BigFooty AFL Live Competition Season 1 - Brownlow Medal Count

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

For those reading, this is a Brownlow Medal count for the PS3 competition we've been holding in this thread: http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=856464

Each competitor has submitted a 3, 2, 1 of votes for each game they took part in. Votes will be counted and tallied round by round, with leaderboards posted every four rounds. The most a player can receive per game is 6 votes, if receiving a 3 from each competitor.

For some matches, only one competitor may have submitted votes. If this happens, the other competitor has had to previously specify that they want their competitor's votes doubled. Otherwise, the votes of the voting party are doubled for their players only.

In some cases, if no votes are submitted by either competitor, no votes are given for the match.

The Brownlow winner(s) will be declared at the end of round 24 voting. There will be no countback in the case of a tie. Let the voting begin. Comments are welcome as we go (if anyone is still up).

FINAL LEADERBOARD:

62. G.Ablett (GCS)
57. A.Sandilands (Frem)
53. S.Thompson (Adel)
49. B.Deledio (Rich)
44. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
41. M.Pavlich (Frem)
40. S.Black (Bris)
39. S.Mitchell (Haw)
35. D.Petrie (NM)
34. B.Harvey (NM)
33. M.Bate (Melb)
33. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
33. K.Tippett (Adel)
32. N.Foley (Rich)
32. M.Murphy (Carl)
32. J.Roughead (Haw)
31. D.Pearce (PA)
30. B.Goddard (St.K)
30. L.Montagna (St.K)
30. A.Swallow (NM)
30. J.Waite (Carl)
30. J.Watson (Ess)
28. M.Hurley (Ess)
28. D.Jackson (Rich)
28. C.Knights (Adel)
25. S.Hill (Frem)
25. K.Jack (Syd)
24. J.Brennan (GCS)
24. S.Burgoyne (Haw)
23. J.Brown (Bris)
22. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
22. J.Riewoldt (Rich)
21. P.Dangerfield (Adel)
21. P.Ryder (Ess)
20. A.Cooney (WB)
19. L.Hansen (NM)
19. J.Podsiadly (Geel)
18. K.Cornes (PA)
18. L.Greenwood (NM)
18. C.Mayne (Frem)
18. R.O'Keefe (Syd)
17. R.Crowley (Frem)
17. S.May (GCS)
17. A.Monfries (Ess)
17. M.Rischitelli (GCS)
16. C.Mooney (Geel)
16. C.Sylvia (Melb)
15. M.Clark (Bris)
15. L.Franklin (Haw)
14. D.Fletcher (Ess)
14. C.Judd (Carl)
14. C.Ling (Geel)
14. D.Motlop (PA)
14. B.Sewell (Haw)
14. R.Sloane (Adel)
14. A.Welsh (Ess)
13. T.Cotchin (Rich)
13. D.Mundy (Frem)
13. C.Stiller (Bris)
12. A.Davey (Ess)
11. J.Kelly (Geel)
11. L.Picken (WB)
11. D.Rich (Bris)
11. B.Stanton (Ess)
9. J.Bartel (Geel)
9. M.Kreuzer (Carl)
9. K.Moore (Rich)
9. J.Westhoff (PA)
8. N.Bock (GCS)
8. A.Goodes (Syd)
8. H.Hartlett (PA)
8. M.Jamar (Melb)
8. C.Jones (St.K)
8. J.McVeigh (Syd)
8. R.Tambling (Adel)
8. T.Varcoe (Geel)
7. H.Ballantyne (Frem)
7. C.Bateman (Haw)
7. D.Brogan (PA)
7. J.Fraser (GCS)
7. B.Reilly (Adel)
7. S.Salopek (PA)
6. J.Anthony (Frem)
6. B.Boyd (WB)
6. N.Dal Santo (St.K)
6. L.Hayes (St.K)
6. J.Schulz (PA)
6. T.Scully (Melb)
6. W.Thursfield (Rich)
6. D.Zaharakis (Ess)
5. T.Boak (PA)
5. A.Graham (Rich)
5. J.Gram (St.K)
5. H.McIntosh (NM)
5. R.Nahas (Rich)
5. C.Newman (Rich)
5. F.Ray (St.K)
5. Z.Smith (GCS)
5. J.Watts (Melb)
4. D.Astbury (Rich)
4. M.Bailey (Haw)
4. T.Banfield (Bris)
4. T.Dennis-Lane (Syd)
4. B.Ebert (PA)
4. N.Fyfe (Frem)
4. J.Green (Bris)
4. B.Hall (WB)
4. S.Johnson (Geel)
4. D.Jolly (Coll)
4. J.Lamb (Syd)
4. B.Maloney (Melb)
4. B.Matera (GCS)
4. B.McLean (Carl)
4. A.Morabito (Frem)
4. R.Murphy (WB)
4. B.Ottens (Geel)
4. J.Selwood (Geel)
3. P.Chapman (Geel)
3. L.Henderson (Carl)
3. M.Luenberger (Bris)
3. B.McEvoy (St.K)
3. S.McKernan (Adel)
3. M.Osborne (Haw)
3. J.Polec (Bris)
3. J.Porplyzia (Adel)
3. B.Schammer (Frem)
2. E.Betts (Carl)
2. S.Byrnes (Geel)
2. M.Campbell (NM)
2. J.Corey (Geel)
2. A.Davey (Melb)
2. Z.Dawson (St.K)
2. J.Grant (WB)
2. L.Jurrah (Melb)
2. D.Kerr (WCE)
2. J.Koschitzke (St.K)
2. N.Krakouer (GCS)
2. J.King (Rich)
2. Q.Lynch (WCE)
2. C.Morton (Melb)
2. R.Petterd (Melb)
2. J.Rivers (Melb)
2. S.Tuck (Rich)
2. J.Winderlich (Ess)
2. D.Wojcinski (Geel)
1. D.Cox (WCE)
1. J.Drummond (Bris)
1. S.Gilbert (St.K)
1. R.Gray (PA)
1. J.Grimes (Melb)
1. J.Gwilt (St.K)
1. D.Hille (Ess)
1. L.Hodge (Haw)
1. B.Houli (Rich)
1. L.Jetta (Ess)
1. N.Jones (Melb)
1. J.Kennedy (WCE)
1. A.McPhee (Frem)
1. J.Pittard (PA)
1. R.Shaw (Syd)
1. D.Swan (Coll)
1. M.Williams (Ess)
1. C.Young (Haw)

