Crichton Medal 2013

[VelvetSledge]

1) Hibberd
2) Zaharakis
3) Watson
4) Goddard
5) Stanton
6) Heppell
7) Fletcher
8) Hurley
9) Howlett
10) Melksham

On the bandwagon

 

[Slattery_20]

This is what I want

Hurley
Goddard
Hibberd
Watson
Zaharakis
Winderlich
Heppell
Carlisle
Ryder
Fletcher
Howlett.

Rationale
.

Did you count to 10 on your fingers?
If so: double-check they're all fingers, and also, put your pants back on.

 

[Keystone agony]

Did you count to 10 on your fingers?
If so: double-check they're all fingers, and also, put your pants back on.

He has an equal 10th

I think my list is pretty similar to yours. Watson has to be number one, Zaka surprised he polled so well last year and also the year before winning it, the coaches must love him. I expect 3,4,5 to be shared between Heppell, Goddard and Stanton after that.

Crameri is yet to finish outside the top 8 and i still dont think hes reached anywhere near his potential. Ill have him at 6.

I think i like everyone else is getting this weird vibe/feeling about Hibberd having one of those superb years (maybe in a Dempster 2012 mould). Hurley will be up there along with Fletch.

1. Watson
2. Zaharakis
3. (Stanton/Goddard/Heppell)
4. (Stanton/Goddard/Heppell)
5. (Stanton/Goddard/Heppell)
6. Crameri
7. Hibberd
8. Hurley
9. Fletcher
10. Dayle Garlett

 

[ItchMint5]

So many people are forgetting Stants. If he doesn't finish top 5 (top 3 even), I'll be surprised. I guess it just shows how strong the list is going to be when people are forgetting him.
Stanton will run a muck next year due to Goddard being in the middle.

 

[Lord Nicholson]

Ryder for me. If he can play a full season at the peak of his powers, we'll be doing nicely.

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

You've double up the 2009 and 2010 as McPhee is still there and same votes etc.

Thanks, good pick up! Fixed

 

[Keystone agony]

So many people are forgetting Stants. If he doesn't finish top 5 (top 3 even), I'll be surprised. I guess it just shows how strong the list is going to be when people are forgetting him.
Stanton will run a muck next year due to Goddard being in the middle.

If i was the opposition id still tag him first. For me the player that helps Stanton is David Zaharakis. Most teams will go H2H with Watson and Goddard which has been the case for the past few years because some clubs doubt their defensive side especially in Goddards case. Its no coincidence that Stanton really struggled when Zaka got injured whilst he was leading the brownlow? (just about) up until Zaka got injured.

 

[yaco55]

No Stanton in the top ten, yaco55?

he will finish in the top 10.

Mine is a wish list.

Stanton finishes 11th and we've had an excellent season

 

[Rack Watts]

Apart from thread being pointless

It lacks Crameri

7. Stewart Crameri

 

[Rack Watts]

Stanton finishes 11th and we've had an excellent season

If Stanton finishes 11th, he's been injured for more than half of the season.

 

[Doss]

If Stanton finishes 11th, he's been injured for more than half of the season.

Or he went all Terry Daniher on someone..

 

[2one2]

Watson
Myers
Stanton
Goddard
Heppell
Zaharakis
Carlisle
Hurley
Davey
Howlett