Oppo Camp Dangerfield's Gone (Zero tolerance to trolling) - READ THREAD LINKED IN OP BEFORE POSTING

Bovo · Oct 1, 2015

gothecrows said:
If we're losing a whole handful of players in one go, then we've got bigger problems to worry about than crappy compensation picks (which is all you'd get for players we don't care enough to keep) - e.g. Brisbane.

Indeed but if you have a handful of players who played for 8 or more years, you'd want something in return.

Mego Red · Oct 1, 2015

manboob said:
Offer an alternative trade then. This is a discussion forum.

Two first round picks. It's obvious and easy.

If the answers no, just go straight to mediation so we don't waste our time with all of the PSD and other club posturing (from both sides). Mediate it early and move on.

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

The AFL have to remove compensation ASAP but to counter balance that they must allow clubs to trade players where ever they wish.

Therefore, ideally 12 months ago we trade Dangerfield to a Melbourne based club.

Kane McGoodwin · Oct 1, 2015

MRB37 said:
Problem is the AFL have said they'll jump on any deal we try and make with Geelong that's lopsided.

& you can guarantee given the Tippett-gate fiasco, they will be looking for the #23 & White equivalent.

Just not worth the risk - don't we have a part suspended sanctions hanging over our heads?

JP Sauce · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:
Adelaide get: Pick 9, Aish & Redden
Adelaide lose: Dangerfield & second round pick

Geelong get: Dangerfield
Geelong lose: Pick 9, Jansen

Brisbane get: 2015 second round pick (Adelaide), 2016 first round pick (Geelong) Jansen
Brisbane lose: Aish & Redden

That one almost kind of works. :thumbsu:

Although it goes against Geelong posters stance that they won't give up two first rounders and a player.

Mego Red · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:
Adelaide get: Pick 9, Aish & Redden
Adelaide lose: Dangerfield & second round pick

Geelong get: Dangerfield
Geelong lose: Pick 9, Jansen

Brisbane get: 2015 second round pick (Adelaide), 2016 first round pick (Geelong) Jansen
Brisbane lose: Aish & Redden

Geelong also lose their 2016 first. They should get a 2016 third back from Brisbane.

dogs105 · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:
Adelaide get: Pick 9, Aish & Redden
Adelaide lose: Dangerfield & second round pick

Geelong get: Dangerfield
Geelong lose: Pick 9, Jansen

Brisbane get: 2015 second round pick (Adelaide), 2016 first round pick (Geelong) Jansen
Brisbane lose: Aish & Redden

Brisbane won't trade Aish

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

Kristof said:
Geelong also lose their 2016 first. They should get a 2016 third back from Brisbane.

Crows could also swap that second pick for CEY, who I think will help the Lions right now more than some 18 year old kid.

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

dogs105 said:
Brisbane won't trade Aish

When push comes to shove and his manager is reminding them he wants a trade and a good dealis on the table - they will trade him.

dogs105 · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:
When push comes to shove and his manager is reminding them he wants a trade and a good dealis on the table - they will trade him.

No. Lethal's making a stand apparently

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

dogs105 said:
No. Lethal's making a stand apparently

OK. I'm sure a club has taken that stance before and ended up traded

Samcro24 · Oct 1, 2015

Deleted by samcro24

Bovo · Oct 1, 2015

dogs105 said:
Brisbane won't trade Aish

He goes in the psd and gets picked up by them again...lol

AusTerran · Oct 1, 2015

Samcro24 said:
Neil Patrick Harris, I mean, Steven.

Sorry, that went over my head. No idea what that means. Anyway, deleted my post.

Samcro24 · Oct 1, 2015

AusTerran said:
Sorry, that went over my head. No idea what that means. Anyway, deleted my post.

In that case I have deleted your quote from mine.

Which now makes my post even more abstract.

AusTerran · Oct 1, 2015

Samcro24 said:
In that case I have deleted your quote from mine.

Which now makes my post even more abstract.

lol Thank you, Who would of thought that my relative reads bigfooty and quickly got a text from him telling me off in a not so nice way

lol

manboob · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:
Where is yours?