 

[Mahama]

I would stick with my Pavlich prediction, and think Thompson and Deledio will do well as standouts in mediocre teams... But we all know Judd has this wrapped up.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 1:
Brisbane v Adelaide
5. K.Tippett (Adel)
5. S.Thompson (Adel)
1. J.Brown (Bris)
1. J.Drummond (Bris)

Western Bulldogs v Geelong
6. J.Podsiadly (Geel)
4. L.Picken (WB)
2. J.Corey (Geel)

Sydney v Collingwood
6. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
4. A.Goodes (Syd)
1. D.Swan (Coll)

St. Kilda v Carlton
6. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
3. J.Waite (Carl)
2. B.Goddard (St.K)
1. J.Koschitzke (St.K)

Hawthorn v North Melbourne
6. L.Hansen (NM)
4. S.Mitchell (Haw)
1. A.Swallow (NM)
1. J.Roughead (Haw)

Fremantle v Richmond
6. A.Sandilands (Frem)
2. K.Moore (Rich)
2. J.Riewoldt (Rich)
2. R.Crowley (Frem)

Port Adelaide v Gold Coast
5. M.Rischitelli (GCS)
4. J.Brennan (GCS)
3. D.Pearce (PA)

Essendon v Melbourne
6. D.Fletcher (Ess)
2. A.Davey (Melb)
2. C.Sylvia (Melb)
2. J.Winderlich (Ess)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 2:

Geelong v St. Kilda
6. B.Goddard (St.K)
2. J.Gram (St.K)
2. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
1. C.Jones (St.K)
1. J.Kelly (Geel)

