Changes for R7 v Suns

[getgaff]

IN: Lycett
OUT: McInnes/Sinclair

Think that will be a popular view this week

 

[getgaff]

Don't think Ellis is right yet. I'd like to see him have a game for EP first as well.

 

[kaiserchief13]

When is Darling back?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

This thread shouldn't be started until the game is finished.

Out: Bennell (unlucky)
In: Rosa

B: Nelson, McGovern, Butler
HB: Hurn, Schofield, Wellingham
C: Gaff, Priddis, Rosa
HF: LeCras, McInnes, Cripps
F: Hill, Kennedy, Sinclair
R: Naitanui, Shuey, Yeo
I: Sheppard, Masten, Sheed
S: Duggan
E: Lycett, Bennell, Hutchings

Came down to Bennell or Nelson to make way for Rosa.

Duggs back to sub as part of his management.

Keep persisting with the Naita/Sinclair/McInnes combination for now, Sinclair lifted in the second half.

 

[Matele]

Out: Sinclair (crab), Bennell (omitted)

In: Lycett, Rosa

Start Nelson over Butler. (Purely a management thing).

 

[Patron]

Sinclair actually competed really well in the second half. That said he or Mcinnes must go and I feel Mcinnes is more likely to be factor going forward so,

Out: Sinclair
In: Lycett

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Out: McInnes, Sinclair, Bennell
In: Colledge, Lycett, Rosa

B: Nelson - McGovern - Butler
HB: Hurn - Schofield - Wellingham
C: Gaff - Priddis - Rosa
HF: LeCras - Kennedy - Masten
F: Hill - Lycett - Cripps

R: Naitanui - Shuey - Yeo

Int: Sheppard - Duggan - Sheed

Sub: Colledge

 

[SpaceClef]

IN: Lucas
OUT: Duggan (susp.)

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

No chance Duggan gets suspended.

If it's reportable he'll get a fine at most.

 

[Gunther999]

Sinclair actually competed really well in the second half. That said he or Mcinnes must go and I feel Mcinnes is more likely to be factor going forward so,

Out: Sinclair
In: Lycett

Out McInnnes

In Rosa.

Bennell to sub. Let's have the Full Nelson.

Lycett to do his penance a while longer as he's been ragdolled in the ruck this year. Completely uncompetitive. Let him breath fire and champing at the bit in the WAFL before rewarding him.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

No change for mine.

Though Rosa will be fit and I wouldn't be surprised to see Bennell left out for him and Nelson head down back. Rosa to get the job on Bennell

Nelson looked all at sea up the ground.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

No chance Duggan gets suspended.

If it's reportable he'll get a fine at most.

A) he didn't get him high

b) he had his hands out to pick up the ball

no dramas, would even be surprised if they mentioned in their gameday reports.

 

[Turky]

Out: Masten
In: Someone with decent disposal efficiency.

73% DE is pretty decent!

 

[dext]

IN: Lucas
OUT: Duggan (susp.)

Ay?? Should have been a free kick to duggan for taking his legs

 

[Keys]

I haven't watched the game yet but did hear Simpson say he was very happy with sinclairs efforts in the ruck in the second half after naitanui struggled to have an influence in the first

Now I have no idea as to how accurate this summation is but if that's the view of the coach then I think it's doubtful Sinclair is dropped

Ellis hasn't played for over 2 months so I can't see him coming straight back into a winning side

Rosa a good chance as he seems a Simpson favourite although I can't say who deserves to be replaced

None of the players who played for East Perth had games that demanded elevation IMO

 

[jaxxon]

Surely we can't play both McInnes and Sinclair, both were invisible for much of the match, except for when Sinclair was just giving the ball back to Port at every opportunity. I'd prefer both out, but structurally we do look better with a second KPF.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

None of the players who played for East Perth had games that demanded elevation IMO

In theory, who would be the next few cabs off the rank?

Colledge and Waterman?

 

[Keys]

IN: Lucas
OUT: Duggan (susp.)

I saw Lucas play yesterday

If he comes into the seniors on the back of that game I'll punch somebody

 

[SpaceClef]

Ay?? Should have been a free kick to duggan for taking his legs

You just never know with the MRP

 

[SpaceClef]

I saw Lucas play yesterday

If he comes into the seniors on the back of that game I'll punch somebody

Pretty weird how you punch people when you're ecstatic

 

[Stereophonic]

Get in early.

In rosa Lycett waterman into the 25 man squad

 

[Smotie]

Dont want to bring back any returning injured midfielders tbh. The midfield is playing well. How do we change it after we just had our best win for some years?

 

[Keys]

In theory, who would be the next few cabs off the rank?

Colledge and Waterman?

Hutchings was our best player for East Perth yesterday so I'd say it's between him and colledge

Waterman is still short of the required tank for AFL and should be allowed to develop his game at WAFL level for the time being. He does look promising

Lycett went ok but it will depend on whether the match committee think he's worked hard enough on the issues that saw him dropped which I'm guessing was not competing hard enough. If I'm right on that he's not quite there yet

 

[Keys]

Pretty weird how you punch people when you're ecstatic

I was talking about the East Perth game yesterday. Lucas doesn't deserve to come in after his performance in that game especially considering our great win today

To bring him in then would be dumb and I'd want to punch the person responsible

 

[Turky]

Out - Sinclair Bennel
In - Rosa and Nelson full game time?
I don't think we'll need to have two rucks against the GC inexperienced Smith + Nicholls recent line up. We only really needed it against GWS's mummy and Ports Lobbe + Ryder. Unless one of our rucks are making an impact on the score board in which Natanui and Sinclair had a combined effort of one goal assist.