Changes next week

[lynchy4610]

Out: JON, Riewoltd, Rance, White, Edwards

IN: Cotchin, Thursfield, Hughes, Pettifer, Morton,

 

[TigerCleavage]

Out: JON, Riewoltd, Rance, White, Edwards, Wallace

IN: Cotchin, Thursfield, Hughes, Pettifer, Morton, a coach with a spine and the balls to blast his players into action

edited for accuracy.

 

[Get Thee To A Nunnery]

I wasn't at the game....but from what i heard on radio was White that bad ? he has been solid this year..not a star but solid....as for JON...bye bye....and I think Edwards is not up to it ..as everybody keeps saying he gets pushed off to easy......Didn't hear much about rance, but heard some ordinary commentry about Riewoltd...I think Jack needs some time in Coburg. Although bringing Huhges from the Coburg's two's does not inspire me, and from what I hear Thursfield aint doing much either.......Let's look to next year....we say that each year at this time don't we ????

 

[Madtiger2006]

Out: JON, Riewoltd, Rance, White, Edwards

IN: Cotchin, Thursfield, Hughes, Pettifer, Morton,

I like this, but you can leave Reiwoldt in and drop Schulz. Reiwoldt and Hughes work well together

 

[krustyman]

maybe brown can also come in.

 

[Barnzy]

There's so many duds in the team but not enough half decent players to replace them.

OUT: Edwards, JON, Rance (in), Bowden, Schulz, Simmonds, Collins/White (both poor today)

IN: Pattison, Cotchin, Morton, Brown, Thursfield, Hughes, McMahon

 

[krustyman]

I like this, but you can leave Reiwoldt in and drop Schulz. Reiwoldt and Hughes work well together

what did schultz do wrong? he got a goal from several shots and centred from simmo to goal, riewoldt did almost nothing all day.

 

[Saint KFC]

There's so many duds in the team but not enough half decent players to replace them.

OUT: Edwards, JON, Rance (in), Bowden, Schulz, Simmonds, Collins/White (both poor today)

IN: Pattison, Cotchin, Morton, Brown, Thursfield, Hughes, McMahon

Christ that's stupid.

 

[win1soon]

Out- Jon,Edwards,Schultz,Rance(inj)

In- Vickery(leave him play full forward for the rest of the year) cotchin, brown, raines.

 

[L_J_T]

Out: JON, Edwards
In: Cotchin, Brown

That's just the definites right now.

 

[L_J_T]

Forgot Rance out...unfortunately.

 

[Barnzy]

Christ that's stupid.

Please tell me why it's so stupid. I know the list a whole lot better than some St.Kilda bandwagon supporter.

Pretty straight swaps in all positions. I'm sure you just think it's stupid because I listed McMahon since you just believe what is posted by other users because you can't think for yourself. McMahon might be shit as a defender but so is Bowden which showed today and he was hitting targets better the last 2 weeks than Bowden today. There is simply no one else to come in.

 

[TheCuzEffect]

Out: JON, Edwards
In: Cotchin, Brown

That's just the definites right now.

do you really think Rance is going to play :\

Out's Jon, Rance (inj), Bowden, Riewoldt, Edwards

In's Cotchin, Hughes, Morton, PEttifer, Vickery

 

[_RT_]

Out: Rance, Moore, Schulz
In: Thursfield, Pattison, Cotchin.

 

[ize_]

Was I the only one who noticed JON's consistent strong marking across half forward and intent to tackle all day?

Out - Riewoldt (has been so devastatingly disappointing all year), Edwards, Rance

In - Thursfield, Hughes, Cotchin

I want Vickery in too, Schulz went missing today but it frustrates me so much how Wallace stuffs around with him. Why can't we just leave him at FF for a whole game, he was good there first quarter. Instead we were going forward kicking to Nahas and Tambling all day. So I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt. Really starting to think Out - Wallace too, it's just a waste of time now.

 

[Saint KFC]

Please tell me why it's so stupid. I know the list a whole lot better than some St.Kilda bandwagon supporter.