North Melbourne v Brisbane
6. D.Petrie (NM)
3. L.Hansen (NM)
2. H.McIntosh (NM)
1. A.Swallow (NM)

Carlton v Western Bulldogs
6. J.Waite (Carl)
3. M.Murphy (Carl)
3. L.Picken (WB)

Richmond v Collingwood
6. B.Deledio (Rich)
4. D.Jackson (Rich)
2. J.Riewoldt (Rich)

West Coast v Sydney
6. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
4. K.Jack (Syd)
1. D.Kerr (WCE)

Gold Coast v Fremantle
6. A.Sandilands (Frem)
2. S.Hill (Frem)
2. M.Pavlich (Frem)
1. G.Ablett (GCS)
1. M.Rischitelli (GCS)

Melbourne v Port Adelaide
6. M.Bate (Melb)
3. M.Jamar (Melb)
3. C.Sylvia (Melb)

Adelaide v Essendon
3. B.Stanton (Ess)
3. D.Zaharakis (Ess)
2. C.Knights (Adel)
2. S.Thompson (Adel)
2. J.Watson (Ess)

 

[skill1414]

ROUND 1:

Missing Geel vs WB game?

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 3:

Brisbane v Port Adelaide
6. J.Brown (Bris)
4. K.Cornes (PA)
1. D.Pearce (PA)
1. D.Rich (Bris)

Western Bulldogs v Adelaide
6. K.Tippett (Adel)
4. S.Thompson (Adel)
2. P.Dangerfield (Adel)

Melbourne v West Coast
6. M.Bate (Melb)
4. C.Sylvia (Melb)
2. R.Petterd (Melb)

Hawthorn v Gold Coast
6. G.Ablett (GCS)
3. S.Mitchell (Haw)
3. Z.Smith (GCS)

Collingwood v North Melbourne
No votes awarded

St. Kilda v Sydney
5. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
4. K.Jack (Syd)
3. B.Goddard (St.K)

Fremantle v Carlton
5. J.Waite (Carl)
5. A.Sandilands (Frem)
1. J.Anthony (Frem)
1. S.Hill (Frem)

Richmond v Essendon
4. J.Watson (Ess)
3. D.Jackson (Rich)
3. N.Foley (Rich)
1. B.Deledio (Rich)
1. M.Williams (Ess)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

Missing Geel vs WB game?

Whoops. Sorry mate, bit tired... this is gonna take a while.

Cheers.

 

[skill1414]

No probs. Your doing a good job

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 4:

Carlton v Hawthorn
4. S.Mitchell (Haw)
4. C.Judd (Carl)
4. M.Murphy (Carl)

West Coast v Brisbane
6. J.Brown (Bris)
4. S.Black (Bris)
2. D.Kerr (WCE)

Collingwood v St. Kilda
6. C.Jones (St.K)
4. B.Goddard (St.K)
2. N.Riewoldt (St.K)

North Melbourne v Western Bulldogs
6. D.Petrie (NM)
4. B.Harvey (NM)
2. A.Swallow (NM)

Adelaide v Fremantle
5. C.Knights (Adel)
4. C.Mayne (Frem)
3. A.Sandilands (Frem)

Gold Coast v Geelong
5. N.Bock (GCS)
5. G.Ablett (GCS)
1. J.Selwood (Geel)
1. J.Podsiadly (Geel)

Sydney v Essendon
4. K.Jack (Syd)
3. M.Hurley (Ess)
3. J.Watson (Ess)
2. D.Bradshaw (Syd)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

So 4 rounds in and the top of the leaderboard is as follows:

20. A.Sandilands (Frem)
19. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
15. B.Goddard (St.K)
14. J.Waite (Carl)
13. J.Brown (Bris)
12. G.Ablett (GCS)
12. M.Bate (Melb)
12. K.Jack (Syd)
12. D.Petrie (NM)
11. S.Mitchell (Haw)
11. S.Thompson (Adel)
11. K.Tippett (Adel)

No surprises to see Sandilands poll well. He'll do so all year due to his dominance and Fremantle's near unbeaten season. Bradshaw an early surprise, but the Swans won their first 4. Their form starts to get patchy now. Goddard and Waite both around the mark.

