That one came from a poster on our board. It really seems far too much in your favour. Drop the pick going to you guys and it seems more on the money IMO.
Bryce Gibbs staying at Carlton - Silvagni in the no blinking zone
- Thread starter Malifice
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
We screwed ourselves with Jacobs and Betts.
Can we stop with the ridiculous suggestions of Crouch?
Now THIS is a ******* rebuild!
Last edited by a moderator:
I wonder what we'll get for him?!?
Those two shocking deals were ENTIRELY Carlton's fault. Well played Crows for seeing value and seizing the opportunities.
I know Crows fans would baulk at McGovern but I don't see why he should be off the table...they are in desperate need of a mid like Gibbs and McGoven, while a quality prospect, probably isn't in their best 22.
BluStreak
Norm Smith Medallist
IMO, no ******* way do we send anything extra with Gibbs.
He is worth their first round pick and a best 22 player.
Lever or Talia.
He is worth their first round pick and a best 22 player.
Lever or Talia.
Last edited by a moderator:
Dreaming on Lever or Talia. What else they got that's under 23 and can play?
McGovern
8Special K
Senior List
How is it that ridiculous, he's contracted and Victorian just as Gibbs is contracted and South Australian
He's an unprofessional flog and injury prone?
8Special K
Senior List
Tambourine
Team Captain
- Jul 2, 2016
- 315
- 524
- AFL Club
- Carlton
When the wife speaks she usually gets what she wants. Poor gibbs.
- Feb 11, 2015
- 5,050
- 8,339
- AFL Club
- Carlton
To be honest, I'm not mad at all. I respect Bryce's decision. Besides he is worth more now than he ever will be in the future.
It will hurt the club greatly moving forward, but this is what a rebuild is meant to be, starting again from the roots and finding the green shoots.
However, that does leave Patrick Cripps, Marc Murphy and Ed Curnow as our main midfielders at the moment which is deeply concerning, given that one is carrying the team, another is edging towards retirement and one is more of a b-grade defensive soldier than a-grade talent.
This comes to show that we need to take advantage in the draft and find the next generation of Carlton midfielders to help Cripps out. Try our best to develop Cuningham and not worry too much about the forward line until every other area is properly addressed (I'd still like for us to obtain Stewart though).
It will hurt the club greatly moving forward, but this is what a rebuild is meant to be, starting again from the roots and finding the green shoots.
However, that does leave Patrick Cripps, Marc Murphy and Ed Curnow as our main midfielders at the moment which is deeply concerning, given that one is carrying the team, another is edging towards retirement and one is more of a b-grade defensive soldier than a-grade talent.
This comes to show that we need to take advantage in the draft and find the next generation of Carlton midfielders to help Cripps out. Try our best to develop Cuningham and not worry too much about the forward line until every other area is properly addressed (I'd still like for us to obtain Stewart though).
Last edited:
GC would not agree to that.
Personally don't want to lose Gibbs, but if we do this is the best suggestion so far!
- Oct 28, 2014
- 9,912
- 24,137
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
He played every game bar 1, and that was a rest! If he goes anywhere Id suggest it will be WA.
As long as it means we don't trade pick 5 for Marchbank I'm ok with this
He played every game bar 1, and that was a rest! If he goes anywhere Id suggest it will be WA.
Fair cop, I didn't realise he was quite that established. Still, you have depth in that area.
straight swap for Eddie Betts xo
If he doesn't win a flag, much like Camporeale, he has sold his football identity. I'm no mad at him (I have stopped following him on Twitter, that'll keep him up at night), but I am looking forward to a day when players come to us to win a premiership before they retire.
Sent from my D6653 using Tapatalk
Sent from my D6653 using Tapatalk
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
