Changes Vs Melbourne

[Infamy]

Yep, only one more game for Edwards to qualify for VFL finals

Out: Edwards, Riewoldt
In: Meyer, Rance

 

[T4P]

What I would like to happen that is actually realistic:

IN: Meyer (Will play in McMahon's position), Tivendale (farewell game), Collard (if Edwards goes could be a chance), Rance (doubt it but would like it)
Out: McMahon (bad form), Connors (someone has to make way for Tivva), Edwards (maybe), Thursfield (could happen)

What will most likely happen:

IN: Tivendale
OUT: Connors/Edwards

They will keep Cartledge to try out - remember it is Melbourne we are playing.

 

[HBK619]

For those wanting Patto in it won't happen, Pattison suffered a fractured Vertebrae in the game against Brisbane, won't play for the rest of the year.

Also for those wanting McMahon out are you stupid? The guy played one of his best games for us last week, has a shocker the next and he is to be out?

IMO the changes:
IN: Collard(Come from Coburg Ressies, starred in the seniors, deserves a go) and maybe Graham(Just see how he goes against the worst team in the league).

OUT: Edwards(Needs a rest) and maybe Cartledge(Don't think he has been too bad, but Gus might need a go).

 

[The Dice Man]

What I would like to happen that is actually realistic:

IN: Meyer (Will play in McMahon's position), Tivendale (farewell game), Collard (if Edwards goes could be a chance), Rance (doubt it but would like it)
Out: McMahon (bad form), Connors (someone has to make way for Tivva), Edwards (maybe), Thursfield (could happen)

What will most likely happen:

IN: Tivendale
OUT: Connors/Edwards

They will keep Cartledge to try out - remember it is Melbourne we are playing.

I say go further and play JON, Gourdis and Hughes too.

Play all the kids if St.Kilda win today, but let Richo, Lids and Tuck all play (for the race to the Jack Dyer).

Keep Tambo, Morton, Reiwoldt, White, Schulz, Moore as a team building excercise.

Rest Mcmahon, Bowden, Foley, Simmo.


Probably save cash on match payments too


Let the kids go out.

 

[riewoldt4aa2011]

i want to see graham getting a go.

 

[RichosGuns]

Now the we can't make finals unless we beat mfc club by 200 points:

OUT: McMohan, Bowden, Foley, Simmonds, Johnson (anyone else with niggling injuries)

IN: Rance, Graham, Collins, Meyer, Tivendale

 

[TIGER03]

IN : anyone who has not played a senior game this year regardless of form or fitness.


OUT : all senior players and anyone with a slight injury.


the team could look like this :


B : king thursfield mcguane
HB : JON moore rance
C : polo tambling white
HF : morton riewoldt meyer
F : conners shulz edwards
FOLL : pattison cotchin collins
INT : graham hughes gourdis tivendale (last game)

bowden, johnson, newman, richo, simmonds, tuck, foley, mcmahon, deledio all rested

cogs, pettifer, polak, putt, raines, brown, casserly injured

cartledge, collard, howat, sylvester all rookies

 

[Madtiger2006]

Out: Reiwoldt, Edwards, Mcmahon, Cartledge
In: Polo, Rance, Graham, Tivendale(farewell game)

 

[Tumble]

Ins could depend on if Coburg need to win think they are still a chance to finish higher.
Tivendale probably deserves a farewell game but will play finals at Coburg.
Think they should make sure any players that can qualify for finals at Coburg play at Coburg would be good to see some of the younger players win a couple of finals there.
Nothing would be gained from playing a kid in the Melbourne game it means nothing at least they can take Coburg into the finals with winning form.

 

[sante]

We won't see that many changes, you can't drop guys in form.

IN: Tivva - Gus/Patto
OUT: Cartledge - Edwards

I want to see Meyer but I am not sure who would go out?

 

[HBK619]

IN : anyone who has not played a senior game this year regardless of form or fitness.


OUT : all senior players and anyone with a slight injury.


the team could look like this :


B : king thursfield mcguane
HB : JON moore rance
C : polo tambling white
HF : morton riewoldt meyer
F : conners shulz edwards
FOLL : pattison cotchin collins
INT : graham hughes gourdis tivendale (last game)

bowden, johnson, newman, richo, simmonds, tuck, foley, mcmahon, deledio all rested

cogs, pettifer, polak, putt, raines, brown, casserly injured

cartledge, collard, howat, sylvester all rookies

Honestly, I have a feeling that with that team we would actually get beaten, and we don't want to get done by Melbourne.

 

[Richo88]

For those wanting Patto in it won't happen, Pattison suffered a fractured Vertebrae in the game against Brisbane, won't play for the rest of the year.

Played VFL on the wkend did a few very nice pickups off the deck.

 

[Goldust]

FFS ....Edwards was one of our best on Saturday!!!

 

[HBK619]

Played VFL on the wkend did a few very nice pickups off the deck.

Really, interesting, I guess it wasn't as bad as first thought.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

If Edwards is 1 game off VFL finals qualification then I say drop him. Melbourne are VFL standard anyway and finals experience can only help him. Bring in Meyer give him a taste and some confidence for a HUGE preseason.

 

[Kyusss]

Out - Foley , Riewoldt , Schulz , Edwards , Johnson
In - Tivendale , Meyer , Rance , Cogs , Collins

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Why should anyone be given free games of footy by the RFC. Stuff Graham,stuff Collins, bugger giving games away for the fun of it. They are not up to the level. Get on Melbourne this week.

 

[TimeFor11]

Edwards cannot be dropped he had 4 clearances on the weekend that being the second in our team so that is enough to keep him. He ran all day and although he didnt do much in 2nd half he can play.

I would like too see Rance but cant see him playing for purely match up reasons so I think Meyer is a better chance.

Foley didnt look right to me I think we may rest him and not risk any disasters late on.

 

[PHX]

FFS ....Edwards was one of our best on Saturday!!!

Yeah but if we drop him he can play the finals series with the Burgers.