Collingwood List of the Decade - #2

[Lensen]

The List so far:

#1 - Damian Monkhorst

We're on to #2. There are four options this time. Just so everyone's aware, the "decade" is the last 10 years - ie, not just the 90s.

Tony "Scooter" Francis ('95-'98, 48 games, 40 goals)
Mark "To Sydney And Back" Orchard ('99-'00, 33 games, 6 goals)
Damien "Chipper" Adkins ('01-'02, 4 games, 0 goals)
Shane "Woey" Woewodin ('03-'04, 47 games, 26 goals)

Vote away!

 

[jefffff34]

Scooter. But then Woey.

 

[Lensen]

Francis for mine. Orchard and Adkins weren't good enough, and I really don't like Woewoeful as a player. Although these four years weren't Tony's best, I still rate them higher than Woey's 2.

 

[The Scarecrow]

Scooter.

 

[tomaraya]

woey.
alot more consistent than scooter was in those years.
having said that, if 90-91 were included in this it would cease to be a contest.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

woey.
alot more consistent than scooter was in those years.
having said that, if 90-91 were included in this it would cease to be a contest.

ditto

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Considering that in his two years Woey's played as many games as Francis did in those four years, I have to go with Woey.

 

[Nardz]

i voted scooter, but that may or may not have been flawed by the early 90's

 

[hotpie]

You cant vote for a bloke who averaged 12 games a season. Woey gets my vote, only because of the "cut-off" date of 1994. Over their entire careers its a toss-up, but I'd prefer Francis.

 

[grayza]

id have to say woey, was never really a fan of tony francis, plus he didnt do a great deal in the period in question, so woey gets my vote
plus im pretty sure adkins played a few more than four games....

 

[browny4PM]

only played 4 games in the #2 jumper, the rest were while wearing #41

 

[WZA]

Woewodin.

 

[Pedro]

Francis

 

[grayza]

only played 4 games in the #2 jumper, the rest were while wearing #41

der of course, sorry my bad

 

[Cassius_Clay]

most of the replys on this thread have said that they voted for woey yet the poll is 19:11 in francis' favour... whats with that

 

[Nardz]

most of the replys on this thread have said that they voted for woey yet the poll is 19:11 in francis' favour... whats with that

cause some ppl dont find it necessary to state the name of who they voted for. The vote itself is enough.

 

[MACDAICOS]

Wooey wouldnt be good enough to carry Scooters bag in the ground, yes I know he did win a brownlow but not wearing black and white, one of our favourite sons, gave his all for the jumper.

 

[The Scarecrow]

most of the replys on this thread have said that they voted for woey yet the poll is 19:11 in francis' favour... whats with that

I guess some that haven't posted have also voted.

 

[MarkT]

I don't care what the rules are Francis isn't the only player on that list who deserves a vote in a Collingwood rep side of any era.

 

[Johnson#26]

Dammit. Missed out.

Oh well, would have voted for Scooter or Chipper.

______________
Good Old Collingwood - Forever.