Best Young Forward

[BigBomber09]

Who would you rather have at your club?

 

[madhawkboy]

Who would you rather have at your club?

Poll?

 

[__aria__]

quality options

 

[BigBomber09]

Sorry bout that accidently stuffed up the post, and sent it without the poll. come back and vote now.

 

[blockman155]

i wouldnt consider gill as a young forward
McKinley is the best out of that lot by far followed by Riewoldt

 

[THEGREATRICHO]

jack reiwolt - great mark and kick hes only 19 and just needs to buffen up a fair bit.

 

[BigBomber09]

Id personally go McKinley by a fair bit. Great mark, great kick. could be the next big thing in AFL forwards. Riewoldt needs to get some meat onto him.

 

[gavdog08]

1. Ben McKinley - West Coast
2. Jack Riewoldt - Richmond
3. Jay Neagle - Essendon
4. Nick Gill - Adelaide
5. Justin Westhoff - Port Adelaide
6. Ryan Gamble - Geelong

 

[BluesMan]

I'd go McKinley just over riewoldt

 

[HBK619]

Why the **** is Nick Gill on that list?!? He is 26 years old!

Honestly, do some research before making a Poll about "Young" players.

The best actual young Forward from that list would be McKinley followed by Riewoldt, but Riewoldt is almost 2 years younger than McKinley and is a better KP option with an extra 8cm over McKinley, so I would take Riewoldt for the Tiges.

 

[kingyubbo]

1. Ben McKinley - West Coast
2. Jack Riewoldt - Richmond
3. Jay Neagle - Essendon
4. Nick Gill - Adelaide
5. Justin Westhoff - Port Adelaide
6. Ryan Gamble - Geelong

No offence dude, but even as an Adelaide supporter I wouldn't rate Nick Gill above Ryan Gamble.

McKinley, then Riewoldt, then Neagle, then Gamble. Gill shouldn't make the list.

 

[Drummond]

Taylor Walker clearly isn't half as good a prospect as Gill.

 

[Daz]

Riewoldt
McKinley
Gamble
Neagle
Westhoff
Gill

 

[The Purple Jesus]

mcKinley
Riewoldt
Westhoff
Gamble
Neagle (too many injuries)
Gill (is he young?)
why cant people do there research? Pav is only just older than Gill!!!!!! Why not throw him in? Or Dunstall? Or John Coleman? or Pratt?

 

[BigBomber09]

Frickin hell have a sook a got it a bit wrong with Gill. If his so old why doesnt he play many games.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Frickin hell have a sook a got it a bit wrong with Gill. If his so old why doesnt he play many games.

Ever seen him kick a football? me neither, it looks like it comes off his shin or something every time.

 

[TheWiseOne]

Ben McKinley - West Coast

 

[BigBomber09]

Ever seen him kick a football? me neither, it looks like it comes off his shin or something every time.

quite true. He takes one good mark all year. And after Tippet and Porplyzia are injured they talk him up to be Adelaides next "Big" forward.

It's clear Ben McKinley is the best forward out of this group.

I wanna do a new poll. What should it be about????

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Mckinley best ATM, Riewoldt best prospect i think.

 

[iGNITER]

Riewoldt/ McKinley a long way ahead of the rest

 

[Dandy_GO]

quite true. He takes one good mark all year. And after Tippet and Porplyzia are injured they talk him up to be Adelaides next "Big" forward.

What? No we didn't. We talked him up as the only uninjured forward we had left on our list!
I love Gill, but nobody thinks he'll ever be a superstar.

 

[BigBomber09]

Gill is alright i spose. nothing too exciting.

 

[BlackGun1]

Why isn't Jack Anthony on this list?

Replace him with Gill.

 

[mattdwyer]

i'd say franklin ...

 

[BigBomber09]

Why isn't Jack Anthony on this list?

Replace him with Gill.

You mean John Anthony from the pies. I'll put him on next time.