Carlton's top ten

[marcmurphy3]

Who would be in your top ten players at the club right now.
Mine would go like this:

1. Fevola
2. Murphy
3. Scotland
4. Simpson
5. Kouta
6. Stevens
7. Whitnall
8. Walker
9. Waite
10. Thornton

 

[Jeremias]

1. Fevola
2. Murphy
3. Whitnall
4. Scotland
5. Simpson
6. Koutoufides
7. Walker
8. Waite
9. Thornton
10. Lappin or Stevens

 

[deano the hawka]

1. Fevola
2. Murphy
3. Whitnall
4. Scotland
5. Simpson
6. Koutoufides
7. Walker
8. Waite
9. Thornton
10. Lappin or Stevens

to be honest...that looks like a pretty decent top 10 players....i thought all carlton players were crap with sum exceptions...but i gess i was rong...

BTW...this is a non-troll speeking

 

[Jeremias]

to be honest...that looks like a pretty decent top 10 players....i thought all carlton players were crap with sum exceptions...but i gess i was rong...

BTW...this is a non-troll speeking

We are now starting to get a pretty good bunch of players together. 2 more drafts, and we will have an excellent bunch of kids, and also an excellent bunch of middle aged players, eg. Simpson, Walker etc. as leaders. Older players will be the likes of Scotland, Fevola, Whitnall and Stevens.

Once we get the players, our rise will commence

We are almost ready to start.

 

[Johnny_3]

to be honest...that looks like a pretty decent top 10 players....i thought all carlton players were crap with sum exceptions...but i gess i was rong...

BTW...this is a non-troll speeking

non troll pfft.. "all players are crap exept some... but im not trolling" please dont be a joke

id say in no order atm our best 10 on performance are

fev, scotland, whitnall, murphy, walker, simpson, thorton, houlihan, stevens, kouta..
on potential i have
1. Murphy
2. Waite
3. Fevola
4. Murphy
5. Walker
6. Whitnall
7. Stevens
8. Houlihan
9. Sentanta
10. Bryan
and i know the last 2 on that list arent rated highly in somes views, and many of you are wondering why simpson isn't in there. On potential those are my best, and i just think simpsons football package isn't as good as Waite's for one reason, waite could be (now i know this may seem a bit biast and some would label me as very stupid buttt) a more athletic wayne carey, wheather its injury or lack of effort i rate waite extremely high and id hate to see it go to waste. I wanna see some domination nations by carey in the near future.

 

[murph#3]

1-fevola
2-murphy
3-simpson
4-stevens
5-scotland
6-whitnall
7-walker
8-waite
9-thornton
10-lappin

 

[murph#3]

on potential i have
1. Murphy
2. Waite
3. Fevola
4. Murphy
5. Walker
6. Whitnall
7. Stevens
8. Houlihan
9. Sentanta
10. Bryan

lol we know the kid's got heaps of potential...but that's just taking it too far!!

 

[Salaryman]

Fevola
Lance
Stevens
Murphy
Waite
Simpson
Walker
Thornton
Lappin
and




Gibbs

 

[Feva]

non troll pfft.. "all players are crap exept some... but im not trolling" please dont be a joke

id say in no order atm our best 10 on performance are

fev, scotland, whitnall, murphy, walker, simpson, thorton, houlihan, stevens, kouta..
on potential i have
1. Murphy
2. Waite
3. Fevola
4. Murphy
5. Walker
6. Whitnall
7. Stevens
8. Houlihan
9. Sentanta
10. Bryan
and i know the last 2 on that list arent rated highly in somes views, and many of you are wondering why simpson isn't in there. On potential those are my best, and i just think simpsons football package isn't as good as Waite's for one reason, waite could be (now i know this may seem a bit biast and some would label me as very stupid buttt) a more athletic wayne carey, wheather its injury or lack of effort i rate waite extremely high and id hate to see it go to waste. I wanna see some domination nations by carey in the near future.

On potential you have Houlihan ahead of Simpson!

You have a player that will probably play his last season for CFC next year or the year after, as opposed to Simpson who will probably one day captain (or at least vice captain) the club. Very confusing.

 

[westbrom]

non troll pfft.. "all players are crap exept some... but im not trolling" please dont be a joke

I think the quote was a fair assesment. The average supporter who sees Carlton 1-2 a year and reads the paper to see us getting flogged, would think our entire list is ****ed with 2-3 exceptions.

I think some people are too precious sometimes

 

[HBF]

Mine would look something like this:

1. Fevola
2. Whitnall
3. Simpson
4. Stevens
5. Murphy
6. Waite
7. Fisher
8. Thornton
9. Scotland
10. Walker

 

[BlueBelle]

Walker
Simmo
Murphy
Whitnall
Fev
Scotland
Houlihan
Stevens
Kouta
Lappin

 

[HBF]

Walker
Simmo
Murphy
Whitnall
Fev
Scotland
Houlihan
Stevens
Kouta
Lappin

What an "unbiased" view BG!

 

[Jeremias]

What an "unbiased" view BG!

Unbiased?

Would you prefer it if she put some WCE players or Crows in there instead?

 

[Aussie Joe]

1. Fevola
2. Whitnall
3. Stevens
4. Scotland
5. Simpson
6. Murphy
7. Walker
8. Thornton
9. Houlihan
10. Lappin

 

[BlueBelle]

What an "unbiased" view BG!

Well they aren't in any order HBF

Are your preferences in order? If they are then I have a bone to pick with you regarding where you have put Walks!!

 

[bluey#4]

We are now starting to get a pretty good bunch of players together. 2 more drafts, and we will have an excellent bunch of kids, and also an excellent bunch of middle aged players, eg. Simpson, Walker etc. as leaders. Older players will be the likes of Scotland, Fevola, Whitnall and Stevens.

Once we get the players, our rise will commence

We are almost ready to start.

Actually quite amazing looking at that list of 10 players and then looking at the success the team has had in recent years.
I cant wait for the day when we turn this potential of a great team into a great team

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

1. Fevola
2. Whitnall
3. Stevens
4. Scotland
5. Simpson
6. Murphy
7. Walker
8. Thornton
9. Houlihan
10. Lappin

Agree with all except for Houlihan

 

[AndyWalkersGirl]

1. Simpson
2. Fevola
3. Walker
4. Lance
5. Scotland
6. Murphy
7. Thornton
8. Stevens - he'll lift next year!
9. Kouta
10. Houlihan