Surprising to see a lot of key position players heading the board. Perhaps a sign that their impact equals more than the accumulation of the midfielders. Ablett, Jack, Mitchell and Thompson thereabouts as the ballwinners polling well.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

And if it takes me an hour to do four rounds, I may spread this out over a few days. Will see how I go for the time being.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 5:

Carlton v West Coast
6. M.Murphy (Carl)
2. M.Kreuzer (Carl)
2. L.Henderson (Carl)
1. J.Kennedy (WCE)
1. Q.Lynch (WCE)

Port Adelaide v Richmond
6. N.Foley (Rich)
3. R.Nahas (Rich)
2. J.Schulz (PA)
1. K.Cornes (PA)

Sydney v Hawthorn
5. L.Franklin (Haw)
5. S.Burgoyne (Haw)
1. M.Bailey (Haw)
1. R.O'Keefe (Syd)

Geelong v Collingwood
No votes awarded

North Melbourne v Fremantle
6. M.Pavlich (Frem)
4. B.Harvey (NM)
2. A.Sandilands (Frem)

Essendon v St. Kilda
4. M.Hurley (Ess)
4. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
4. N.Riewoldt (St.K)

Gold Coast v Melbourne
4. T.Scully (Melb)
3. M.Jamar (Melb)
3. M.Bate (Melb)
2. G.Ablett (GCS)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 6:

Western Bulldogs v Brisbane
6. A.Cooney (WB)
4. R.Murphy (WB)
2. S.Black (WB)

Adelaide v Sydney
6. C.Knights (Adel)
4. S.Thompson (Adel)
2. D.Bradshaw (Syd)

Geelong v Carlton
4. T.Varcoe (Geel)
3. C.Ling (Geel)
3. J.Selwood (Geel)
2. J.Podsiadly (Geel)

Collingwood v Port Adelaide
No votes awarded

Hawthorn v Richmond
4. L.Franklin (Haw)
3. J.Roughead (Haw)
2. S.Mitchell (Haw)
2. M.Bailey (Haw)
1. A.Graham (Rich)

Essendon v West Coast
5. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
4. P.Ryder (Ess)
2. A.Monfries (Ess)
1. L.Jetta (Ess)

St. Kilda v Melbourne
6. M.Bate (Melb)
2. L.Jurrah (Melb)
2. T.Scully (Melb)
1. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
1. J.Grimes (Melb)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 7:

West Coast v Port Adelaide
6. S.Salopek (PA)
4. B.Ebert (PA)
1. D.Cox (WCE)

Brisbane v Hawthorn
4. D.Rich (Bris)
3. J.Polec (Bris)
2. S.Black (Bris)
2. S.Mitchell (Haw)
1. M.Bailey (Haw)

Richmond v Sydney
4. A.Goodes (Syd)
4. R.O'Keefe (Syd)
2. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
2. D.Jackson (Rich)

Carlton v North Melbourne
6. A.Swallow (NM)
4. D.Petrie (NM)
2. B.Harvey (NM)

Collingwood v Gold Coast
6. J.Fraser (GCS)
4. J.Brennan (GCS)
2. G.Ablett (GCS)

Fremantle v Geelong
5. M.Pavlich (Frem)
5. R.Crowley (Frem)
1. A.Sandilands (Frem)
1. J.Anthony (Frem)

Essendon v Western Bulldogs
6. M.Hurley (Ess)
4. J.Watson (Ess)
2. A.Monfries (Ess)

Melbourne v Adelaide
6. S.Thompson (Adel)
4. P.Dangerfield (Adel)
2. J.Porplyzia (Adel)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 8:

Geelong v Brisbane
4. M.Clark (Bris)
3. M.Luenberger (Bris)
3. T.Banfield (Bris)
2. D.Wojcinski (Geel)

