Changes round 4 VS Sydney

[avishka5]

"Rookies aren't included on the official injury list" would be the response to that. Completely ignoring the fact tunbridge has been on the official list all year, of course.

I actually meant the ins and outs that Simmo apparently disclosed to Vishy this morning

Didn't know Vishy spoke to simmo

I'm like the least trustworthy poster in here and can't believe you bit my bait. TBH i went with it cause i thought you knew.

 

[King LeBron]

Well im glad duggan is in, for us to improve as a ream we need the likes of him to step up

Would have been even happier if Redden was dropped for Shred. Duggan and Shred are both vital for our future.

 

[avishka5]

Would explain why he was so angry

show me evidence of my anger?

 

[avishka5]

while everyone is melting over the non selection of sheed, simmo be like

 

[WCErevival]

show me evidence of my anger?

Simmo's anger

 

[shaztec]

Perhaps Jetta pulled up sore with his quad again?

 

[wce4premiership]

Not sure on Duggan, want him to get 25+ and see if he can avoid shanking it. Needs to improve and stay in the game.

 

[ChampRevesby]

Perhaps Jetta pulled up sore with his quad again?

If he isn't injured I'm not surprised he got axed, just is not delivering what is expected.
Duggan is a great pick, hope he does well

 

[ziad]

I'm coming to the conclusion that the Selectors have NFI! Sheed has the body in the midfield that we need. Did Sheed sleep with Simmos wife or something as he appears to be out of favour at present.

but its the tarzan and jane problem again
he plays soft outside where he is slow and not a brilliant kick (ok but not brilliant)

 

[ziad]

Sheed had 37 ****en touches!

On SM-G920I using BigFooty.com mobile app

how many contested and really inside, how many tackles. swans are not a WAFL side

 

[ziad]

So Duggan to play Jetta's role presumably, which is somewhat understandable (although it's probably premature and I'd almost rather Jetta's 10 touches over Duggan's inevitable 10 touches).

But Butler in for Hutchings over Sheed? A bit strange tbh.

simmo was furious after that game that they planned for Martin but did not deliver. my suspicion (no evidence at all) is that the plan was for Hutchings to follow him forward.

he didnt

 

[DickDunn]

Good changes imo.

Butler in hopefully frees Wellingham up to provide more rebound and burst off half-back. Hutchings a bit unlucky but not a huge loss.

Jetta deserved to be dropped and Duggan now has a huge incentive to perform and take his spot.

Sheed is a bit stiff but didn't exactly do much at AFL level last time he played. It won't kill him to back it up in the WAFL (although with Darling hit and miss, every chance he comes in as an emergency anyway)

 

[Hap Hapablap]

how many contested and really inside, how many tackles. swans are not a WAFL side

And what makes you think duggans touches were more infleuncial?

 

[ziad]

And what makes you think duggans touches were more infleuncial?

he hasnt had an AFL game with zero contested/tackles

sheed need to redeem himself

 

[Carbine Chaos]

he hasnt had an AFL game with zero contested/tackles

sheed need to redeem himself

Redeem himself from what? A few quiet games in injury interrupted periods of a young career?

Sheed has produced more at AFL level than Duggan.

 

[Hap Hapablap]

Redeem himself from what? A few quiet games in injury interrupted periods of a young career?

Sheed has produced more at AFL level than Duggan.

exactly

everyone seems to be forgetting sheeds first season

 

[new breed]

Sheed , Priddis , Redden , Mitchell offer similar qualities , Duggan is pretty versatile hopefully we are changing things up a bit with Wellingham and Nelson get some midfield time also .

 

[dajesmac]

Happy enough that Duggan is in, he needs the experience and in terms of player type he is the sort of player we need to bring in at the moment. Every game he plays is one step closer to him either realizing his potential or certifying that he is a crab. Win win.

Sheed I am surprised has not been picked but it suggests to be they were really unimpressed with his 11 possession game against the Saints. At the time I thought he might have been underdone but I feel like this sends the message that he was dropped on form.

Not sure about dropping a midfielder for a defender, but we probably have a better balance between inside and outside types now.

 

[dajesmac]

exactly

everyone seems to be forgetting sheeds first season

Sheed had one of the worst debut seasons I have ever seen, but his second season was ridiculously good in comparison.

When fit I think he is a walk up start in our team.

 

[Logue]

Sheed is terrible in traffic, panics and still hasn't learnt to free his arms - as another said too similiar to others alread in the middle, he's also painfully slow.

Great footskills, but needs to play an outside role to be effective at AFL level.

 

[RookiePick]

Sheed was excellent in traffic in 2015. Was getting very good at ripping the ball out of congestion too.

Hasn't seemed to find his mojo since his pec injury early last year unfortunately. Still young though, hopefully he smashes another strong game out for EP this weekend.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[Boohemian]

Sheed was fantastic in 2015, it's a shame that 2016 was a horror for him injury wise. I was looking forward to seeing him build on that year. If Mitchell wasn't recruited the likelihood is that he would be getting a game, this year he's going to have to earn his spot which is a positive in a sense. Couple more solid games and if the opportunity presents I expect him to take it. He's too good to be languishing in the WAFL.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Sheed is terrible in traffic, panics and still hasn't learnt to free his arms

This is basically the opposite of how I view him tbh.

 

[ziad]

Redeem himself from what? A few quiet games in injury interrupted periods of a young career?

Sheed has produced more at AFL level than Duggan.

sadly not in his last game

 

[ziad]

This is basically the opposite of how I view him tbh.

thats BF for you