Best Team Formation

[mojon95]

1 Ruckman
2 Mids
1 Defence
1 Forward

Hawks
Carlton
Brisbane
Fremantle
West Coast
Geelong
Essendon

 

[Sainters08]

um...St.Kilda?

easily better than Essendon's

King = Hille
Dal Santo >> Stanton
Hayes >>> Watson
S.Fisher = Fletcher
Riewoldt >>> Lucas/Lloyd

 

[TigerGlory]

Interesting.

For the Tigers it looks like the following;

Troy Simmonds
Nathan Foley
Brett Deledio
Matthew Richardson
Graham Polak.

 

[goal sneak]

um...Melbourne?

easily better than Essendon's

White >>> Hille
McLean >> Stanton
Jones >>> Watson
Carroll = Fletcher
Miller >>> Lucas/Lloyd

 

[matty_boy08]

um...Melbourne?

easily better than Essendon's

White >>> Hille
McLean >> Stanton
Jones >>> Watson
Carroll = Fletcher
Miller >>> Lucas/Lloyd

Carroll is no where near fletchers level?

 

[thebigboy]

um...Melbourne?

easily better than Essendon's

White >>> Hille
McLean >> Stanton
Jones >>> Watson
Carroll = Fletcher
Miller >>> Lucas/Lloyd

Easy response to this one. um....no chance in hell.

How players like Miller can even get a gig at the top level is beyond me. Looked disinterested on Saturday.

 

[didaka]

um...Melbourne?

easily better than Essendon's

White >>> Hille
McLean >> Stanton
Jones >>> Watson
Carroll = Fletcher
Miller >>> Lucas/Lloyd

Did I read this one properly

 

[HBK619]

um...Melbourne?

easily better than Essendon's

White >>> Hille
McLean >> Stanton
Jones >>> Watson
Carroll = Fletcher
Miller >>> Lucas/Lloyd

This is a joke right?

Miller better than Lucas or Lloyd, Carroll equal to the numerous times All Australian Fletcher, Jones over Watson I agree but maybe by one >, McLean equal to Stanton I think, McLean has been average so far to say the least, and White should be better than Hille but he is so damn lazy.

Good luck being on the bottom of the ladder, at least I know the Tigers won't win that wooden spoon.

 

[Last Line Hero]

1 Ruckman
2 Mids
1 Defence
1 Forward

Hawks
Carlton
Brisbane
Fremantle
West Coast
Geelong
Essendon

B. Ottens
G. Ablett- J. Bartel
M. Scarlett
C. Mooney

Yeah that'll do...

The scary thing is you could make several formations for Geelong that would still be better than just about any other club.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

um...St.Kilda?

easily better than Essendon's

King = Hille
Dal Santo >> Stanton
Hayes >>> Watson
S.Fisher <<< Fletcher
Riewoldt < Lloyd

St.Kilda's is better than Essendons but your smoking crack if you think Sam Fisher is on the same level as Fletcher arguably one the best defenders in the last decade.

 

[JKCeagle]

Cox
Kerr, Priddis
Glass
Lynch

I'd say 2nd or 3rd stongest overall...easily the best ruck, probably 2nd best mids after Geelong (Hawks might be equal), equal best defender with Geelong...but likely last in the forward.

 

[Shaymuhz]

Sandilands
J.Carr, Headland
Pavlich
McPharlin

bell could slot in to the mids i guess

 

[Sainters08]

St.Kilda's is better than Essendons but your smoking crack if you think Sam Fisher is on the same level as Fletcher arguably one the best defenders in the last decade.

where did I say Fisher is on the same level as Flether??

Fletcher is very over-rated IMO

 

[SuperHooper]

Charman
Black, Johnstone
Merret
JONATHAN BROWN

I reckon its the best
My personal BIASED opinion

 

[Amazing Bombers]

where did I say Fisher is on the same level as Flether??

Fletcher is very over-rated IMO

So is Fisher.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

where did I say Fisher is on the same level as Flether??

Fletcher is very over-rated IMO

You said its in your post

Fletcher = S.Fisher

Fletcher is only overrated if you dont consider one percenters, foot skills and spoiling.

 

[Sainters08]

You said its in your post

Fletcher = S.Fisher

Fletcher is only overrated if you dont consider one percenters, foot skills and spoiling.

Fletcher used to be a star.

he has aged obviously and now he isn't as good as he once was.

I would take S.Fisher every day of the week.

If it was 5 years ago then I would take Fletcher.

 

[Sainters08]

So is Fisher.

LOL. you tool.

if anything, he is under-rated

 

[doggiesin08]

Sam Fisher is highly rated now, heavily due to dream team. I believe Dream team does have an impact on public perceptions of players.

DOGS

Ben Hudson
Cooney, Cross
Brian Lake (IMO top 3 fullback)
Brad Johnson.

Quite strong.

 

[bomberstomake8]

um...St.Kilda?

easily better than Essendon's

King = Hille
Dal Santo >> Stanton
Hayes >>> Watson
S.Fisher = Fletcher
Riewoldt >>> Lucas/Lloyd

i agree with the first three.. fletcher>S.Fisher
and Lucas>Riewoldt. riewoldt gets more of the ball but lucas is much more damaging then riewoldt. he marks it inside 60m and he has a great chance at kicking the goal.

 

[mojon95]

um...St.Kilda?

easily better than Essendon's

King = Hille
Dal Santo >> Stanton
Hayes >>> Watson
S.Fisher = Fletcher
Riewoldt >>> Lucas/Lloyd

Geelong

King <<< Ottens
Dal Santo <<< Ablett
Hayes <<< Bartel
Scarlett <<< Fisher
Riewoldt >>> Mooney

Hawthorn
King = Campbell/Taylor
Dalsanto <<< Hodge
Hayes <<< Mitchell
Fisher >>> Brown
Riewoldt = Buddy

 

[eth-dog]

1 Ruckman
2 Mids
1 Defence
1 Forward

Hawks
Carlton
Brisbane
Fremantle
West Coast
Geelong
Essendon

please tell me you are joking.

 

[Last Line Hero]

Geelong

King <<< Ottens
Dal Santo <<< Ablett
Hayes <<< Bartel
Scarlett <<< Fisher
Riewoldt >>> Mooney

Hawthorn
King = Campbell/Taylor
Dalsanto <<< Hodge
Hayes <<< Mitchell
Fisher >>> Brown
Riewoldt = Buddy

Fisher is better than Scarlett?????????

Oh Dear!!!!

King is better than Ottens??????????

Oh Dear!!!!

You truly are a mojon.

 

[jonoman89]

please tell me you are joking.

Cam Cloke (experience over Hammer and Kruez)
Chris Judd, Nick Stevens/Marc Murphy
Jarrad Waite
Brendan Fevola

not too shabby - its the other players who let them down remember.

 

[Last Line Hero]

Cam Cloke (experience over Hammer and Kruez)
Chris Judd, Nick Stevens/Marc Murphy
Jarrad Waite
Brendan Fevola

not too shabby - its the other players who let them down remember.

This would be lucky to be Top 12.