Carltons 3 no 1 draft picks.

[SA HAWK]

All 3 look like being stars of the competition for some time.

The question is who do you think will have the best career out of the 3 by the end of their careers?

I vote gibbs.

 

[bluesforever]

Gibbs has shown lately how good he can become. Murphy and Kreuz will be stars but Gibbs could be a SUPERstar in a couple of years.

 

[Thunderstruck]

Been saying it for ages but Gibbs. Is just an exquisite footballer and still improving. Makes others look hapless with the time he has with the ball. Will retire one of the champions of the game.

 

[OniAu]

its worrying all three are in the same team, can you imagine them at around 24 25. going to be a dangerous team in 5 years time when tehy are all at their peak

 

[Young Gun #6]

Easily Gibbs. Bit hard to tell yet though. Murhpy will have a fine career but haven't seen enough of Kruzier to judge.

And who's to say Gubbs might just do a ACl and retire?

 

[patto_man]

well that gay i was the first to vote for kreuzer

 

[Team Mo']

And who's to say Gubbs might just do a ACl and retire?

What?

Why even say that?

 

[Young Gun #6]

What?

Why even say that?

I'm just saying you can't judge who will be better in 10 years because what if one retires or gets majorly injured?

 

[Dave The Man]

Matthew Kreuzer

 

[murph#3]

What?

Why even say that?

no he's got a point. as much as it hurts talking about it it applies for every player. at the moment, everyone knows gibbs will be a champion of the game some even know that he will probably be the standout player of the competition one day but one injury and that could be the end of that. look what happened to graham polak and peter motley (the latter was extremely similar to gibbs).

 

[Heater39]

1.Gibbs
2.Kreuzer
3.Murphy

Even though Murphs my favourite of the three he doesn't quite have the ability of Gibbs and Kreuzer

 

[McManus2Waterhouse]

definitely gibbs will be a superstar

kruezer looks like he could be great

murphy looks like a flat out dud king of the turn over goes missing when it counts

 

[Artie Bucco]

1. Gibbs, will be that special player that makes things happen with minimal disposal

2. Kruezer, Looks like he can play anywhere...personally haven't seen an 18 year old ruckman ever look so comfortable at AFL level.

3. Murphy, Workhorse player. Might need to add another dimension to his game to step up to elite. Looks like being a gun


So happy with those three

 

[Young Gun #6]

1. Gibbs, will be that special player that makes things happen with minimal disposal

2. Kruezer, Looks like he can play anywhere...personally haven't seen an 18 year old ruckman ever look so comfortable at AFL level.

3. Murphy, Workhorse player. Might need to add another dimension to his game to step up to elite. Looks like being a gun


So happy with those three

You will next year.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Probably Squibbs.

 

[Silvagnis]

Isn't Kreuzer Richmond's number one pick?

A bit like Goddard.

Kreuzer will be the number one pick who has the most impact on Carlton's future.

A great big man always beats a good small man and makes his teammates walk taller.

 

[jonoman89]

Can't choose yet. They all have so much potential.

 

[The Grover]

Gibbs easily.

 

[Hawkk]

Very difficult to compare them until there into their 4th or 5th seasons.

Deledio looked like an out and out superstar after his first season and a half, but stalled somewhat as he had to learn how to deal with excess attention from opposition coaches.

With that said, what's that old saying, midfielders are plentiful but quality talls are a dim dozen. On that alone I'd probably take Kreuzer over Gibbs (who has the mobiltiy and height to play both as a midfielder and as KPP) over Murphy (who is confined to the midfield based on his stature)

As it stands, Murphy's been in the system the longest and is stating to produce serious results, though Gibbs and Kreuzer will probably end up having more influence assuming they continue to improve