Competitions AFC Board Draft Game 2017 Thread...

[1990crow]

Rams FC

FB: Grant Birchall ~ Steven May ~ Matt Scharenberg
HB: Nathan Wilson ~ Daniel Talia ~ Marley Williams
C: Jaeger O’Meara ~ Dustin Martin ~ Jack Newnes
HF: Lewis Taylor ~ Tom Hawkins ~ Jake Melksham
FF: Brandon Matera ~ Peter Wright ~ Mark LeCras
R: Stefan Martin ~ Stephen Coniglio ~ Scott Selwood
Bench: Jackson Thurlow ~ Lachie Weller ~ Sam Gibson ~ Karl Amon

Emergency: Dale Thomas, Mark Hutchings, Adam Cerra, Paul Ahern, Lyndenn Dunn, Sam Wright, Dawson Simpson, Lukas Webb

 

[hendo8888]

Good job all. Finished before New Year's.

 

[Scorpus]

Is Menzel rated as a KPF? That’s pretty surprising.

No

 

[Scorpus]

Here is my undeniably very good high quality team

B Luke Hodge - Joel Hamling - Dylan Grimes
HB Shaun Burgoyne - Jackson Trengove - Jarrad McVeigh
C Matthew Suckling - Callan Ward (c) - Isaac Smith
HF Dayne Zorko - James Stewart - Richard Douglas
F Jake Stringer - Tom McDonald - Eddie Betts
R Zac Smith - Marcus Bontempelli - David Mundy
I Alex Neal-Bullen - Liam Duggan - Dale Morris - Tim O'Brien

E Kamdyn McIntosh - Nick Robertson - Sam Gilbert - Jack Bowes
E Jackson Nelson - Matt Rosa - Ed Langdon - Daniel Nielson

Coach: Ross Lyon

11 players disloyal is a decent result too

 

[Danger Zone]

The Three-Eyed Ravens in all their glory.

B Neville Jetta - Liam Jones - Lachie Plowman
HB Daniel Rich - Alex Rance - Jasper Pittard
C Aaron Hall - Dayne Beams (C) - Lewis Jetta
HF Shaun Higgins - Justin Westhoff - Will Hoskin-Elliott
F Dan Butler - Levi Casboult - Jarman Impey
R Ben McEvoy - Joel Selwood (VC) - Seb Ross
I Ryan Griffen - Jimmy Webster - Jy Simpkin - David Mackay

E Will Langford - Sam Frost - Jordan Murdoch - Jonathan Ceglar - Kyle Langford - Nathan Broad - Wylie Buzza - Luke Partington

 

[Hank93]

Final team

FF: C. Cameron, H. Himmelberg, J. Gresham
HF: R.Knight, T. Membrey, H. McCluggage
C: S. Menegola, R. Sloane, P. Seedsman
HB: B. Houli, J.Kolodjashnij, E. Yeo
FB: D. Roberton, D.Astbury, R. Laird
R: P. Ryder, T. Rockliff, S. Powell-Pepper
IC: K. Jack, P. Dow, A Brayshaw (Frem), D. Towers

Emergencies: I. Soldo, S. Kerridge, S. Durdin
The Rest: Z. Guthrie, D. Myers, R. Bonner, J. Lonie, T. Broomhead

1 (6): Rory Sloane (Adelaide)
2 (31): Paddy Ryder (Port Adelaide)
3 (42): Rory Laird (Adelaide)
4 (67): Elliot Yeo (West Coast Eagles)
5 (78): Tom Rockliff (Port Adelaide)
6 (103): Dylan Roberton (St Kilda)
7 (114): Tim Membrey (St Kilda)
8 (139): Bachar Houli (Richmond)
9 (150): Charlie Cameron (Brisbane Lions)
10 (175): Sam Menegola (Geelong)
11 (186): Sam Powell-Pepper (Port Adelaide)
12 (211): Jade Gresham (St Kilda)
13 (222): David Astbury (Richmond)
14 (247): Paul Seedsman (Adelaide)
15: (258): Kieren Jack (Sydney Swans):
16 (283): Harrison Himmelberg (GWS Giants)
17 (294): Jake Kolodjashnij (Geelong)
18 (319): Riley Knight (Adelaide)
19 (330): Hugh McCluggage (Brisbane Lions)
20 (355): Paddy Dow (Carlton)
21 (366): Andrew Brayshaw (Fremantle)
22 (391): Dean Towers (Sydney)
23 (402): Zach Guthrie (Geelong)
24 (427): Sam Kerridge (Carlton)
25 (438): Sam Durdin (North Melbourne)
26 (463): Ivan Soldo (Richmond)
27 (474): David Myers (Essendon)
28 (499): Riley Bonner (Port Adelaide)
29 (510): Jack Lonie (St Kilda)
30 (535): Tim Broomhead (Collingwood)

 

[Deaneus!]

