AFL Draft Game Version 2.0

[Mop]

By popular demand, I'll show you how the points ended up.

I used a system of 10 - 1. Ten points being the best, 1 being the worst. Some people used this structure, others I reversed it so that I could do it the way I wanted.

Juddy – 83
Fivey – 79
Heagle – 73
Beatle – 66
Rojo – 64
Jezza – 55
Mop – 49
EA- 45
Prolix – 44
Scooter – 32
Liam- 15

 

[beatlesmith]

Sweet. Content with 4th.
Well done juddy, comiserations Fivey and Liam
You're a gun mop

 

[Prolix]

Mah Votes (best to least best)
Juddy
Fivey
Rojo
bs
Jezza
Happy
EA
Scooter
Mop
Liam

Published by unpopular demand ('Unpopular Demand' would be a good name for an indie band. Or an indie clothing label. Or a Michael Moore documentary).

 

[happy_eagle]

oooh 4th last
Just joking Prolix, honest voting

 

[scooterselwood]

to everyone involved, what was wrong with my team?

what made my team second last.

im not going to lie, i rated my team as top three but obviously something was wrong.

 

[Prolix]

oooh 4th last
Just joking Prolix, honest voting

It was extremely difficult to split that middle group. My notes tell me you had an excellent, balanced back line though.

 

[beatlesmith]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1: Happy eagle
Defence:8.5/10
Midfield:8/10
Forward: 8.5
2:Fivestrings
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 8.5/10
Forward: 8/10
3: Juddy88
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 9/10
Forward: 8/10
4:Rojo
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 9/10
Forward: 7.5/10
5rolix:
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 7.5/10
Forward: 9/10
6: Scooter
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 7.5/10
Forward: 8.5/10
7:Mop
Defence: 8.5/10
Midfield: 8/10
Forward: 7/10

8: EA
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield:8/10
Forward: 8/10
9: Liam
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 9/10
Forward: 6.5/10
10: Jezza
Defence: 8.5/10
Midfield: 7/10
Forward: 8/10


Don't have a go at me for the area ratings. Everyone rates players differently, and everyone has a different idea about positions for players and structure. It will just end in an argument. A useless and un-neccessary argument

As my ratings show, no-one had a bad team, it was just really close. Only 2 points separated the top from the bottom, so don't have a cry and claim i am saying your or another persons team is shit

 

[happy_eagle]

I seem to be getting alot of the 10 votes

 

[scooterselwood]

so beatle, the bench doesn't count for anything?

 

[scooterselwood]

my votes:

1) Happy
2) Juddy
3) Beatle
4) Fivey
5) Jezza
6) E.A
7) Mop
8) RoJo
9) Liam
10) Prolix

 

[Mop]

so beatle, the bench doesn't count for anything?

I would assume that he calculated the bench players into their respective positions' ranking

to everyone involved, what was wrong with my team?

what made my team second last.

im not going to lie, i rated my team as top three but obviously something was wrong.

Clouded by our own self-confidence.
Your backline was okay, but King? What the ****. The guy can't crack a game so he was certainly a weak link.
The midfield was very middle of the road. Mitchell obviously being the centrepiece, but it was all too a bit too workhorse and not enough genuine class to be deemed a threat.
Your forward line was your strong point. It worked well, but really it wasn't enough to salvage an otherwise - dare I say it - bland team.

 

[Jezzza]

[FONT=&quot]Here's my rankings,

10 Rojo
9 5Strings
8 Juddy88
7 Mop
6 Beatlesmith
5 EagleAnt
4 HappyEagle
3 Liam
2 ScooterSelwood
1 Prolix

[/FONT]

 

[RoJo Junior]

My ratings:

1st Juddy- Pretty solid across the ground, great midfield, good forward line

2nd Beatle - Hard to split between you and Juddy, your midfield is better (to settle your earlier argument) but he narrowly has you covered in the other areas.

3rd Fivey - Very good defence (best in the game... other than mine ), fairly good midfield, but forward line loses all credibility with the worst 200 gamer ever.. cmon haha.

4th Happy - Very defensive centre line, Forward line Buddy therefore = good. With Glassy holding up the defence.

5th EA - Pretty good forward line (minus Tambling haha), a few gun mids, but a few defenders let you down. Wells would be better off on the wing than Staker btw.

6th Mop - Very (too) tall defence, forward line best part of the team.

7th Scooter - Defence unaccountable, pretty much all rebounding players with minimal defensive qualities. Forward line best part despite an undersized CHF.

8th Prolix - Pretty good forward line and an ok midfield.

9th Jezza - Fairly good defence and forwards, average midfield lets him down.

10th Liam - Structure poor. Players playing out of position and players yet to be fully established in many roles.

The guys ranked from 5 - 9 i seriously could barely separate... it was like scissors paper rock i was moving them around constantly haha.

 

[beatlesmith]

my midfield was ridiculous
Ablett, sewell, black, c.cornes, mcveigh, tuck and dew. Hells yeah

 

[Juddy88]

and Juddy, your midfield is better (to settle your earlier argument)

Thanks

 

[RoJo Junior]

Hahaha nice bit of selective hearing you've got their Juddy. Oh well you won.. congrats.

 

[Mop]

And so ends 2.0.

 

[mitchzz]

Congratz Juddy.