My BF join date is not indicative of the date that I began following St. Kilda - rather it is indicative of the date that I joined BigFooty. I've been following St. Kilda since I was born, in fact I was born in St. Kilda, and my parents have been supporting St. Kilda since they were born.

Pretty straight swaps in all positions. I'm sure you just think it's stupid because I listed McMahon since you just believe what is posted by other users because you can't think for yourself. McMahon might be shit as a defender but so is Bowden which showed today and he was hitting targets better the last 2 weeks than Bowden today. There is simply no one else to come in.

I will go through your outs and then your ins.

OUT:
Edwards Understandable, was a late replacement
JON Understandable, although I do think that he's playing alot better this year than he ever has
Rance (in) A given
Bowden Why? One of the only people in your team who genuinely wants the ball all the time. Demands the ball, provides run out of your backline, experienced defender. Made a few errors today but has been solid thus-far in the year. Honestly I've never seen a board of people so willing to throw proven, senior players to the dogs after a bad game
Schulz Went missing today. I agree
Simmonds What is he meant to do? Gave it a crack up forward and picked up 4 goals, is obviously getting low ruck TOG and surely it can't bode well for his confidence after being dropped in favor of a 22yr old after having one of his best years ever.
Collins/White (both poor today) I thought Collins gave it a crack apart from going missing in the 2nd. White I'll agree with, didn't do anything after the 1st quarter

IN:
Pattison Understandable
Cotchin If ready it's a given. I'd say that he's in your top 5 players
Morton I wouldn't, but I guess you could make a case
Brown Is definitely in your best 22, but should only come in if he's going to give 100% (which he hasn't been) and is over his 'injury'
Thursfield Maybe
Hughes No. Wait until he does well at VFL seniors level (not reserves) before bringing him into an AFL side
McMahon I would say that it's either him or Raines in for Rance. McMahon has been your whipping boy thus far and Raines did SFA in the VFL last week. It's just a shame that Coburg have a bye this weekend so you can't get a better look at both.

I may not know the list aswell as you, but I have watched most of Richmond's games thus far in the year and have always had a soft spot for the Tigers. And for that reason, I don't respond to losses with the same overreacting crap that I see on your board every week

IMO, what should happen is:

IN: Pattison, Cotchin, McMahon/Raines
OUT: Schulz, White, Rance

Maybe Thursfield for Moore aswell depending on how he pulls up

 

[tiges1]

Was I the only one who noticed JON's consistent strong marking across half forward and intent to tackle all day?

.

yep , you were



..... when he seldom touches the ball --always make's the wrong decision

alas the club is now a certified basket case



.

 

[tiger taskforce]

no change we now will just happly lose the rest of our games and give our new coach the number 1 pick

 

[folester41]

edwards, rance and JON out, dont care who comes in.
schulz is bought in to play foward and half the game i see him down back or on the pine.

 

[coke_zero]

out- Rance, JON, riewoldt

in- pattison, morton, thursfield

 

[one eyedtiger]

Out: Rance, Schulz, Edwards, JON (Marked well but did nothing with it, maybe just did enough to keep his spot)

In: Thursfield, Pattison, Brown (He will come in, unless Wallace is not coaching) Cotchin.

 

[coke_zero]

JON (Marked well but did nothing with it, maybe just did enough to keep his spot)

that was his only up side. and i hat to say it but lost our lead in the 2nd quarter. a strong mark but he needs to give it off faster and spear the pass not a up and under kick.

 

[Punt Road Feral]

Was I the only one who noticed JON's consistent strong marking across half forward and intent to tackle all day?

I noticed it as well today.
For years we have been crying out for players to provide us with a target along the half forward flank and wing. JON is doing that very well imo.
I wonder if JON played this role in a side like Hawthorn he wouldn't do little 20m chips into the forward 50 but would pump it long with confidence knowing he has 2 great power forwards ready to mark it, he would be known as a good player.

 

[Themi#9]

JON was shit today....turned it over so many times, he cant even f***** handball!!

 

[Themi#9]

Out- Rance (inj) edwards JON Riewoldt

In - Cotch Hughes Thursfield Morton

Must come in!! i have such a good feeling about this guy, needs to be given opurtunity!
needs to be thrown in the deep end!