The Glip-Glops

F: Paul Puopolo ~ Jesse Hogan ~ Jamie Elliott
HF: Jack Watts ~ Shane Kersten ~ Jake Lloyd
C: Jack Crisp ~ Josh Kennedy ~ Bryce Gibbs
HB: Jason Johannisen ~ Zaine Cordy ~ Brendan Goddard
B: Shane Savage ~ Daniel McStay ~ Sam Mayes
R: Nic Naitanui ~ Hugh Greenwood ~ Ryan Bastinac

INT: Matthew Broadbent ~ Ryan Lester ~ Shane Biggs ~ Rhys Mathieson

EMG: Michael Johnson ~ Trent McKenzie ~ Harry Morrison ~ Matthew Lobbe
EMG: Ryan Schoenmakers ~ Brendan Whitecross ~ Harry Cunningham ~ James Aish

Pick 15 - Josh P. Kennedy
Pick 22 - Jesse Hogan
Pick 51 - Nic Naitanui
Pick 58 - Bryce Gibbs
Pick 87 - Jason Johannisen
Pick 94 - Brendon Goddard
Pick 123 - Jamie Elliott
Pick 130 - Sam Mayes
Pick 159 - Jake Lloyd
Pick 166 - Daniel McStay
Pick 195 - Jack Crisp
Pick 202 - Jack Watts
Pick 231 - Ryan Bastinac
Pick 238 - Zaine Cordy
Pick 267 - Hugh Greenwood
Pick 274 - Shane Kersten
Pick 303 - Shane Savage
Pick 310 - Paul Puopolo
Pick 339 - Matthew Broadbent
Pick 346 - Ryan Lester
Pick 375 - Shane Biggs
Pick 382 - Rhys Mathieson
Pick 411 - Michael Johnson
Pick 418 - Trent McKenzie
Pick 447 - Harry Morrison
Pick 454 - Matthew Lobbe
Pick 483 - Ryan Schoenmakers
Pick 490 - Brendan Whitecross
Pick 519 - Harry Cunningham
Pick 526 - James Aish

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Final team

B: Dane Rampe - Jack Hombsch - Luke McDonald
HB: Kade Simpson - Lachie Henderson - Tom Cutler
C: Dom Sheed - Dylan Shiel - Jared Polec
HF: Mav Weller - Joe Daniher - Isaac Heeney
F: Luke Breust - Sam Reid - Jamie Cripps
1R: Jordan Roughead - Jack Viney - Taylor Adams
INT: Angus Brayshaw - Adam Kennedy - Koby Stevens - Alex Sexton

EMG:
Taylor Duryea
Harry Perryman
Jaidyn Stephensen
Zac Bailey
Tommy Sheridan

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Final team

B: Dane Rampe - Jack Hombsch - Luke McDonald
HB: Kade Simpson - Lachie Henderson - Tom Cutler
C: Dom Sheed - Dylan Shiel - Jared Polec
HF: Mav Weller - Joe Daniher - Isaac Heeney
F: Luke Breust - Sam Reid - Jamie Cripps
1R: Jordan Roughead - Jack Viney - Taylor Adams
INT: Angus Brayshaw - Adam Kennedy - Koby Stevens - Alex Sexton

EMG:
Taylor Duryea
Harry Perryman
Jaidyn Stephensen
Zac Bailey
Tommy Sheridan

Tough to beat. Great line up

 

[Deaneus!]

Okay, here's my team rankings / top 5 from best to 5th best

5. 1990crow (best)
4. hendo8888
3. FAITH
2. Scorpus
1. Kristof

As for everyone else - there were good teams, and bad teams, but you all tried very hard.

 

[FAITH]

When everyone has time send me their rankings from best to worst

 

[hendo8888]

Do we have a voting system this year? Or do you just want a 1-18 rank?

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Tough to beat. Great line up

Thanks mate

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Time for some more draft reviews

Best value picks Rounds 16 to 20

279 Danger Zone - Liam Jones (Carlton)
It was almost as though we collectively couldn't change our perception of this bloke. We were stuck on 'spud' after his previous seasons of beyond woeful forward line play. Last season Jones proved once again the old adage that 'any hack can be a quality defender because it's so easy' was true. Bargain for Danger Zone here.

286 FAITH - Jake Kelly (Adelaide)
The sort of player you can pencil into the AFC line up for the next decade. Will play his role, sneak into the B&F top 10 at times especially in our poor years and have a solid 200 game career.

287 Danger in Texas - Bailey Dale (Western Bulldogs)
Reckon this bloke is set to go to the next level in 2018. The baby faced talent has shown glimpses but with an extra preseason and some experience behind him is ready to step up. Add in a resurgent Bulldogs in 2018 and I think he'll prove to be a shrewd pick.

290 Danger In Texas - Ed Curnow (Carlton)
Unfashionable but gets it done every year. Taggers coming back into vogue and Gibbs out could see him more prominent in Carlton's line up.

292 hendo8888 - Allen Christensen (Brisbane)
Forgotten player. Has some skill and ex-factor. Will benefit from playing half forward at Brisbane, where no defender will bother picking him up because they're winning by so much. Could slip under the radar and get plenty of touches and goals.

297 Danoz - Bradley Sheppard (West Coast)
A bit like a Jake Kelly. Just a rock solid pick who plays pretty well every game.