Fremantle v St. Kilda
5. A.Sandilands (Frem)
3. D.Mundy (Frem)
3. B.McEvoy (St.K)
1. R.Crowley (Frem)

Hawthorn v West Coast
6. S.Mitchell (Haw)
4. S.Burgoyne (Haw)
2. J.Roughead (Haw)

Port Adelaide v Essendon
4. D.Motlop (PA)
3. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
3. A.Welsh (Ess)
2. D.Pearce (PA)
1. H.Hartlett (PA)

Adelaide v Carlton
6. J.Waite (Carl)
4. C.Judd (Carl)
1. C.Knights (Adel)
1. L.Henderson (Carl)

North Melbourne v Richmond
5. N.Foley (Rich)
3. H.McIntosh (NM)
2. J.King (Rich)
2. D.Petrie (NM)

Melbourne v Collingwood
No votes awarded

Western Bulldogs v Gold Coast
6. S.May (GCS)
4. G.Ablett (GCS)
2. B.Hall (WB)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

So the top 10 on the leaderboard:
28. A.Sandilands (Frem)
23. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
21. M.Bate (Melb)
21. S.Mitchell (Haw)
21. S.Thompson (Adel)
20. G.Ablett (GCS)
20. J.Waite (Carl)
18. D.Petrie (NM)
15. B.Goddard (St.K)
15. N.Riewoldt (St.K)

Sandilands retains and extends his lead over Bradshaw. Mitchell and Thompson big movers to jump up into contention. Bate and Ablett steady in attracting votes.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 9:

Hawthorn v Western Bulldogs
6. J.Roughead (Haw)
4. S.Mitchell (Haw)
2. B.Sewell (Haw)

West Coast v Geelong
6. J.Podsiadly (Geel)
4. C.Ling (Geel)
2. S.Johnson (Geel)

Richmond v Melbourne
6. W.Thursfield (Rich)
4. C.Newman (Rich)
1. C.Sylvia (Melb)

Adelaide v Collingwood
6. R.Tambling (Adel)
4. S.Thompson (Adel)
2. C.Knights (Adel)

Fremantle v North Melbourne
6. A.Swallow (NM)
4. B.Harvey (NM)
2. D.Petrie (NM)

Sydney v Port Adelaide
6. K.Cornes (PA)
4. D.Motlop (PA)
1. T.Dennis-Lane (Syd)
1. R.Gray (PA)

Gold Coast v Essendon
4. J.Watson (Ess)
4. G.Ablett (GCS)
3. A.Monfries (Ess)
1. N.Bock (GCS)

Brisbane v St. Kilda
6. L.Montagna (St.K)
3. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
3. C.Stiller (St.K)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 10:

Hawthorn v Port Adelaide
6. D.Pearce (PA)
2. D.Brogan (PA)
2. J.Westhoff (PA)
1. J.Roughead (Haw)
1. S.Mitchell (Haw)

Geelong v Adelaide
6. K.Tippett (Adel)
3. J.Podsiadly (Geel)
2. J.Kelly (Geel)
1. B.Reilly (Adel)

Brisbane v Sydney
5. J.McVeigh (Syd)
3. R.O'Keefe (Syd)
3. T.Dennis-Lane (Syd)
1. R.Shaw (Syd)

Collingwood v Carlton
No votes awarded

St. Kilda v Western Bulldogs
6. L.Hayes (St.K)
4. A.Cooney (WB)
2. Z.Dawson (St.K)

West Coast v Fremantle
6. M.Pavlich (Frem)
4. H.Ballantyne (Frem)
2. S.Hill (Frem)

Gold Coast v Richmond
6. B.Deledio (Rich)
3. J.Riewoldt (Rich)
2. N.Foley (Rich)
1. S.May (GCS)

Melbourne v North Melbourne
4. L.Hansen (NM)
3. J.Watts (Melb)
1. N.Jones (Melb)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 11:

Port Adelaide v Adelaide
5. D.Pearce (PA)
3. D.Motlop (PA)
2. D.Brogan (PA)
1. S.Salopek (PA)
1. H.Hartlett (PA)

