a top 3 pick to get Robey. I could see us trading up but need at least a 2nd rounder back for Dean points. Cant rely on pick 20 alone to match bids for Dean and Ison.

Also, not sure we can rely on our F1 and Sydney's F1 alone to match Walker bid. Probably need another one or to swap for a guaranteed top 5 F1 (WestCoast)

Cheers mate
It is just a bit of a rough roadmap going forward ?
I’m very keen to add Smith Robey and Walker to the mix.
We can always trade some 2017 currency forward if we need some extra to make it work …

 

[marcmurphy3]

Cheers mate
It is just a bit of a rough roadmap going forward ?
I’m very keen to add Smith Robey and Walker to the mix.
We can always trade some 2017 currency forward if we need some extra to make it work …

The dream is that bidding changes are pushed back. Would massively increase our ability to trade up or grab a guy like Humphrey. AFL needs to confirm asap.

 

[Michael Jezz]

If we get an additional "A" grader to Dean whether its pick 2 or the Humphrey, Butters fairy tale and pay for walker and Ison...this draft/ trade is a win. That is my benchmark

 

[Aphrodite]

People need to stop with the, why would anyone want to come with us garbage.

It appears that Essendon in the massive heap they’re in, will still attract Flanders.

Saints have attracted plenty.

Melbourne who are a mess, seem they have players interested.

If we are refusing to overpay, it’s different to, no good player wants to come

Not happening :-

 

[The Bighouse]

If we get an additional "A" grader to Dean whether its pick 2 or the Humphrey, Butters fairy tale and pay for walker and Ison...this draft/ trade is a win. That is my benchmark

Charlie in or out?

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Hypothetical
Syd/GC - Rowbottom & 10 for Rosas & 7

Syd/Carlton - 7, F1, Hayward & Florent for Charlie

 

[Michael Jezz]

Charlie in or out?

Charlie Out..

 

[Gointocarlton]

Not happening :-

Gonna have to change their name to $t Kilda.

 

[circusdevil]

When do we sign Harry Charleson? Must keep him!

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Where's Mitch Robinson when you need him?

Cotters is the man for this job

 

[DangerousD]

Not happening :-

Saints and Demons are terrible, but still can attract players, we can too

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Monahan one extra year

Kerry’s Rob Monahan signs one-year contract extension with Carlton Blues in the AFL

Former Kerry underage footballer Rob Monahan has agreed a new one-year contract with the Carlton Blues that will keep him at the Melbourne-based Australian Rules club for at least a third season in 2026.

m.independent.ie

 

[Michael Jezz]

Saints and Demons are terrible, but still can attract players, we can too

As Keith Mckenzie, barrassi asst coach, once told me it is charisma and personality that attracts players. St. Kilda can roll out Lyon and SoS. Carlton have no one with Charisma. Voss has lost the lustre and Priestley has not got it. Dam pity Priestley couldn't see past self interest and accept Fitzpatrick in the interest of the club

 

[swuzzlebubble]

SoS

charisma

 

[macky99]

As Keith Mckenzie, barrassi asst coach, once told me it is charisma and personality that attracts players. St. Kilda can roll out Lyon and SoS. Carlton have no one with Charisma. Voss has lost the lustre and Priestley has not got it. Dam pity Priestley couldn't see past self interest and accept Fitzpatrick in the interest of the club.

lt looks more like Wright is trying to reset the list & free up cap space for the following year and bring in young talent.

Saints are massively overpaying players to bring them up. $ is the reason

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Monahan one extra year

Kerry’s Rob Monahan signs one-year contract extension with Carlton Blues in the AFL

Former Kerry underage footballer Rob Monahan has agreed a new one-year contract with the Carlton Blues that will keep him at the Melbourne-based Australian Rules club for at least a third season in 2026.

m.independent.ie

Interesting re-signing. That fills our Cat B quota for 2026 along with Duffy, so we'd have to take Clark and possibly Gresham on the senior or Cat A rookie list if we were to select them.

Monahan is an interesting one. Totally out of his depth in his first year, but in 2025 showed a lot of improvement to the point that he actually looked like an AFL player at state league level. Definitely not against him getting another year, although it will be a make or break assignment.

 

[The Bighouse]

Interesting re-signing. That fills our Cat B quota for 2026 along with Duffy, so we'd have to take Clark and possibly Gresham on the senior or Cat A rookie list if we were to select them.

Monahan is an interesting one. Totally out of his depth in his first year, but in 2025 showed a lot of improvement to the point that he actually looked like an AFL player at state league level. Definitely not against him getting another year, although it will be a make or break assignment.

A bonus if we get AFL quality out of Monahan & Duffy (assuming only on his 2nd year in ‘26?).

Monahan can hopefully return forward with a bit more nous about the game..

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

A bonus if we get AFL quality out of Monahan & Duffy (assuming only on his 2nd year in ‘26?).

Monahan can hopefully return forward with a bit more nous about the game..

Not sure about Duffy's status. We signed him along with Monahan, but of course he did his knee in the Gaelic Football final and missed 2024, so not sure if that was technically the first year of his contract or 2025....although I would assume 2025 was the first year.

Our comms dept are pretty ordinary with communicating this stuff - they're more concerned about nice fluffy pieces to keep us all happy and joyous. It's pathetic that the first we hear about Monahan's re-signing is via an Irish newspaper.