Corey or Bartel

[happy_eagle]

Upgrading Palmer, and wanted all of your oppinions on who you think would be the better player

Like choosing between God and Jesus

Corey- Pros
7,000 cheaper
Averages more (by .15)
Been much more higher this year (meaning really high scores)

Cons
Got tagged last week, and suffered
Is second behind ablett for the tag
Is a bit wayward and could pull a 60 anytime



Bartel- Pros
2007 puts him in high regard
Dosnt need a stack load of possies to score high
Never rarely gets the tag

Cons
7,000 more expensive
averages less
More popular

 

[kenny712]

Bartel. As you said, Corey cant really cope with tags and I have a good feeling about Bartel ripping it up after his well earnt rest. Had the same decision 3-4 weeks ago and based my decision on Bartel and his scoring capability compared to Corey when near full fitness

 

[BartBart]

Had the same choice a couple of weeks ago (for Houli) and went with Bartel. Gets extra points (as you alluded to) with marks/tackles. Has been a bit below last year, but has the potential to increase in the 2nd half of season. Either way - can't really lose (barring bad luck) with a Geelong midfielder at the moment.

 

[94_Eagles]

JB in a canter.

 

[Daz]

If ever there was a time to get Bartel it is now. Will enjoy the week off as there has been much speculation about an injury. He is also well priced. Has more upside than Corey and seemed to be back to his best in the 2nd half against West Coast.

 

[Kennyrocks]

Agreed Dazza

 

[Stodgee Stars]

If ever there was a time to get Bartel it is now. Will enjoy the week off as there has been much speculation about an injury. He is also well priced. Has more upside than Corey and seemed to be back to his best in the 2nd half against West Coast.

Got on him for last round which now gives me the Ablett/Bartel combo... Im very happy to say the least.

 

[Get Up]

Upgrading Palmer, and wanted all of your oppinions on who you think would be the better player

Like choosing between God and Jesus

Corey- Pros
7,000 cheaper
Averages more (by .15)
Been much more higher this year (meaning really high scores)

Cons
Got tagged last week, and suffered
Is second behind ablett for the tag
Is a bit wayward and could pull a 60 anytime



Bartel- Pros
2007 puts him in high regard
Dosnt need a stack load of possies to score high
Never rarely gets the tag

Cons
7,000 more expensive
averages less
More popular

Im lucky enough to have both as well as ablett, but if i were to pick one id take Bartel, purely because he has the ability get massive scores, while still be consistent.

 

[TrueBlueboy]

is it bad if i have both plus g ablett?

 

[Saint KFC]

is it bad if i have both plus g ablett?

Put it this way.

I am jealous.

 

[kangaroo19]

is it bad if i have both plus g ablett?

To go with Thompson, Swan and Kornes?

I'm certainly banking on my midfield to cover any 0's I get from my backline!

 

[Jimhouse]

To go with Thompson, Swan and Kornes?

I'm certainly banking on my midfield to cover any 0's I get from my backline!

No need to brag there

 

[Tippaz]

i like Corey this year.

 

[kangaroo19]

No need to brag there

I have to brag about my midfield to make me feel good about my injured backline!

 

[Ole Gill]

I had the same decision and ended up taking Sammy M

 

[Next Of Kin]

What about Bartel v Ablett? Am I better off getting Bartel and using the extra money to upgrade elsewhere?

 

[coughs2richo]

Bartel Is GOD! this is a no brainer surely?