Western Bulldogs v West Coast
No votes awarded

St. Kilda v Richmond
6. B.Deledio (Rich)
4. L.Montagna (St.K)
2. D.Astbury (Rich)

Carlton v Sydney
6. K.Jack (Syd)
3. R.O'keefe (Syd)
3. C.Judd (Carl)

Essendon v Brisbane
3. P.Ryder (Ess)
3. D.Fletcher (Ess)
3. D.Zaharakis (Ess)
2. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
1. D.Hille (Ess)

North Melbourne v Gold Coast
6. J.Brennan (GCS)
2. D.Petrie (NM)
2. A.Swallow (NM)
1. L.Hansen (NM)
1. G.Ablett (GCS)

Fremantle v Melbourne
6. A.Sandilands (Frem)
4. A.Morabito (Frem)
2. C.Mayne (Frem)

Geelong v Hawthorn
5. J.Roughead (Haw)
5. C.Mooney (Geel)
1. L.Franklin (Haw)
1. S.Burgoyne (Haw)

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

ROUND 12:

Port Adelaide v Geelong
3. D.Pearce (PA)
3. C.Mooney (Geel)
3. J.Bartel (Geel)
2. J.Schulz (PA)
1. J.Podsiadly (Geel)

Richmond v Brisbane
6. S.Black (Bris)
2. N.Foley (Rich)
2. R.Nahas (Rich)
1. J.Brown (Bris)
1. B.Houli (Rich)

Adelaide v North Melbourne
6. P.Dangerfield (Adel)
4. B.Harvey (NM)
2. K.Tippett (Adel)

Sydney v Fremantle
6. S.Hill (Frem)
4. J.Anthony (Frem)
2. H.Ballantyne (Frem)

Carlton v Gold Coast
5. G.Ablett (GCS)
4. S.May (GCS)
2. Z.Smith (GCS)
1. M.Rischitelli (GCS)

St. Kilda v Hawthorn
6. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
4. L.Montagna (St.K)
1. S.Mitchell (Haw)
1. L.Franklin (Haw)

Collingwood v Essendon
6. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
4. D.Jolly (Coll)
2. B.Stanton (Ess)

Western Bulldogs v Melbourne
No votes awarded

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

The top 10 on the leaderboard after 12 rounds is:
34. A.Sandilands (Frem)
30. G.Ablett (GCS)
27. S.Mitchell (Haw)
25. S.Thompson (Adel)
24. N.Riewoldt (St.K)
23. D.Bradshaw (Syd)
22. D.Petrie (NM)
21. M.Bate (Melb)
20. S.Gumbleton (Ess)
20. D.Pearce (PA)
20. J.Waite (Carl)

Sandilands holds his lead but his scoring is slowing. Big Fremantle wins could see votes spread, particularly as they have the league's leading goalscorer. Ablett has closed the gap to be ouright second, but the Suns only win 4 more games for the season. Will that count against him? Mitchell and Thompson not as prolific as the previous rounds, while Bradshaw and Bate have dried up. Nick Riewoldt the other big mover and not without a chance. The Saints come home strongly and a lot of their losses are tight ones.

It will be an interesting final 12 rounds, but I'll have to call it a night. Will try and continue this tomorrow.

Comments are very much welcome.

 

[HBK619]

It's interesting to see the voting and how people perceived the match, not a ton of parallel voting going on.

Although I believe there's a mistake here jorel.

ROUND 9:
Richmond v Melbourne
6. W.Thursfield (Rich)
4. C.Newman (Rich)
1. C.Sylvia (Melb)

Pretty sure that don't add up. Unless a vote wasn't added?

 

[BlackMamba]

Nice work jorel.... Looking forward to part 2 of the count soon. Good work spending all this time on the season.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

HBK - Stakerz didn't submit votes. So only votes for your players were doubled. There will be a few instances of this, unfortunately.

 

[SugarShane]

Very interesting read. I had nothing to do with the comp but this kind of thing is pretty interesting. Hope Scotty Thompson had a big second half of the year.