Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Draft Game Version 2.0

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I'll have a crack at what Liam's team might look like:

B: R.Hayden W.Thursfield H.Taylor
HB: L.Hodge T.Croad K.Moore
C: T.Cotchin A.Cooney R.Palmer
HF:S.Goodwin M.Kreuzer B.Vince
F:M.Williams D.Hale C.Jones
R: D.Petrie B.Deledio B.Gibbs
I: K.Tippett N.Jones L.Hansen G.Ibbotson
 
FiveStrings said:
I'll have a crack at what Liam's team might look like:

B: R.Hayden W.Thursfield H.Taylor
HB: L.Hodge T.Croad K.Moore
C: T.Cotchin A.Cooney R.Palmer
HF:S.Goodwin M.Kreuzer B.Vince
F:M.Williams D.Hale C.Jones
R: D.Petrie B.Deledio B.Gibbs
I: K.Tippett N.Jones L.Hansen G.Ibbotson
Click to expand...

Liams team:
B: Hayden Croad Moore
HB: Hodge Thursfield Deledio
C: Cotchin Jones Gibbs
HF: Goodwin Petrie Vince
F: Williams Hale Jones
R: Kruezer Palmer Cooney
I: Tippett Hansen Ibbotson Moore
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Jezzza said:
So when we grade the teams do we rate them as if all players are at the peak of their powers or on how they are now & how we would expect them to go next year?
Click to expand...
Recent form / past form, structure and positioning is what I mark it on.
 
happy_eagle said:
For the convenience of all

Code: 
[B]                                Mop's Mops                 [/B]
 
[B]B:[/B]   Tom Harley             Daniel Merrett           Adam Hunter
[B]HB:[/B] Rick Ladson              Luke McPharlin        Max Rooke
[B]C: [/B]Chance Bateman             Brock McLean       [B]Kane Cornes[/B] (vc)
[B]HF:[/B] Paul Hasleby          Michael O'Loughlin    Andrew  Embley 
[B]FF: [/B]Russell Robertson      Daniel Bradshaw       Austin Wonaeamirri
[B]R: Dean Cox[/B] (c)            Kane Johnson          Scott Thompson[B]
INT: [/B]Brendan Lade   Chris Masten   David Wojcinski   Brad Miller

​
Code: 
                        [B]Happy's Heroes[/B]
[B]B[/B]:   Joel Bowden      [B] Darren Glass (vc)[/B]      Brent Guerra
[B]HB[/B]: Darren Milburn    Michael Firrito       Joel McDonald
[B]C[/B]: Brady Rawlings     [B]Brett Kirk  (c)  [/B]         James McDonald
[B]HF[/B]: Brent Stanton    Cameron Mooney         Tyson Edwards
[B]FF[/B]: Stephen Milne    Lance Franklin       Matthew Stokes
[B]R[/B]: Darren Jolly         Brent Harvey        Luke Power
[B]INT[/B]: Robert Campbell  Nick Stevens   Matthew Bate    Josh Hunt

Code: 
                    Scoter's Team
[B]B[/B]:  Newman             Lake                  King
[B]HB[/B]: Enright             Mackie               Johncock
[B]C[/B]:   J McVeigh           Mitchell              Welsh
[B]HF[/B]:  Giansiracusa     O'Keefe              C Morton
[B]FF[/B]:  Medhurst          Pavlich               LeCras
[B]R[/B]: Sandilands          Green                Dal Santo
[B]INT[/B]:Warnock          Kelly                   Gilham           Watson
Code: 
               Juddy's Team
B[/B]: Mattner             Carlile                Wheatley
[B]HB[/B]:S.Fisher           C.Bolton              Goddard
 [B]C[/B]: R.Murphy          Swan                   Salopek
 [B]HF[/B]:Chapman-          Lucas                  Porplyzia
 [B]FF[/B]: Rioli            Treadrea              N.G.Brown
 [B]R[/B]: Fraser            Bartel                  Kerr
 [B]INT[/B]: Carrazzo          Maric                  Prismall           Mundy

Code: 
                          [B]EA Sports (Eagle Ant)[/B]
[B]FB[/B]: Beau Waters,          Mathew Egan,         Harry O'Brian 
[B]HB[/B]: Heath Scotland,      Mathew McGuire,    Xavier Ellis
[B]C[/B]: Adam Goodes,          Ryan Griffin,           Brent Staker
[B]HF[/B]: Dale Thomas,         Johnathon Brown,   Scott Welsh
[B]FF[/B]: Richard Tambling,    Barry Hall,             Brett Ebert
[B]R[/B]: Steven King,            Luke Ball,             Joel Selwood
[B]INT[/B]:Mark Seaby,          Daniel Wells,       Shannon Hurn,     Luke Ablett


Code: 
        [B]Jezza's Juggernauts[/B]

[B]B[/B]:Grover           Scarlett           Adcock
[B]HB[/B]: Gram          Waite              Drummond
[B]C[/B]: Brennan       S Burgoyne       Young
[B]HF[/B]: Didak           Lynch             Soloman
[B]FF[/B]: Aa Davey     Riewoldt          McKinley
[B]R[/B]: McIntosh       Lewis              Boyd
[B]INT[/B]: Boak           Priddis             Leuenberger            Pendlebury


