2026 Trade / FA Thread

[gouki88]

Nice idea. I might call him schnooky. Or maybe schmoopie.

I did like that name from some reality show from years back, the bloke who called himself "The Situation".

 

[sideswipe]

What a great name. I know nothing else about him. My sporting nickname should have been The Disintegration.

 

[Apex36]

Umm? More money?
Maybe you should be asking why your club is trying to re-sign him right now on bigger money, then try to figure out why he's refusing.

They were due to the threat of Tassie, but that seems to have died off. Why is he refusing? Likely because we aren’t offering a payrise, just an extension. He’s already our highest paid player, he knows that in order to be in a successful club you need to have money in the kitty to attract talent from elsewhere.

Geelong re-signed Bailey Smith recently on bigger money even though he was already signed long term.

This is the nature of the industry.

Bailey Smith was woefully underpaid for his level of talent. Nick is not.

 

[Apex36]

Umm, Collingwood is offering Daicos roughly $2m a year for 9 years. It's highly unlikely he would get an offer much bigger than that.
The only scenario where that's "less money" now would be if he was considering Tasmania for the huge sign-on bonus.

And even if your conjecture was correct, that there's less money being offered now, so what? Contracts can be re-negotiated at any time. I raise the Bailey Smith example again; signed long-term upon but still got a payrise a year later.

Calling bullshit, that hasn’t been reported anywhere I’ve seen.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Last time I checked he was having a statistically better season than his last Brownlow year.

And Wells was a perfectly legitimate gamble too. Probably would have won us the 2018 flag if not for an unfortunate traumatic injury. Just because a gamble doesn’t come off, doesn’t mean it was the wrong move.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Wouldn't you rather almost acquire Merrett?

I laugh at those who question offering a 33yo Neale three years, but don’t bat an eyelid at offering a 31yo-to-be in Merrett the same to come to the Hawks in addition to having to cough up a reported 1st and 2nd round pick while Neale only costs cap.

 

[gouki88]

I laugh at those who question offering a 33yo Neale three years, but don’t bat at eyelid at offering a 31yo-to-be in Merrett the same to come to the Hawks in addition to having to cough up a reported 1st and 2nd round pick while Neale only costs cap.

And he's worse than Neale to begin with!

 

[granniewolf]

They were due to the threat of Tassie, but that seems to have died off. Why is he refusing? Likely because we aren’t offering a payrise, just an extension. He’s already our highest paid player, he knows that in order to be in a successful club you need to have money in the kitty to attract talent from elsewhere.

Bailey Smith was woefully underpaid for his level of talent. Nick is not.

I thought Bailey Smith took a paycut just so he could get to Geelong. Seems that has now been rectified.

 

[Harry O]

I try very hard not to be.
Many will throw it out there just because they don’t like negativity however it’s not my intention to just be all doom and gloom for the sake or it —and many are passing it off as such but I do not enjoy it
I have been around here a long time and this is the first time I have genuinely believed we haven’t got a good handle on the wheel

At least we know what you have your handle on

 

[Hardas]

Honestly don't want to invest the reported money in King.
Rather put big money into mids - this year or next.
If Butters truly is out of reach, as has long seemed likely, then Neale, Ballard, a second-tier fwd like Gruzewski & a mid in this year's draft?
Then continue chasing another top mid like Rowell for next year.

 

[sr36]

Honestly don't want to invest the reported money in King.
Rather put big money into mids - this year or next.
If Butters truly is out of reach, as has long seemed likely, then Neale, Ballard, a second-tier fwd like Gruzewski & a mid in this year's draft?
Then continue chasing another top mid like Rowell for next year.

Gruzewski is just another bit below par tallish forward to add to our collection of them. Pass on him.

 

[Hardas]

Gruzewski is just another bit below par tallish forward to add to our collection of them. Pass on him.

I just used him as an example.
Whoever we get needs to be a decent contested mark/ kick for goal, and/or a decent second ruck fwd.
Buller is neither.

 

[Ugene41]

You just know with King, if he was to come to Collingwood, that he will start kicking like Cloke and become a 30 goal 50 behind forward

 

[sr36]

I just used him as an example.
Whoever we get needs to be a decent contested mark/ kick for goal, and/or a decent second ruck fwd.
Buller is neither.

Unless it's King or a high ceiling kid like Walter - I want Darcy Moore to play centre bounce ruck and then move forward and West to be backed in.

Round 1 forward line:

Moore McStay West Elliott* Hill McCreery Schultz.

* The oldies for some unknown reason seem to come back quicker from ACLs than youngsters do.

 

[gouki88]

Unless it's King or a high ceiling kid like Walter - I want Darcy Moore to play centre bounce ruck and then move forward and West to be backed in.

Round 1 forward line:

Moore McStay West Elliott* Hill McCreery Schultz.

* The oldies for some unknown reason seem to come back quicker from ACLs than youngsters do.

Moore playing as a kind of super Steene would be awesome

 

[Go Woods]

Umm, Collingwood is offering Daicos roughly $2m a year for 9 years. It's highly unlikely he would get an offer much bigger than that.
The only scenario where that's "less money" now would be if he was considering Tasmania for the huge sign-on bonus.

And even if your conjecture was correct, that there's less money being offered now, so what? Contracts can be re-negotiated at any time. I raise the Bailey Smith example again; signed long-term upon but still got a payrise a year later.

Yeah ok, I'm actually involved with the negotiations and we're trying to get a Villa in Europe thrown in.......FM.

 

[manicpie]

You just know with King, if he was to come to Collingwood, that he will start kicking like Cloke and become a 30 goal 50 behind forward

That's why I'm not sure on him

 

[ZEV]

And Wells was a perfectly legitimate gamble too. Probably would have won us the 2018 flag if not for an unfortunate traumatic injury. Just because a gamble doesn’t come off, doesn’t mean it was the wrong move.

Wellsy played 15 games, we only lost 3 times when he played.

He was such a gun and looked a class above everyone on our list at the time.

 

[peter9789]

You just know with King, if he was to come to Collingwood, that he will start kicking like Cloke and become a 30 goal 50 behind forward

Or he will be perenially injured like his brother

 

[Dtennent94]

And he's worse than Neale to begin with!

Has Merrett ever been injured though? Can’t remember him ever being injured.

 

[GreekLunatic]

So if we give Neale 3 years does that mean lions get better compensation by afl

 

[Apex36]

So if we give Neale 3 years does that mean lions get better compensation by afl

Maybe, but it’s unlikely they’ll get anything beyond a band 3 compo.

 

[Jen2310]

So if we give Neale 3 years does that mean lions get better compensation by afl

so best case for them would be a pick in the late 30s

 

[Horaceg]

Wellsy played 15 games, we only lost 3 times when he played.

He was such a gun and looked a class above everyone on our list at the time.

Agree, the game he hurt himself was some of his best, it was an impact injury that got him, not a soft tissue so can’t blame age, just sh1t luck.

 

[gouki88]

Has Merrett ever been injured though? Can’t remember him ever being injured.

Only a broken hand from memory