Best 22 (age 30+)

[carlton09]

B: D.Fletcher - S.Prestigiacomo - C.Chornes
HB: A. McLeod - M.Scarlett - S.Goodwin
M: N.Eagleton - L.Hayes(C) - T.Lockyer
HF: J.Akermanis - A.Goodes - B.Harvey
F: S.Milne - B.Hall - C.Mooney

Foll: B.Hudson - S.Black - B.Cousins

Inter: D.Brogan - B.Johnson - B.Kirk - J.Bolton

Emerg: B.Ottens - M.Doughty - T.Edwards

Thoughts?

 

[wce4premiership]

Intimidating side, lots of experience and talent.

Ben cousins for captain

 

[Ron The Bear]

- a fit Ottens is better than Hudson or Brogan
- Burton, Bradshaw etc. better than Doughty
- Port fans will attack you for leaving out Tredrea
- Bolton not quite 30 yet!
- not bad otherwise but it's not super-difficult to pick with only 36 qualifiers

 

[Bowski]

I thought for sure Tredrea was in his thirties. If he is swap Mooney for him and i'd say bingo.

Oh and Edwards and Ottens over Milne and Brogan surely?

 

[Lazarus]

Good team, but:

Johnson >> Eagleton

Ottens >> Hudson >> daylight >>>>>>>>>>>> Brogan

 

[Malifice]

Intresting thread!

 

[Scotland]

Jude Bolton is 29 for another week.

IN: Luke Power, Daniel Bradshaw

OUT: Jude Bolton, Michael Doughty

Lenny Hayes for captain.

 

[bradrowe#32]

I agree with the selections of Lockyer and Presti. Both have had very solid careers.

 

[pacemaker]

No Darren Glass?? WTF at least as an emergency.

And that FB line is a little tall/slow don't you think?

 

[Del80659]

Pretty good thread, but you gotta have Wozza somewhere..

 

[tribey]

- Port fans will attack you for leaving out Tredrea

Par for the course really.

If it was up to the BigFooty genpop Warren would struggle to make a Power best 22 let alone one with wider parameters.

 

[Power King]

tredrea > mooney

 

[Bart Wilson]

I thought for sure Tredrea was in his thirties. If he is swap Mooney for him and i'd say bingo.

Oh and Edwards and Ottens over Milne and Brogan surely?

MILNE > EDWARDS as a forward pocket are you serious??

Yeah sure as a midfielder but dont take milnes sopt MF|!

 

[carlton09]

No Darren Glass?? WTF at least as an emergency.

And that FB line is a little tall/slow don't you think?

Glass is 28 champ...

 

[Invigoration]

You'd take Edwards over Eagleton every day of the week.

Hudson is pretty average as well, dunno why he was included. I'd put Goodes into the ruck (that is where he played his best) and put Tredrea at CHF.

 

[GrandBlue]

Glass is 28 champ...

You still need an excuse for putting Mooney over Tredrea...

 

[carlton09]

You still need an excuse for putting Mooney over Tredrea...

Tredrea is a hack... Would prefer Mooney anyday of the week.

How about some of use guys come up with your own best 22?

 

[Invigoration]

Tredrea is a hack... Would prefer Mooney anyday of the week.

How about some of use guys come up with your own best 22?

I don't want to use guys, I'm not into that thing man

 

[Del80659]

tredrea is a hack... Would prefer mooney anyday of the week.

How about some of use guys come up with your own best 22?

uuuuusseeeeeeee are da worst troll ulehhhh

 

[AG]

B: Simon Prestigiacomo - Matthew Scarlett - Darren Milburn
HB: Andrew McLeod - Dustin Fletcher - Simon Goodwin
C: Ben Cousins - Simon Black - Adam Goodes
HF: Brent Harvey - Warren Tredrea - Jason Akermanis
F: Daniel Bradshaw - Barry Hall - Brad Johnson
R: Brad Ottens - Lenny Hayes - Brett Kirk (c)
INT: Steven King - Luke Power - Chad Cornes - Tyson Edwards

EMG: Stephen Milne - Cameron Mooney - Tarkyn Lockyer

Brogan/Gardiner/King for backup ruck. Gardiner was best when fit but King has had the better career. Not sure on some those guys D.O.B's.

 

[Ess_don]

Interesting idea... not a bad side!

How about an over 27yo team compared to an under 27yo team?
Would a bunch of talented (and presumably faster) kids be able to beat a side full of experienced bodies?

Btw, just thought 27 is kinda fair median age to choose..

 

[Bowski]

MILNE > EDWARDS as a forward pocket are you serious??

Yeah sure as a midfielder but dont take milnes sopt MF|!

A premier midfielder that can kick goals over a shitknacker goal sneak that goes missing every second game? Yeah pretty serious.

 

[Bart Wilson]

A premier midfielder that can kick goals over a shitknacker goal sneak that goes missing every second game? Yeah pretty serious.

you saying you would rather have edwards in the forward pocket in 2010 than milne?

Milne missing? or doing more team things?? And still kicking 60 goals a year! The guy is a gun and cant wait for him to be a premiership player in 7 months.

Milne is the most unfairly judged player maybe of ALL time. never gets credit for good games just hounded on his bad ones.

200 games, 400 goals.

 

[Dangas]

good side

 

[cradle of filth]

B: Simon Prestigiacomo - Matthew Scarlett - Darren Milburn
HB: Andrew McLeod - Dustin Fletcher - Simon Goodwin
M: Tyson Edwards - Lenny Hayes - Brett Kirk
HF: Jason Akermanis - Adam Goodes - Brent Harvey
F: Brad Johnson(C) - Barry Hall - Daniel Bradshaw
R: Michael Gardiner - Simon Black - Ben Cousins
I: Brad Ottens - Tarkyn Lockyer - Chad Cornes - Luke Power
E: Dean Brogan - Michael Doughty - Warren Tredrea