The only play I would say is a conclusively better player than Boomer from that list is Ablett jnr. Everyone else you can find other players that play the exact same role. The impact and uniqueness of Harvey's style of play and effectiveness per possession is not matched nor could be replicated by any other player on that list.
I loved Boomer, but seriously this is bonkers.
Judd - One of the best midfielders to ever play. I don’t rate the Brownlow, but people keep referencing to Boomer coming 2nd and 6th. This guy won 2 over that era.
Franklin - The best forward since Carey. He is about to kick 1000 goals ffs.
Cox - The best ruckman I have ever seen. He was irreplaceable during his era and changed the game as a ruckman.
Scarlett - Best full back I have ever seen. Again changed the game as a full back. He was a stopper, but was also an offensive weapon. To say he was replaceable is beyond insane.
Pavlich - Probably one of the most versatile players to ever play the game at an elite level across all positions. Good luck replacing that easily.
I could go on with the others, but I think you get the point.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com