Code: 
             [B]West Enzymes (Prolix)[/B]

[B]B[/B]: Surjan             Barry                 Wirrpanda
[B]HB[/B]: Malceski         Bock                 P. Burgoyne
[B]C[/B]: Eagleton,        Van Berlo,           Montagna
[B]HF[/B]: Johnstone      Roughead,         McPhee
[B]FF[/B]: Jetta             Fevola              Johnson
[B]R[/B]: Simmonds         Foley                A. Selwood
[B]INT[/B]:Minson          Harris                Knights                 Gray



Code: 
            [B]The Stingers (Fivey)[/B]
[B]B: [/B] L.Gilbee          B.Rutten          R.Hargreave
[B]HB:[/B] A.McLeod        P.Ryder         G.Birchall
[B]C: [/B] D.Cassisi        J.Corey          S.Higgins
[B]HF[/B]: L.Davis         M.Richardson    M.Hahn
[B]F:[/B]  S.Johnson       A.Rocca         D.Rodan
[B]R: [/B] B.Ottens        L.Hayes(c)      C.Ling
[B]I:[/B]  D.Brogan      A.Simpson         M.Rischitelli       S.Gilbert




Code: 
      [B]
             The Shabadoos (Rojo + Shibz)[/B]

[B]FB[/B] C.Brown        Fletcher           Morris
[B]HB [/B]Kennelly        N.J Brown        H. Shaw
[B]C[/B]: Bruce            M. Murphy       Lovett
[B]HF[/B] Akermanis      Kennedy         Schneider
[B]FF [/B]Campbell        Lloyd             Al. Davey
[B]R[/B]: Hille              Judd               Cross
[B]I/C[/B]: P. Johnson   Mi. Johnson     J. Bolton       Walker


Code: 
               [B]Liams Team[/B]
[B]B:[/B] Hayden           Croad              Moore
[B]HB:[/B] Hodge           Thursfield         Deledio
[B]C: [/B]Cotchin           Jones               Gibbs
[B]HF:[/B] Goodwin         Petrie              Vince
[B]F:[/B] Williams            Hale                Jones
[B]R:[/B] Kruezer            Palmer             Cooney
[B]I:[/B] Tippett             Hansen            Ibbotson             Moore


Code: 
               [B]Beatlesmith's Booyakasha's[/B]
[B]B[/B]:Mcmahon          Hudghton           Pratt
[B]HB:[/B]B.Jones              Patfull           Lockyer
[B]C[/B]:C.Cornes            Black (c)       M.Mcveigh
[B]HF[/B]:Osbourne            T.Cloke         M.Morton
[B]F[/B]:D.Motlop              Burton         Kositzke
[B]R:[/B]Charman           G.Ablett          Sewell
[B]INT:[/B] L.Thomas        Rivers           Tuck            Dew
Click to expand...
Quoted incase a new page was formed
 
Mop said:
PM to me.
I'll only vote if there's a tie in first place.
If this is the case then I'll post my votes for all to see.
Click to expand...

You need to vote as well.

Otherwise all 10 of us vote for you, but only 9 people vote for everyone else.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

My voting is done, with a short analysis of where i thought you did good and bad. For the ones rated low... dont feel too bad it was tough to split those lower ones :)
 
Jezzza said:
Anybody else finding this really ****ing difficult to split the teams?
Click to expand...
very very hard. I separated it in to a mark out of 10 for the forward line, midfield and defence, thn combined the scores
4 teams got 24.5
4 teams got 23.5
Will have to look further in to player roles and structure to order it.
 
beatlesmith said:
very very hard. I separated it in to a mark out of 10 for the forward line, midfield and defence, thn combined the scores
4 teams got 24.5
4 teams got 23
Will have to look further in to player roles and structure to order it.
Click to expand...
Yeah because most sides were pretty even i based mine on the best structure. Theres a few teams that i think go too tall or too defensive or not defensive enough. Very in depth stuff :p
 
I just used woman's intuition.
aldo.gif


Nah seriously, I tried to look for the most balanced teams and then which of those had what I felt were the better players.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

You what surprised me the most. We got through this game without the need for a 2nd thread. Haha how much crap did we talk in the first game then :eek:
 
This game would be much better for vics, as they are more exposed to footy around the country. My concern is that guys like pratt, tuck and patfull in my team don't get anywhere near the recognition they deserve, and are vastly underrated by those who don't consistently watch them. Also because they are quiet acheivers, not flashy types. And that we rate eagles players really highly.
 
In the end I ranked the teams 1 to 10 for Backs, Forwards, Ruck & Starting Midfield & a final category I called "Interchange, Midfield Rotation & Flexibility" which incorporated the overall structure. Then just totaled the scores up, in the end I still had 2 lots of 2 teams that were on equal points.

It was like a ****ing essay! Mops probably still trying to figure it all out...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Draft Game Version 2.0

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top