List Mgmt. Aisho Going Elsewhere

[crazybear]

But if Pickering is clever, Aish won't go into the PSD, he will go into the ND. Just as Luke Ball did

Where Carlton's second pick will be before Collingwoods first.

 

[danielnajdek]

Even if they don't end up trading with us it will still be good to see them lose him for nothing.

We are losing Freeman but you don't see anyone from Collingwood coming out and saying we aren't going to trade him. I like how quiet we've been.

For some reason Brisbane have something against us.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Where Carlton's second pick will be before Collingwoods first.

So how did Ball last til pick 30?

 

[Smoky]

Whats with the thread title?

Aish nominates Pies... Brisbane are a basketcase.

Seems a little more appropriate.

 

[Mudeo]

Correct but Carlton can take less back on the Bell deal from Brisbane knowing that they will get Aish in PSD.

If there is a chance a trade will not be done to get to the Pies then he sure as hell wont go into the PSD where there is a chance he will go to your rabble.

 

[crazybear]

So how did Ball last til pick 30?

Aish is a 2 year player former pick 7. This years Draft is perceived to be weaker. The club who drafts him only has to agree to the players terms.

 

[Mudeo]

Aish is a 2 year player former pick 7. This years Draft is perceived to be weaker. The club who drafts him only has to agree to the players terms.

Right, but then he proceeds to go on a holiday and only speaks to Collingwood prior. We leak to the media he failed a medical and no other club can then get into contact with him. Will they still take a chance if a hefty price is on his head?

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Aish is a 2 year player former pick 7. This years Draft is perceived to be weaker. The club who drafts him only has to agree to the players terms.

So you don't have an answer
One way or another Pickering WILL get Aish to Collingwood, get used to it

 

[Jasper84]

Where Carlton's second pick will be before Collingwoods first.

And you will pick up a disgruntled player who doesn't want to be there, walking out after one season. You already benched Henderson for the last 3 weeks, how is it going to look when Aish doesn't play all year after requesting a trade?

 

[Matt_352]

Let Aish go you criminal thugs

 

[Kilmo]

Apparently Carlton are heavily into Aish so could pick him up. Not sure how it would work

Carlton have been told they aren't allowed to recruit anyone from Collingwood because it was getting embarrassing.

So their new strategy: take players who wish they were at Collingwood.
Welcome to Carlton, Treloar and Aish!

 

[Kirby]

I think if we can cleverly trade into late in the first round (say Sydney's pick) then I reckon we will safely get him in the National draft. Even he we cant do that I still think that we could get him with a second round pick.

If Aish steadfastly sticks to his guns and refuses to speak to other clubs then would another club actually draft him? Would Carlton take the risk on drafting a player that refuses to speak to them and doesn't want to be there? I don't believe they would (but they will huff and puff that they will to try to gt Aish to cave and speak to them).

Eddie said in his show this morning that he does not believe that Brisbane have anything against Collingwood and that it seems to be all about Aish. He said we haven't even offered anything yet so questioned Brisbane's position. He also questioned Brisbane's requests for priority picks if they are taking the position that they will let Aish go for nothing. He was overall pretty calm about it and just said if a deal can't be done then Aish will go into the draft.

He also said there is 2 weeks to go before the end of the trade period and a lot can happen in that time.

 

[Mudeo]

I think if we can cleverly trade into late in the first round (say Sydney's pick) then I reckon we will safely get him in the National draft. Even he we cant do that I still think that we could get him with a second round pick.

If Aish steadfastly sticks to his guns and refuses to speak to other clubs then would another club actually draft him. Would Carlton take the risk on drafting a player that refuses to speak to them and doesn't want to be there? I don't believe they would (but they will huff and puff that they will to try to gt Aish to cave and speak to them).

Eddie said in his show this morning that he does not believe that Brisbane have anything against Collingwood and that it seems to be all about Aish. He said we haven't even offered anything yet so questioned Brisbane's position. He also questioned Brisbane's requests for priority picks if they are taking the position that they will let Aish go for nothing. He was overall pretty calm about it and just said if a deal can't be done then Aish will go into the draft.

He also said there is 2 weeks to ge before the end of the trade period and a lot can happen in that time.

Didnt Essendon take the same approach with Ball, said they would still take him even if he didnt have a medical?

 

[Matt_352]

I think if we can cleverly trade into late in the first round (say Sydney's pick) then I reckon we will safely get him in the National draft. Even he we cant do that I still think that we could get him with a second round pick.

If Aish steadfastly sticks to his guns and refuses to speak to other clubs then would another club actually draft him? Would Carlton take the risk on drafting a player that refuses to speak to them and doesn't want to be there? I don't believe they would (but they will huff and puff that they will to try to gt Aish to cave and speak to them).

