Changes v Collingwood

[PeacefulWarrior]

I'm comfortable with Young having another year on his contract and Moore's coming to an end, I shan't lose any sleep.

Every time I hear the names John Butcher and Andrew Moore it makes me sad

 

[PeacefulWarrior]

So I have to balance it by saying Ollie Wines and Chad Wingard

Hey where's those dikless wonders that wanted Wingard dropped a few weeks ago btw?

 

[Janus]

Given that you're the first and only person to mention Young in this thread and you did so by having a pointless crack at him that had no relevance to the post you quoted, it's about time you stop pretending that you rate Young fairly and objectively.

It wasn't meant to be a crack, merely saying that if you're going to make a categorical statement about who is or isn't in our future based on one game against Carlton where the entire team played like shit and a sub performance against Sydney, then you better do the same for everyone else who has had a couple of bad games. I picked Young because a) he always seems to be mentioned with Moore so he was first on my mind b) the guy who was posting is a known Young lover and I love a good troll and c) his stats were the closest to Moore's in his last game of the people who were dropped.

 

[Waspy79]

Slow, too small, can't kick over a jam tin, misses targets, doesn't tackle. If you dispute this I suggest you go back and watch the replay.

He can tweet though.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

It wasn't meant to be a crack, merely saying that if you're going to make a categorical statement about who is or isn't in our future based on one game against Carlton where the entire team played like shit and a sub performance against Sydney, then you better do the same for everyone else who has had a couple of bad games. I picked Young because a) he always seems to be mentioned with Moore so he was first on my mind b) the guy who was posting is a known Young lover and I love a good troll and c) his stats were the closest to Moore's in his last game of the people who were dropped.

Must admit I did expect you to bite on that post as the well known Moore Lover you are... you stick the boots into Young just as hard when you get the chance.

 

[Janus]

Must admit I did expect you to bite on that post as the well known Moore Lover you are... you stick the boots into Young just as hard when you get the chance.

Ah Chee is proving to be better than either.

 

[snozulu]

Only disapointed with krak being dropped. Like the ins. Neade as sub i reckon. Lets give the coaching staff and players a bit of a break peeps we have all had a tuff week with the loss of Walshy and lets enjoy the game for what it is in his honour.

 

[madman]

He showed little effort last week.. he's a liability until he gets over the injuries he's carrying.

True, but I don't think there's anyone who can stand a chance against Cloke in a marking contest. Carlile was our best chance. But we will see how Jackson goes if he takes him on.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Ah Chee is proving to be better than either.

Inside mid with a hunger for the hard ball, doesn't mind contact and has a bullet like handball.... He's my new Young love

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

You need depth in a squad. Right now if anything Moore is a good depth player, we can't afford to be losing players like this.

 

[FishingRick04]

If Arch, Pittard or Jackson are sub I'll vomit.

 

[AdsGoNads]

True, but I don't think there's anyone who can stand a chance against Cloke in a marking contest. Carlile was our best chance. But we will see how Jackson goes if he takes him on.

Agreed.

 

[Wargreymon90]

If Arch, Pittard or Jackson are sub I'll vomit.

Will be Karl or Andrew I reckon

 

[PAFC66]

So I have to balance it by saying Ollie Wines and Chad Wingard

Hey where's those dikless wonders that wanted Wingard dropped a few weeks ago btw?

Name a poster who wanted wingard dropped...

Seriously?

The guy is so far ahead in the B&F with Robbie it isn't funny.

 

[tribey]

Name a poster who wanted wingard dropped...

Seriously?

The guy is so far ahead in the B&F with Robbie it isn't funny.

There was one I can think of. I like to think he meant Corey Wingard.

 

[edgie]

Ah Chee is proving to be better than either.

After 2 years of inconsistent at best SANFL form

 

[Grandaddy J]

After 2 years of inconsistent at best SANFL form

He's 21 years old m9. Lot of people tend to forget that

 

[Long live PAFC]

Hoon for Amon - outside run for outside run. Amon was probably ahead of Hoon prior to his calf strain. Fair enough for him to come in. Hoon was good but his defensive side was lacking as it has been since day dot.

Moore for Neade - selecting for forward 50 defensive pressure. Moore hasn't played well, may have deserved more opportunities but season has been average.

Clurey for Jonas and Carlile for Trengove make sense. Both players have been very average and are team leaders.

O'Shea for Krak - tough call. Krak has good disposal but lacks defensive accountability and fitness. O'Shea hasn't been in great form. Will Krak correct his deficiencies in the SANFL?

 

[Traveling_Power]

Hoon dropped?!

I was disappointed to see that Hoon was dropped

 

[AlbertonBloke]

Put Ah chee in a pack and everyone wait 30 metres off for the handball receive. Problems solved

 

[Long live PAFC]

For those calling for Harvey - who would come out? Is he fit enough? Would throwing him to the wolves do more harm than good?

Whilst Schulz has been very average, who comes in if we drop him? Is he the type of player that would improve if dropped?

 

[Traveling_Power]

actually I change my mind, looking forward to our 1-4 first round draft pick.

maybe we are trying to get Aaron Francis (who will be in the top 4 of the draft) ...

currently we might be able to get Rhys Mathieson (to help out Ollie)

 

[Long live PAFC]

Also why are Hoon, Krak and Moorey the emergencies?

I appreciate we don't have huge depth at the moment but it seems to send an odd message, ie you aren't good enough to play AFL as you have to work on some things but if we are in a tight spot you're in....

 

[edgie]

For those calling for Harvey - who would come out? Is he fit enough? Would throwing him to the wolves do more harm than good?

Whilst Schulz has been very average, who comes in if we drop him? Is he the type of player that would improve if dropped?

I believe we have nothing to gain by dropping Schulz based on form. It is however, a stone cold fact, that Ken has played him injured at points every year since he took over, and is on record saying "He'll rest during the bye".

If sarge needs a physical rest give him one, but whoever we bring in, if we only bring in one replacement, will be thrown to the wolves. Would need to play 2 KPF to have a chance between them. Should be doing that anyway though.

 

[ab56452001]

Krak is that far in front of most regards his disposal skills I can't believe he got dropped , nearly every pass of his up forward results turns into a scoring op , the rest of the changes should of happened weeks ago , and give Ebert a rest to , but you got to show ticker to do that.