List Mgmt. All Trades and Draft Part 2- Draft edition

[FatPizza]

Goals from the mid in 2019 (wikipedia):
Shuey = 2
Gaff = 3
Redden = 5
Sheed = 6
Yeo = 11
Total = 27

Kelly = 24!

That's not correct, Sheed kick 16 i think plus Shuey kicked many more than 2...

 

[Agent93]

I have a feeling the reason that this deal was done so early in the trade period is that West coast need time to trade back into the draft . This is Just the first piece of the puzzle .

If that's the plan wou've gotta wonder what we're going to trade with.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Thrilled to get kelly .

Almost the same as the neale trade but we had to pay the equivalent on an extra 1st rounder due to him being uncontracted.

I wonder how hard rawlings is laughing

 

[Ok Boomer]

Just because our picks in the 30's in recent times have been hit and miss doesn't mean we should throw them around like confetti. Poor logic.

 

[Forward Press]

Reserving judgement until we hear what that essendon trade for 37 involved

Effectively 33 + 57 for 37 and 52 I think it was.

 

[Pykie]

The only player in the last 10 years taken with pick 33 that has really done anything is Jeremy Howe.

This trade is fine.

And Bradley Hill.....

Prior to that was Jed Adcock, Sam Gilbert, David Rodan, Craig Bolton and Shaun Hart.

Statistically from the last 14 drafts, they have an 11% chance of getting an AA out of a 30-50 pick, a 14% chance of a 200 gamer and a 36% chance at a 100+ gamer.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

We took Anus in the 30s, yet Rioli in the 50s.

Have faith people.

 

[Forward Press]

Does this mean those with Tim Kelly avatars can now post on the Geelong board?

 

[random260]

So guys what happens if: Shuey/kelly/gaff/yeo does their acl?

Congrats wce you traded the farm to pick up 1 player (who turns 26 next year) who has 5 years left of his prime. Well know I know wce motto is I (Tim kelly) instead of team (4 potential stars).

Uncontracted, Fremantle were never interested. I know let's fold like paper

We could have picked up Devon Robertson. Mark my words if he shows any similarities to glass or hodge pitch forks comes out

 

[Forward Press]

Just because our picks in the 30's in recent times have been hit and miss doesn't mean we should throw them around like confetti. Poor logic.

Ask Geelong if they would prefer all those picks or Tim Kelly.

That should provide the answers for the naysayers in this deal.

 

[gazzathegreat]

Round 1 Changes from Semi-final loss to Geelong.

Out: Masten
In: Kelly

Geelong.
Out: Kelly
In: Stevens

 

[squashface]

And Bradley Hill.....

Prior to that was Jed Adcock, Sam Gilbert, David Rodan, Craig Bolton and Shaun Hart.

Statistically from the last 14 drafts, they have an 11% chance of getting an AA out of a 30-50 pick, a 14% chance of a 200 gamer and a 36% chance at a 100+ gamer.

Must have missed Brad Hill.

Tim Kelly however is a 100% chance of getting an AA though so I’m still happy with the trade.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

don't get the point of this really.

We get 52 instead of 57

Its just a diversion so you dont look at the ass raping

 

[FKASC]

That's not correct, Sheed kick 16 i think plus Shuey kicked many more than 2...

These are the real stats:

Gaff - 3
Shuey - 8
Sheed - 16
Yeo - 11
Redden - 0

Total: 38

 

[Seadog]

Does this mean those with Tim Kelly avatars can now post on the Geelong board?

Only one way to find out.

 

[gazzathegreat]

So guys what happens if: Shuey/kelly/gaff/yeo does their acl?

Congrats wce you traded the farm to pick up 1 player (who turns 26 next year) who has 5 years left of his prime. Well know I know wce motto is I (Tim kelly) instead of team (4 potential stars).

Uncontracted, Fremantle were never interested. I know let's fold like paper

What happens if an asteroid hits the world tomorrow and we all die? I paid my taxes this year for nothing

 

[hudson2006]

Goodbye farm. Hello Tim.

Get Excited, Eagles: The best of star recruit Tim Kelly

Former Geelong midfielder Tim Kelly lands at West Coast in a significant trade

www.afl.com.au

 

[squashface]

 

[Carbine Chaos]

So guys what happens if: Shuey/kelly/gaff/yeo does their acl?

Congrats wce you traded the farm to pick up 1 player (who turns 26 next year) who has 5 years left of his prime. Well know I know wce motto is I (Tim kelly) instead of team (4 potential stars).

Uncontracted, Fremantle were never interested. I know let's fold like paper

That's so dumb.

What if Fyfe runs over Walters, then careers into a deep ravine and drowns?

You can't deal in hypotheticals.

 

[Forward Press]

So guys what happens if: Shuey/kelly/gaff/yeo does their acl?

Congrats wce you traded the farm to pick up 1 player (who turns 26 next year) who has 5 years left of his prime. Well know I know wce motto is I (Tim kelly) instead of team (4 potential stars).

Uncontracted, Fremantle were never interested. I know let's fold like paper

We could have picked up Devon Robertson. Mark my words if he shows any similarities to glass or hodge pitch forks comes out

Potential stars ain't gonna win us flags.

Who would you prefer heading into 2020? Tim Kelly, or Cam McCarthy, Billy Hartung and Tom Cutler? I just used the 2013 draft with the same picks we gave up as an example.

1 known elite quantity over maybe 3 future quality any day when you're in the window.

 

[FKASC]

These are the real stats:

Gaff - 3
Shuey - 8
Sheed - 16
Yeo - 11
Redden - 0

Total: 38

Further to this, Kelly kicked more goals this year than:
- Redden has kicked in his career at the Eagles
- Gaff has kicked in the past three years
- Shuey has kicked in the past three years

 

[HoneyBadger35]

So guys what happens if: Shuey/kelly/gaff/yeo does their acl?

So if Shuey, Kelly, Gaff, Yeo did an ACL, your solution would be rely on the second round pick to carry the load?

In general, most teams aren’t set up to carry losing All Australian players.

 

[Seadog]

Goodbye farm. Hello Tim.

Get Excited, Eagles: The best of star recruit Tim Kelly

Former Geelong midfielder Tim Kelly lands at West Coast in a significant trade

www.afl.com.au

A farm's not much good to you in a drought*.



*See Fremantle

 

[Forward Press]

That's so dumb.

What if Fyfe runs over Walters, then careers into a deep ravine and drowns?

You can't deal in hypotheticals.

Is that you Ross? I guess you have plenty of free time nowadays to post on BigFooty.

 

[Shmiddy15]

These are the real stats:

Gaff - 3
Shuey - 8
Sheed - 16
Yeo - 11
Redden - 0

Total: 38

Can't believe redden went down from 10 to 0. Needs to rediscover his 2018 form. Hopefully Gaff can do the same now with more time on the outside, and pick up AA #3.