Remove this Banner Ad

VFL 2025 Swans Reserves

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Last edited:
Umps have single handedly cause a 4 goal swing with some of these shocking calls

Rubbish.

We have gone back to being a rabble.

That last Southport goal was attributable to our wingers not bothering to run back & left an opponent free inside 50.

The Corey Warner goal disallowed was poor - but we’ve been abysmal.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Rubbish.

We haven’t gone back to being a rabble.

That last Southport goal was attributable to our wingers not bothering to run back & left an opponent free inside 50.

The Corey Warner goal disallowed was poor - but we’ve been abysmal.
Snell has conceded 3 goals from horrific FKs, Warner incorrect goal

The chaos caused by the umps not controlling the physicality has caused it.

Its bloody obvious to anyone watching the game
 
Maybe watch the game not the stats sheet.

Umps have lost control of this game and caused it
I have watched the game thanks

Why do you always act like your opinion is fact? **** off
 
I have watched the game thanks

Why do you always act like your opinion is fact? **** off
I haven't acted like that at all mate. You just have basically no ability to associate how the umpiring differential is causing chaos.

Yes Sydney has played poorly but that is majority caused by these umps.

Chopping of the arms in transition happened multiple times but isn't called then a TO happens and Southport would kick a goal in transition. Let alone the direct goals the umps have caused
 
I haven't acted like that at all mate. You just have basically no ability to associate how the umpiring differential is causing chaos.

Yes Sydney has played poorly but that is majority caused by these umps.

Chopping of the arms in transition happened multiple times but isn't called then a TO happens and Southport would kick a goal in transition. Let alone the direct goals the umps have caused
You act like it constantly, I see it all the time. You’re often rude as ****.

The ball got to the Snell contests exactly how genius? Because we are being beaten across the ground.

I have a different opinion to you. Don’t tell me to watch the game. FO.
 
I think two things can be true at once. Umpires absolutely turned the match. No one watching this objectively could deny they're clearly favouring Southport for whatever reason.

But from there, we dropped our bundle massively. The umpiring was just as bad in the first quarter but we kept at it and overcame it, showing that it's possible with a bit of grit and skill execution. Couldn't back it up a second go round.

Just disappointing entirely
 
I haven't acted like that at all mate. You just have basically no ability to associate how the umpiring differential is causing chaos.

Yes Sydney has played poorly but that is majority caused by these umps.

Chopping of the arms in transition happened multiple times but isn't called then a TO happens and Southport would kick a goal in transition. Let alone the direct goals the umps have caused

Sorry, but telling one of the most respected posters here that he has “no ability to associate” and needs to “watch the game not the stats sheet” is just making you look like a complete dill.
 
You act like it constantly, I see it all the time. You’re often rude as ****.

The ball got to the Snell contests exactly how genius? Because we are being beaten across the ground.

I have a different opinion to you. Don’t tell me to watch the game. FO.
The ball got to Snell because the ump wouldn't call FKs for contests on the wing with push in the back and also Chopping of the arms.

If you can't see the rules for some but not for all then thats on you
 
Lacking of winning culture has heavily affected the 2s this year. In the hunt then the heads drop and we concede a run of goals, happens almost every week these uphill battles

Cleary is enjoyable to watch especially in the guts
It is clearly a leadership issue where there is an inability to stem the momentum flow against us.
In the past few weeks it's happened it's fair top say the lack of experience was the main culprit.
But today we have Florent, Warner, Lloyd, Ladhams, Paton, all players with regular senior experience that should all know what is required in such circumstances, especially in a lower grade where their experience is magnified.

I see players that are concerned about their own situation rather than finding form as part of a team & building from there.
this has not been a good second quarter.
It's a disease within where we fold easy & allow multiple unanswered goals against us. Seniors & Reserves.
Not sure what the answer is other than to bring in coaches with a winning mentality & also players that have some 4 quarter fight.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

More concerned about the development of players than winning games.

Kirk and Paton having been worst on ground

Green looks to be being held back from Crossley

Cleary Florent and Lloyd have been great

Hamling has been great

Outside of that been a horrific watch
 
The ball got to Snell because the ump wouldn't call FKs for contests on the wing with push in the back and also Chopping of the arms.

If you can't see the rules for some but not for all then thats on you
13 frees apiece.
18 players for each team on the ground at one time.
This is not an umpiring issue causing us grief.
It's a ball in hand for us issue & a ball in the oppositions hands issue.
We have no system or belief in the gameplan.
It causes players to not work hard enough.
Top of the list to the bottom.
 
McVeigh moves the magnets after what Hardwick did in that Essendon game and an Andrews gets a goal
 
Andrew looks like he forgot where his man is and concedes it right back
 
More concerned about the development of players than winning games.

Kirk and Paton having been worst on ground

Green looks to be being held back from Crossley

Cleary Florent and Lloyd have been great

Hamling has been great

Outside of that been a horrific watch

Not surprising by your list analysis the AFL standard players are performing well the speculative players in Kirk and Paton are struggling.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Ladhams concedes a HTB because he should have been able to break the tackle even though he didn't have prior. Horrific call again.

Almost caused a chain of events which should have caused a Southport Goal
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom