Prediction Changes for Semi Final v GWS

[peterss]

Bring it on!!

Discuss away peeps

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I can see them going unchanged again.

The only player I'd seriously consider dropping would be Le Cras, but Rioli would probably be too big a risk. Naitanui punt isn't needed with Petters and Vardy doing well. I thought Partington was valuable with his pressure tonight.

Unchanged it is.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Duggan has got to be seriously thought about for the match committee to drop,
he was dreadful he had so many kick turnovers and is always getting tackled.

His past month of footy hasnt been good

Partington for Rioli or Lecras for Rioli is another as Partington was a passenger tonight, Just a question on Rioli fitness

Dom Sheed will get another game, but is cementing a reputation as a player that will never stand up in finals

Considering we are playing GWS we could afford to go tall and bring Naitanui in

 

[Coaster2012]

In: wellingham
Out: parto/duggen.

Both didnt offer much

 

[FKASC]

In: NN, Willie
Out: Parto, Vardy

 

[2006_Eagles]

I can see them going unchanged again.

The only player I'd seriously consider dropping would be Le Cras, but Rioli would probably be too big a risk. Naitanui punt isn't needed with Petters and Vardy doing well. I thought Partington was valuable with his pressure tonight.

Unchanged it is.

Yeah Lecca is a pile of shit these days

Couldn't hurt giving Willie a run

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

In: wellingham
Out: parto/duggen.

Both didnt offer much

if we bring in Wellingham we need to play him in the midfield where he is good at contested possessions

 

[2006_Eagles]

In: NN, Willie
Out: Parto, Vardy

What no

Vardy did some awesome things. He stays.

 

[TassieEagle]

Parto, Duggan and Lecca and the only candidates to drop and NN is the only bloke I want coming in, Can't drop Vardy or Petrie though.

So all in all no changes.

 

[Big Cox 88]

Hutchings was terrible

 

[Coaster2012]

if we bring in Wellingham we need to play him in the midfield where he is good at contested possessions

Yeah exactly. Wellers contested ball would be better than Partos straight up. A no brainer for me.

 

[Coaster2012]

Hutchings was terrible

16 touchs 7 marks. Not going anywhere

 

[Ok Boomer]

On tonight's performance.

Wellingham in for one of Partington, Duggan or Lecras.

Won't be Duggan, almost certainly will be Partington. I am glad he got to experience a final though.

Rioli for Lecras would be a huge gamble.

 

[Biggie]

Duggan has been well down.

Can see Wellers coming in for him, but that's about it. Maybe Parto, but he, when he had it was clean . Duggan not so much.

 

[QS]

Is everyone forgetting how shit Wellingham was before he was dropped? No thanks.

 

[FKASC]

What no

Vardy did some awesome things. He stays.

Gotta bring in the panther though. And Petrie > Vardy.

How else do we #bringhimin

 

[matt_bas]

Out: Shuey (rested)
In: Masto (for lols)

 

[Biggie]

Out: Shuey (rested)
In: Masto (for lols)

Yourself.

Uppercut it.

 

[FKASC]

Duggan, apart from uncharacteristic kicking errors, just needs to learn when to take on the tackler and when to pass off quickly.

I love the fact he tries to break tackles but he needs to know his limits and I'm sure there's a technique to it that he can hone over the off season.

He deserves to stay.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Why is it an issue to replace players that aren't producing. LeCras has had a shocking year and is back in poor form, Parto has shown a bit but he's not a forward pocket and his best work is when he's up in the play getting hands to it.

We aren't winning anything with this 22 plus Wellingham FWIW.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Out: Shuey (rested)

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Duggan, apart from uncharacteristic kicking errors, just needs to learn when to take on the tackler and when to pass off quickly.

I love the fact he tries to break tackles but he needs to know his limits and I'm sure there's a technique to it that he can hone over the off season.

He deserves to stay.

Nothing fundamentally wrong, and not in shocking form. He'll produce again soon.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Why is it an issue to replace players that aren't producing. LeCras has had a shocking year and is back in poor form, Parto has shown a bit but he's not a forward pocket and his best work is when he's up in the play getting hands to it.

We aren't winning anything with this 22 plus Wellingham FWIW.

It's Willie's time and why does anyone think it isn't?

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Is everyone forgetting how shit Wellingham was before he was dropped? No thanks.

Depend where we play him, at east perth he stars in the middle and his clearance work was first class,
and thats a area where we lack a lot of cover.
If we play him in the forward pocket he wont do much for us.
Give him time in the middle giving Priddis and Mitchell a break and he will be good for us

 

[Eastern Rangers]

16 touchs 7 marks. Not going anywhere

Slow and slow kicks. If he stays he needs to play negative on Sheil and test his shoulders out.