298 Danger Zone - Lewis Jetta (West Coast)
Not sure why this bloke hasn't developed into a star. Has the skill, has the speed. Has had some dire seasons. At the end of last season though he finally signaled that perhaps he was going to realise that potential.

309 AdelaideFan14 - Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle)
Turf toe has stopped him in his tracks the last couple of seasons. Still one of the most influential big men in the league when he gets on the park.

323 Danger In Texas - Marcus Adams (Western Bulldogs)
Will settle nicely back into the Bulldogs line up and be a lock for them.

349 Scorpus - Liam Duggan (West Coast)
The Weagles are looking to revamp their midfield and you'd think this guy would get significant minutes.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Botched Picks Round 16 to 20

272 Drugs Are Bad Mackay - Alex Pearce (Fremantle)
Don't usually include my own picks in either the good or bad lists but can't ignore this one. Knew he'd been out injured, didn't realise it had been for so long and with so many complications. Whoops. Bonus if he plays.

274 deaneus - Shane Kersten (Fremantle)
Teams are scratching around for quality key forwards which is why they break AFL rules for the likes of Kurt Tippett, pay millions for unproven kids like Tom Boyd and recycle uber spuds like Kersten from other clubs. He is to Freo what Ian Downsborough was to us. Kersten has had six seasons in the AFL system and last year was his zenith... with one goal per game.

276 adelaidecrows - Jack Silvagni (Carlton)
I know he's young but he gets by by having a famous name, a hot mum and a younger brother who's supposed to be better. If he was called Jack Jones he wouldn't have played a senior game.

316 Danoz - Brendan Ah Chee (West Coast)
Did you mix him up with the Ah Chee who kicked 5 goals against us playing for Gold Coast last season? This is the other one - the Port dud who barely gets a touch even in the SANFL.

320 dogs105 - Billy Stretch (Melbourne)
Melbourne have 15+ midfielders/flankers better than this guy.

352 Danoz - Matthew Taberner (Fremantle)
Was the great white hope to take over from Pavlich but there was only one problem - he can't do anything. Terrible mark, unrealiable kick, useless at ground level, weak frame, reads the game poorly, average work rate.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Botched Picks Round 16 to 20



276 adelaidecrows - Jack Silvagni (Carlton)
I know he's young but he gets by by having a famous name, a hot mum and a younger brother who's supposed to be better. If he was called Jack Jones he wouldn't have played a senior game.
.

MILF

 

[Deaneus!]

274 deaneus - Shane Kersten (Fremantle)
Teams are scratching around for quality key forwards which is why they break AFL rules for the likes of Kurt Tippett, pay millions for unproven kids like Tom Boyd and recycle uber spuds like Kersten from other clubs. He is to Freo what Ian Downsborough was to us. Kersten has had six seasons in the AFL system and last year was his zenith... with one goal per game.

Ahem that's 1.2 goals per game, playing for Freo, who were terrible. Will be better this year.

 

[FAITH]

Do we have a voting system this year? Or do you just want a 1-18 rank?

Just rank them, and pm them to me.
Then there will be a finals knock out format for top 8 we can all vote

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Complete list and best 22 for The Tune Squad

Best 22

FB: J. MacMillan - M. Hartley - N. Haynes

HB: B. Maynard - K. Brand - J. Hunt

C: T. Scully - B. Crouch - S. Hill

HF: W. Milera - C. McCarthy - S. Edwards

FF: C. Ah Chee - T. Walker (C) - O. Fantasia

Foll: S. Naismith - A. Treloar - J. Steven (vc)

Int: L. Shiels - M. Kennedy - S. Lycett - T. Dickson

Emg: J. Redpath, D. Venables, R. Thompson
Depth: M. Leuenberger, A. Francis, J. Smith, B. Smith


I'd be shocked if my side isn't the quickest in the competition.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Isn't the quickest?

Bloody good team too. Midfield very strong plus a decent handful of players in each half.

 

[Mego Red]

Can we get all the sides into one post, then we all vote after comparing them?

 

[1990crow]

Top 8 teams ranked. I ranked the defences, midfields and forward lines as either A, B or C and then reranked when two teams were closely matched to be either A plus, minus etc. Generally rated teams with better defences and midfields over teams with similar overall strength. Top 2 were very close. Bottom 2 teams were terrible and shall not be named. Although one of them had awesome midfield and forward lines and seemingly no defence.

1. Daniel1812
2. Hendo8888
3. Danoz
4. Kristof
5. Danger in Texas
6. Scorpus
7. Adelaide Crows
8. Maggsy

 

[1990crow]

Can we get all the sides into one post, then we all vote after comparing them?

Just go off first page everyone but Dogs has updated to include a best 22. For Dogs i just went through pick by pick and made a best 22 myself.

 

[dogs105]

Can we get all the sides into one post, then we all vote after comparing them?

I will be able to do my team in a day or two

 

[FAITH]

So got 2 peoples Rankins so far, if we can get them all by the end of the week, then I will reveal the top8