Eddie said in his show this morning that he does not believe that Brisbane have anything against Collingwood and that it seems to be all about Aish. He said we haven't even offered anything yet so questioned Brisbane's position. He also questioned Brisbane's requests for priority picks if they are taking the position that they will let Aish go for nothing. He was overall pretty calm about it and just said if a deal can't be done then Aish will go into the draft.

He also said there is 2 weeks to go before the end of the trade period and a lot can happen in that time.

Nice Cool calm Ed

 

[PicaBoo]

I think if we can cleverly trade into late in the first round (say Sydney's pick) then I reckon we will safely get him in the National draft. Even he we cant do that I still think that we could get him with a second round pick.

If Aish steadfastly sticks to his guns and refuses to speak to other clubs then would another club actually draft him? Would Carlton take the risk on drafting a player that refuses to speak to them and doesn't want to be there? I don't believe they would (but they will huff and puff that they will to try to gt Aish to cave and speak to them).

Eddie said in his show this morning that he does not believe that Brisbane have anything against Collingwood and that it seems to be all about Aish. He said we haven't even offered anything yet so questioned Brisbane's position. He also questioned Brisbane's requests for priority picks if they are taking the position that they will let Aish go for nothing. He was overall pretty calm about it and just said if a deal can't be done then Aish will go into the draft.

He also said there is 2 weeks to go before the end of the trade period and a lot can happen in that time.

I hope that Aish is aware that we won't be bending over for him either. Eddie is just returning fire with similar bluff. Would wonder what would happen if it came that far . Likely a deal will be done somehow.
Anyone else there that we want? Not looking forward to accomodate those clowns for the coming years.

 

[DaVe86]

Obviously i would like to see this get done via a trade. To make that happen, we are probably going to need to involve other clubs because brisbane wont deal with us directly it seems.

This is my proposal:

Step 1: Carlisle and pick 23 to st.kilda who give essendon pick 5.

Step 2: St.kilda give us pick 23 for Freeman

Step 3: we on trade pick 23 to Carlton for Tom Bell

Step 4: Tom Bell goes to Brisbane, and we also send our other 2nd round pick

Step 5: James Aish to Collingwood


Net result

Brisbane: Tom Bell plus pick 26 for James Aish

Coll: James Aish for Nathan Freeman plus pick 26

Carlton: Pick 23 for Tom Bell

Essendon: Pick 5 for Carlisle and pick 23

St.K: Freeman and Carlisle for pick 5

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Why would you "hope" for something like that Brown? Peanut.

So you HOPE for a player to be miserable?
So you HOPE for Collingwood to miss out on a player?
So you HOPE for Brisbane to make their current player retention/attraction situation worse?

Nice going doofus.

 

[Subprime]

Then Brown says the Lions need to get something for a player leaving the club.

 

[Matt_352]

Why would you "hope" for something like that Brown? Peanut.

So you HOPE for a player to be miserable?
So you HOPE for Collingwood to miss out on a player?
So you HOPE for Brisbane to make their current player retention/attraction situation worse?

Nice going doofus.

Too many knocks to the head

 

[Subprime]

Anyone know if Brisbane offer 4 year deals to all draftees when they get picked?

Its hard to see how Matthews can demand 4 years minimum service if it doesn't cut both ways.

 

[ImportExport]

I think Leigh Matthews decided a few weeks ago that if Aish decides to leave then he's gonna make an example of it and force him into the draft unless the trade options are too good to refuse, I think Brisbane have decided that they are not gonna just be taken advantage of and Aish is gonna be the example of this

 

[FIGJAM]

Any chance that we can reverse the GWS offer and trade next year's first pick instead, then flip 7 for Aish?

There are so many complications now with regards to the 'paying' for F&S / academy kids that surely we can sort something out.

 

[Mudeo]

I think Leigh Matthews decided a few weeks ago that if Aish decides to leave then he's gonna make an example of it and force him into the draft unless the trade options are too good to refuse, I think Brisbane have decided that they are not gonna just be taken advantage of and Aish is gonna be the example of this

So at the end of the day what's the difference with Redden? Apart from giving more service to the club the situation is no different.

 

[Subprime]

I think Leigh Matthews decided a few weeks ago that if Aish decides to leave then he's gonna make an example of it and force him into the draft unless the trade options are too good to refuse, I think Brisbane have decided that they are not gonna just be taken advantage of and Aish is gonna be the example of this

No matter how many knots they tie themselves in

 

[Kirby]

Didnt Essendon take the same approach with Ball, said they would still take him even if he didnt have a medical?

You're stetching my memory but i think that's right. I vaguely recall that a couple of clubs left the option open.