Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Evolution player ratings discussion thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Thommo333 said:
Cripps is better than Ziebell and this could come across as being biased but I think Macrae had a better season than Griffin, Mundy and Ebert and is still on the up so he should be higher rated than them
Click to expand...
Agree with all of this.
 
We'll move on to the Key Defenders now! But by all means make suggestions for previous categories still. Order from best to worst.
upload_2017-1-10_10-4-26.png
 
Last edited:
Grundy Gibson hooker far too high

Hurley was better than hooker pre ban so needs bump up

Lever very good much higher

Kaiden brand will play plenty for hawks he is around the 72 players

Trengove around frawleys level needs solid bump up

Carlisle, barrass, hartley all slightly higher than players around them

Hamling slightly lower
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

bradburygold said:
Grundy Gibson hooker far too high

Hurley was better than hooker pre ban so needs bump up

Lever very good much higher

Kaiden brand will play plenty for hawks he is around the 72 players

Trengove around frawleys level needs solid bump up

Carlisle, barrass, hartley all slightly higher than players around them

Hamling slightly lower
Click to expand...
Where do you think Grundy, Gibson and Hooker should be placed in the list?
 
I have an issue with Hurley being 86 with a year out of the game and Robbie Tarrant being below him when he was unlucky to not be All-Australian. Rance isnt that clear above the rest. Tarrant and McDonald should be higher.
 
kangle4 said:
Rance plays as an entire back 6 for Richmond and is easily the best KD in the league.
Click to expand...

Bachar Houli had 25 touches a game as a running defender...I get they're not the premier back 6 in the AFL but 92 just is at a level of superstardom that I dont think Rance is at. He makes some shocking decisions.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Updated Marsh on the DEF/MID list. We will roll onto the Medium Defenders now. Still feel free to suggest changes to previous categories. Remember the aim at this stage is to order them from best to worst.
upload_2017-1-10_9-58-18.png
 
Last edited:
Apart from bottom placed dons and freo games Boyds last 10 games werent very impressive and he was the most surprising AA inclusion, and 9th in b&f, cant see him ahead of hodge or burgoyne who were teriffic in last few weeks when finally fit (well burgoyne was great all season he is at least equal to hodge at 87)
 
bradburygold said:
So does danger buddy and fyfe but look at their ratings
Click to expand...

Danger and Fyfe have higher disposal efficiency percentages than Rance. Buddy's bad decisions are having shots on horrid angles, other than that he played very well up the ground this year I thought.
 
GOTHELIONS16 said:
Updated Marsh on the DEF/MID list. We will roll onto the Medium Defenders now. Still feel free to suggest changes to previous categories. Remember the aim at this stage is to order them from best to worst.
View attachment 325902
Click to expand...

Why the bulldogs so far higher? Rampe, wood, stratton are above both and in their peak (why bob murphy not getting the 'obligatory' 3 grade bump after injury like rough and the don players?). Birchall agree no longer elite but he is no B grader, needs a bump. Howe played well in a top 8 side at end of season he is ahead of hampton and smedts
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

GOTHELIONS16 said:
Updated Marsh on the DEF/MID list. We will roll onto the Medium Defenders now. Still feel free to suggest changes to previous categories. Remember the aim at this stage is to order them from best to worst.
View attachment 325902
Click to expand...


Tyson Goldsack 5 points above Brayden Maynard? You put a player who played 4 games above one who played 20? Maynard getting more touches I might add. Do you actually watch some teams play? Some of these ratings really have me shaking my head. Dane Rampe should be at the top of this list also.
 
FearTheBeard13 said:
Tyson Goldsack 5 points above Brayden Maynard? You put a player who played 4 games above one who played 20? Maynard getting more touches I might add. Do you actually watch some teams play? Some of these ratings really have me shaking my head. Dane Rampe should be at the top of this list also.
Click to expand...
That's why i'm asking for all the help. Its harder than you think to compile over 700 players ratings and make it so they all are perfect. That is why we are going through this process. :)
 
bradburygold said:
Why the bulldogs so far higher? Rampe, wood, stratton are above both and in their peak (why bob murphy not getting the 'obligatory' 3 grade bump after injury like rough and the don players?). Birchall agree no longer elite but he is no B grader, needs a bump. Howe played well in a top 8 side at end of season he is ahead of hampton and smedts
Click to expand...
I'll make the early changes you suggest. I will put murphy down one as he actually played early in 2016 with excellent form. Roughead has had cancer, not being able to train at all, proabably on chemotherapy which takes a hit to the body. Roughy will never be the same player again as sad as it is. The Bombers players were away from their club for 12 months, and I didn't take much off them anyway.
 
GOTHELIONS16 said:
That's why i'm asking for all the help. Its harder than you think to compile over 700 players ratings and make it so they all are perfect. That is why we are going through this process. :)
Click to expand...

Be honest, it comes down to your opinion. If you actually looked at stats, these lists would look totally different. How do you think the developers at WW would do it? They wouldnt sit there and debate whos better, theyre watching game footage and looking at real statistics.
 
Heres the updated DEF/MID list. I still think Boyd should be up there. More people say it if I'm wrong.
upload_2017-1-10_9-59-43.png
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom