List Mgmt. Carlton's 2018 Draft Thread (cont. in Part 2)

[smashbox gill]

not keen on Hately. Never have been.

Fine take out Hately (proabably to similar to Kennedy anyway) and replace with RCD/O'Halloran/Taylor

Im hoping we do a deal with Adelaide. I would hazard a guess MM would be part of it somehow.

MM, Pick 8 and 13 i would do. Pick up Rozee and RCD would be my preference. Lukocious for those 3

 

[Blue_Fusion]

After Doc went down, how many games did you think we would win?

Not many. I didn't sit there and think to myself shit, now we'll only win X amount of games. I knew we'd definitely struggle with our back line though.

Our biggest problem stopping us from winning games is our midfield. Doc is not going to change that. With the loss of Gibbs, I would have expected 4-5 wins this year. After Doc injury, less but as I said, I didn't put a number to it.

 

[Arr0w]

Players like Valente are often seen as having a high floor but low ceiling. Rozee, Collier-Dawkins etc area lot flashier and have the higher ceiling but sometimes the lower floor. Think Valente would be a super pick, having a high floor should never really be seen as a flaw in my opinion which is what recruiters seem to do quite often. They pick for potential or athleticism rather than picking the best footballer.

And great leadership

 

[Arr0w]

Not many. I didn't sit there and think to myself shit, now we'll only win X amount of games. I knew we'd definitely struggle with our back line though.

Our biggest problem stopping us from winning games is our midfield. Doc is not going to change that. With the loss of Gibbs, I would have expected 4-5 wins this year. After Doc injury, less but as I said, I didn't put a number to it.

So where will we finish next year? Take a shot at an actual ladder position rather than saying bottom 2 or 4 or 6

 

[Blue_Fusion]

I don't not like Rankine, I just don't think he worth a top draft pick. I have my money on him being the slider this year.

What is it about him that makes you think he'll slide or not worthy of a top pick?

 

[Blue_Fusion]

So where will we finish next year? Take a shot at an actual ladder position rather than saying bottom 2 or 4 or 6

Dude, I literally just posted that we're likely to finish last. Must I place imo tags on every post even though it's obvious?

Oh, that OPINION is subject to what we do during trade period. I'll reassess after that.

 

[Arr0w]

Dude, I literally just posted that we're likely to finish last. Must I place imo tags on every post even though it's obvious?

Okay great

If we finish last, I will donate a membership to the Starlight Foundation

If we don't you can donate it

Deal?

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Fine take out Hately (proabably to similar to Kennedy anyway) and replace with RCD/O'Halloran/Taylor


MM, Pick 8 and 13 i would do. Pick up Rozee and RCD would be my preference. Lukocious for those 3

I would be happy with that. Before picking RCD, I would see what GCS would want for Brodie first. I would certainly consider giving them 13/ a PP 19 for Brodie, assuming the previously posted rumours about him are factual.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

What is it about him that makes you think he'll slide or not worthy of a top pick?

Gut feel really. Has a natural talent without a doubt, Im just not getting that gut busting, hard working ethic feel about him. Its how I always thought about Harley Bennel. Naturally talented, just didn't/ doesn't work hard enough, it gets found out eventually.

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Okay great

If we finish last, I will donate a membership to the Starlight Foundation

If we don't you can donate it

Deal?

Starlight Foundation is great I donate anyway. I'll make a $300 donation even if we finish last. If you have the financial capacity, you should donate to them anyway instead of using this nonsensical bet as a reason.

 

[bigdog43]

And great leadership

Part of me wants to take Walsh, Valente and O'Halloran with our first three picks so that we have the Vic Country, Vic Metro and South Australian captains.

 

[Arr0w]

Starlight Foundation is great I donate anyway. I'll make a $300 donation even if we finish last. If you have the financial capacity, you should donate to them anyway instead of using this nonsensical bet as a reason.

Hahaha I already do donate

Okay it's a deal then, $300?

 

[smashbox gill]

I would be happy with that. Before picking RCD, I would see what GCS would want for Brodie first. I would certainly consider giving them 13/ a PP 19 for Brodie, assuming the previously posted rumours about him are factual.

Not sure i'd give up 13 for Brodie. Hasnt set the world on fire up there id give PP(18) and maybe a 2nd rounder

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Hahaha I already do donate

Okay it's a deal then, $300?

Sure.

 

[Arr0w]

Part of me wants to take Walsh, Valente and O'Halloran with our first three picks so that we have the Vic Country, Vic Metro and South Australian captains.

All good players, but would like a bit of toe as well

Rozee, Turner and McHenry are also appealing

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Not sure i'd give up 13 for Brodie. Hasnt set the world on fire up there id give PP(18) and maybe a 2nd rounder

I think Brodie would excel playing next to Patrick Cripps. I wanted us to draft him ahead of SPS.

 

[Arr0w]

Sure.

Done

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Done

Let's just make it clear that for the sake of $300, I'm not HOPING we finish last.

 

[Arr0w]

I think Brodie would excel playing next to Patrick Cripps. I wanted us to draft him ahead of SPS.

Don't rate him, just lacks polish and hurt factor

I hope the rumour is false

 

[Arr0w]

Let's just make it clear that for the sake of $300, I'm not HOPING we finish last.

Happy to make it $1000?

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Don't rate him, just lacks polish and hurt factor

I hope the rumour is false

If the rumour is false I wont lose sleep over it, would happily select RCD instead. That said, I still like Brodie.

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Happy to make it $1000?

Ok. Let's make it 1k. But I know where you're trying to go here, thinking that I'm going to hope that we finish last so I don't pay.

I just hope you don't back out.

 

[smashbox gill]

Dream scenario for me would be Pick 1 & ADE 2nd rounder for Pick 8, 13 and MM.
Pick 8 on Rozee, Pick 13 on RCD/O'Halloran, Pick 18(PP) on McHenry/Caldwell, Pick 22 on Zac Butters

Plowman Weitering Macredie
Williamson Marchbank Docherty
Obrien Kennedy Rozee
SPS Curnow Fisher
Pickett Mckay McHenry
TDK Cripps Dow
IC: RCD Cunningham Butters

 

[Arr0w]

Ok. Let's make it 1k. But I know where you're trying to go here, thinking that I'm going to hope that we finish last so I don't pay.

I just hope you don't back out.

Done, $1000 it is

 

[Blues90]

So where will we finish next year? Take a shot at an actual ladder position rather than saying bottom 2 or 4 or 6

22th.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app