Unofficial Preview Changes vs Adelaide (thread closed, please post in Game Day thread)

[Nicco_jj]

Main question is; who replaces Sidey?

I'd probably just get Degoo to play a full game and bring BenKen/Freeman/Broom in.

Other than that, maybe Reid (if fit...) for Oxley. I thought the Ox was good tonight though!

[***Mod edit: selected team, ins and outs***]

Collingwood
B: Alan Toovey, Nathan Brown, Ben Sinclair
HB: Tom Langdon, Jack Frost, Jackson Ramsay
C: Travis Varcoe, Dane Swan, Jack Crisp
HF: Jamie Elliott, Jesse White, Tim Broomhead
F: Alex Fasolo, Travis Cloke, Jarryd Blair
Foll: Brodie Grundy, Taylor Adams, Scott Pendlebury
Int: Tyson Goldsack, Marley Williams, Paul Seedsman, Adam Oxley
Emg: Sam Dwyer, Patrick Karnezis, Corey Gault

IN: Tim Broomhead, Paul Seedsman
OUT: Steele Sidebottom (thumb), Jordan De Goey (omitted

 

[Baird]

Broomhead and Karnezis for Sidebottom and Ramsay/Oxley

 

[Jonno94]

De Goey full game.

 

[Kappa]

Out: Sidebottom Ramsay

In: Broomhead Kennedy

Please

Oxley as the sub

 

[Nicco_jj]

Broomhead and Karnezis for Sidebottom and Ramsay/Oxley

Forgot about Ramsay.

I'd probably keep Ramsay in on performance but Ox in on potential... Tricky call

Will it upset the balance if we bring in 2 mid/fwd types for 1 mid and 1 defender?

I think you're right though. Broom for Sidey seems the closest to a like for like replacement we have.

Sidey and Greenwood both out hurts.

 

[mattys123]

Out: Sidey , De Goey (just doubt we can carry him without Sidey and Greenwood in the side), Oxley/Ramsay (don't need as many half backs vs Crows)

In: Broomhead, Gault (Grundy needs ruck help), Dwyer/Kennedy (if Dwyer isn't injured he plays, was BOG in the VFL)

 

[ThisIsJake]

Keep Ox, kid can kick.

 

[Nicco_jj]

Out: Sidebottom Ramsay

In: Broomhead Kennedy

Please

Oxley as the sub

Dunno about Ox as a sub... I feel he may not be able to impact a game as a sub that well.

I'd be tempted to make Goldy the sub, but I also don't want to change tonight's team too much.

 

[Nicco_jj]

Keep Ox, kid can kick.

His kick in the first quarter was Buckley-esque... Incredible!

He also looked confident with the ball. I'd be happy to give him another week... But then we'd be dropping Ramsay for essentially no reason.

 

[Nicco_jj]

Out: Sidey , De Goey (just doubt we can carry him without Sidey and Greenwood in the side), Oxley/Ramsay (don't need as many half backs vs Crows)

In: Broomhead, Gault (Grundy needs ruck help), Dwyer/Kennedy (if Dwyer isn't injured he plays, was BOG in the VFL)

Very logical suggestions Matty!

 

[TradeDraft]

In: Broomhead Kennedy Gault

Out:Sidebottom Sinclair ?

 

[Embleberry]

De Goey may be in the vest most games. Bucks said that he was the sub because they felt he wouldn't be able to run out the whole game.


^Sinclair stays in... He was good tonight.

 

[Nicco_jj]

In: Broomhead Kennedy Gault

Out:Sidebottom Sinclair ?

Please rematch the game... Sinclair was very good tonight. Was in our top 10.

 

[Nicco_jj]

De Goey may be in the vest most games. Bucks said that he was the sub because they felt he wouldn't be able to run out the whole game.


^Sinclair stays in... He was good tonight.

Maybe back to the vfl ala what Matty suggested then... Will make way for broom and Patty K and/or Dwyer and/or BenKen et al

 

[pieanitis]

Kennedy ordinary in the vfl today, cant reward him with a game on today's performance. Broomy (good today) in for Sidey, Dwyer (if 100 %) BOG in for De goey (just not quite ready, full game on the vfl better for his development). Only omission De Goey. No need to flirt with form.

 

[Chris_2593]

In: Kennedy
Out: Sidebottom

Ramsay as sub.

 

[Nicco_jj]

In: Kennedy
Out: Sidebottom

Ramsay as sub.

Why Kennedy over Broom?

 

[Kappa]

In: Broomhead Kennedy Gault

Out:Sidebottom Sinclair ?

Sinclair was better than Ramsay and Williams.

 

[Schraderbrau]

lol @ dropping Ramsay or Sinclair. Are people so blinded by their preconceived opinions that they couldn't see that they were two of our better performed tonight.

Tonight was a big FU to those critical of selections last week. The defence was magnificent, it will remain unchanged.

 

[SwanBet]

In: Reid, Kennedy, Broomhead
Out: Oxley, Ramsay, Sidebottom (inj)

B: J.Frost, N.Brown, A.Toovey
HB: T.Langdon, B.Reid, B.Sinclair
C: T.Varcoe, S.Pendlebury, T.Broomhead
HF: J.Elliott, T.Cloke, J.DeGoey
F: A.Fasolo, J.White, T.Goldsack
R: B.Grundy, D.Swan, T.Adams
I: J.Blair, J.Crisp, M.Williams, B.Kennedy

Sidebottom leaves a huge hole in midfield. I think we need to bring in Broomy and Ben ken just to add some run and freshness to a side that looked out on its feet in the last quarter. Bringing Reid back may be a little optimistic, but I just desperately want him back.

 

[Ketchup]

One of our backs have to go. Don't need that many against AdelaidE

Someone needs to take sideass too.

If Reid is capable (highly doubtful, I'd play him Adelaide have much more capable talls)

Would also play gault next week on a dry etihad.

Could be upto 4 imo. As for who for, glad im not selection committee

 

[jmac70]

Our boys were brave tonight but I reckon there will be a few changes. That humidity was a killer. It's going to be tough to back it up but if we show the same intensity we are in with a good chance.

 

[Baird]

lol @ dropping Ramsay or Sinclair. Are people so blinded by their preconceived opinions that they couldn't see that they were two of our better performed tonight.

Tonight was a big FU to those critical of selections last week.

Well, my 'preconceived opinion' of Ramsay was that he was good enough to play 15+ games tonight. Tonight he was fumbly and gave away a few reckless free kicks, he was not one of our better performed players. We need to drop at least one defender this week, for team balance.

 

[SwanBet]

lol @ dropping Ramsay or Sinclair. Are people so blinded by their preconceived opinions that they couldn't see that they were two of our better performed tonight.

Tonight was a big FU to those critical of selections last week. The defence was magnificent tonight, it will remain unchanged.

Sinclair was fantastic tonight & Ramsay was ok but I think we probably have one defender too many in the side at the moment. I'm happy with both in the side, but someone needs to make way for Broomhead and Kennedy in my opinion.

 

[doppleganger]

Why are people making multiple changes??

Team had a great game and just run out of gas.

Out Sidey
In Dwyer