Compensation Picks

[Russian]

To account for extra development time for talls, I've come up with a new formula that in simple terms says everyone up to 188cm is fully developed at age 20, and for every centimetre over that it takes an extra 2 months. Also gives an average score of 30 points instead of 0 for those players who haven't debuted.

We can change this for next year only, this year and next, or neither.

Option A (Original formula from 2 years ago)
Leigh Montagna - 1
Scott Thompson - 1
Jack Redden - 8
Brad Sewell - 3
Travis Cloke - 4
Adam Selwood - 5
Tom Rockliff - 5
Simon Black - 11
Tyrone Vickery - 37
Courtenay Dempsey - 22
Hayden Ballantyne - 22
Mark Jamar - 24
Ayce Cordy - 50
Todd Banfield - 30
Matt Campbell - 34
Ben Bucovaz - 50

Matthew Kreuzer - 10
Nic Naitanui - 22
Michael Hurley - 15
Ben McEvoy - 29
Lachlan Henderson - 29
Jarrad Grant - 18
Ryan Schoenmakers - 32
Phil Davis - 36
David Myers - 25

Option B (revised formula)
Leigh Montagna - 1
Scott Thompson - 1
Jack Redden - 5
Brad Sewell - 5
Travis Cloke - 6
Adam Selwood - 6
Tom Rockliff - 7
Simon Black - 12
Tyrone Vickery - 18
Courtenay Dempsey - 23
Hayden Ballantyne - 23
Mark Jamar - 25
Ayce Cordy - 29
Todd Banfield - 31
Matt Campbell - 36
Ben Bucovaz - 50

Matthew Kreuzer - 1
Nic Naitanui - 2
Michael Hurley - 4
Ben McEvoy - 9
Lachlan Henderson - 13
Jarrad Grant - 19
Ryan Schoenmakers - 21
Phil Davis - 22
David Myers - 26

 

[sausageroll]

Option A (Original formula from 2 years ago)
Matthew Kreuzer - 10
Nic Naitanui - 22
Michael Hurley - 15
Ben McEvoy - 29
Lachlan Henderson - 29
Jarrad Grant - 18
Ryan Schoenmakers - 32
Phil Davis - 36
David Myers - 25

Option B (revised formula)
Matthew Kreuzer - 1
Nic Naitanui - 2
Michael Hurley - 4
Ben McEvoy - 9
Lachlan Henderson - 13
Jarrad Grant - 19
Ryan Schoenmakers - 21
Phil Davis - 22
David Myers - 26

I think the quoted part sums it up perfectly. Option B is much more appropriate. That's where you would realistically be looking at picking up these kids.
Option A is way off with the talls. Pick 22 for Naitanui? That's robbery!

Well done Russian. I think you've nailed it.

 

[Russian]

Need a lot more votes quickly if it's going to change for this year.

 

[peterss]

Option B for me.