Kristof said:
Two first round picks. It's obvious and easy.

If the answers no, just go straight to mediation so we don't waste our time with all of the PSD and other club posturing (from both sides). Mediate it early and move on.

Something around this.

douglyzia · Oct 1, 2015

Strangled Cat said:
On the topic of Brisbane, what's the likelihood of a three-way deal between Geelong, Adelaide and Brisbane? Jarrad Jansen has asked to be traded to Brisbane and Brisbane owe us a favour for accepting unders for Al Christensen. Are you guys still after Aish?

Aish is not going to Collingwood anymore I believe, so perhaps he might be keen on a return to Adelaide? Geelong send pick #9 to Brisbane along with JJ. Geelong swaps its second and third round draft picks with Adelaide. Brisbane send its second round draft pick and Aish to Adelaide.

In summary:

Brisbane lose pick #20 and Aish and gain pick #9 and Jarrad Jansen.

Adelaide lose Dangerfield and (roughly) pick #33 and #51 and gain pick #20, #28, #46 and Aish

Geelong lose pick #9, Jarrad Jansen and pick #28 and #46 and gain Dangerfield and pick #33 #51.

Hmmm. I think a better deal would be:

Adelaide gain: Pick #9, Geelong's 2016 first round pick, Aish, Murdoch
Adelaide lose: Dangerfield

Brisbane gain: Pick #28, Geelong's 2016 2nd round pick, GHS, Jansen
Brisbane lose: Aish

Geelong gain: Dangerfield
Geelong lose: Pick #9, Pick #28, 2016 first round pick, 2016 2nd round pick, Murdoch, GHS, Jansen

Everyone wins.

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

manboob said:
Something around this.

Well?

C'on post it.

manboob · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:
Well?

C'on post it.

R9 this year and R1 next year and pick 14 back to the Cats.
Or
R1 this year and Murdoch (no Gregson, no ****) and not a penny more.

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

douglyzia said:
Hmmm. I think a better deal would be:

Adelaide gain: Pick #9, Geelong's 2016 first round pick, Aish, Murdoch
Adelaide lose: Dangerfield

Brisbane gain: Pick #28, Geelong's 2016 2nd round pick, GHS, Jansen
Brisbane lose: Aish

Geelong gain: Dangerfield
Geelong lose: Pick #9, Pick #28, 2016 first round pick, 2016 2nd round pick, Murdoch, GHS, Jansen

Everyone wins.

Aish is good but not that bloody good.

manboob · Oct 1, 2015

douglyzia said:
Geelong gain: Dangerfield
Geelong lose: Pick #9, Pick #28, 2016 first round pick, 2016 2nd round pick, Murdoch, GHS, Jansen

Everyone wins.

Smithtastic33 · Oct 1, 2015

manboob said:
R9 this year and R1 next year and pick 14 back to the Cats.
Or
R1 this year and Murdoch (no Gregson, no ****) and not a penny more.

manboob · Oct 1, 2015

Smithtastic33 said:

No need to be like that - when a above me contains a trade with 4 picks and 3 players out of Geelong for Dangerfield. You ain't getting mountains of a gold for an out of contract player who will only go to one club.

mistylake · Oct 1, 2015

FR0GGY said:
As has been said before, we have to take advantage of the "free" compo pick aswell as trading, as geelong don't want to pay full odds and we want more than they will give.

Well the AFL will need to step in and let it happen or it will not be possible. What's it gonna be Boys?

Log In or Create New Account

NFL Week 16 🏈 NCAA Bowls and Playoffs

Oppo Camp Dangerfield's Gone (Zero tolerance to trolling) - READ THREAD LINKED IN OP BEFORE POSTING

Premium Platinum

The Artist Formerly Known As Kristof

Cancelled

Make me an Admin!

Brownlow Medallist

The Artist Formerly Known As Kristof

Sweet Kennels Proprietor

Cancelled

Cancelled

Sweet Kennels Proprietor

Cancelled

Covered by the Cape

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Covered by the Cape

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Oppo Camp Dangerfield's Gone (Zero tolerance to trolling) - READ THREAD LINKED IN OP BEFORE POSTING

Similar threads