Delistings

[shuveradda]

Originally posted by brentoncowell
I hope Kinnear gets traded. I hope someone sees that given enough chance he can be a valuable player,like i do. Contrary to what a lot of you think, giving a player a game,watching them play 2 better than average games and then a poor one(along with a few other players) and then dropping them isnt given them a chance. Having a player playing fair football in all his 2003 games and really well in a preliminary final, only to follow that with a four possession in the first 10 minutes of the first qtr in a grand final and then sat at the bench for the remainder of the game and not playing them rd1 the following year isnt giving him a chance. I hope,like all of you,that BK goes somewhere else but because he needs to be given a chance.

I understand where your coming from but it ain't gonna happen. Sorry Mate

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by bucksisbest
Luke Mullins delisted? You've got be ****ing joking.

I like the kid, but he is not getting a game and doesn't look like it. He has been on the list for two years, and after that time, the youngsters usually get the cut. Collingwood will most likely get rid of him.

 

[MarkT]

Mullins will go nowhere unless we get a silly offer for him which won't happen.

 

[browa02]

Tristan Walker who have to be the crapest person at Collingwood. I rekon leon davis is worth his spot but if we can trade him for a good player i'll be happy. Reece Shaw has gotta go dont know about the young blokes though. and boys alot of players are on 100K a year

 

[jefffff34]

Untouchables
Shane Woewodin
Alan Didak
Nathan Buckley
James Clement
Scott Burns
Paul Licuria
Chris Tarrant
Guy Richards
Anthony Rocca
Tarkyn Lockyer
Josh Fraser
Ben Johnson
Cameron Cloke
Simon Prestigiacomo

Should be kept
Ryan Lonie
Brodie Holland
Shane O'Bree
Shane Wakelin
Tom Davidson
Mark McGough
Luke Mullins
David King
Jason Cloke
Dane Swan
Nick Maxwell

Possible trade bait
Leon Davis
Bo Nixon
Rhyce Shaw
Matthew Lokan
Tristen Walker

Get rid of
Steven McKee
Andrew Williams
Ben Kinnear

Untried talent, MUST KEEP
Billy Morrison
Luke Shackleton
Brayden Shaw
Heath Shaw
Brent Hall
Julian Rowe

---

That is how I would do it if I was the boss, I am not however...McGough is obviously going to be used as trade bait because he has been dropped this weekend and Rowe has been brought in...below is a list of players who are from Melbourne who are playing for interstate clubs (the easiest players to poach).

Kris Massie, Brent Reilly, Jacob Schuback, Mark Stevens, Fergus Watts, Matthew Smith # (Adelaide). Jed Adcock, Daniel Bradshaw, Jonathan Brown, Blake Caracella, Chris Johnson, Nigel Lappin, Justin Leppitsch, Dylan McLaren, Tim Notting, Luke Power, Michael Rischitelli, Brad Scott, Chris Scott, Troy Selwood (Brisbane). Adam Campbell, Ryan Crowley, Ryley Dunn, Greg Edgcumbe, David Mundy, Ryan Murphy, Andrew Siegert, Troy Simmonds, Scott Thornton, James Walker, Dylan Smith # (Fremantle). Matthew Bishop, Troy Chaplin, Stephen Gilham, Damien Hardwick, Adam Kingsley, Josh Mahoney, Brett Montgomery, Luke Peel, Matthew Primus, Steven Salopek, Toby Thurstans (Port Adelaide). Luke Ablett, Jude Bolton, Amon Buchanan, Sean Dempster, Andrew Erickson, Adam Goodes, Barry Hall, Nick Malceski, Stuart Maxfield, Ryan O'Keefe, Jason Saddington, Andrew Schuable, Josh Thewlis, Rowan Warfe, Scott McGlone #, Luke Taylor # (Sydney). Damien Adkins, Michael Braun, Callum Chambers, Ashley Hansen, Jeremy Humm, Paul Johnson, Chris Judd, Daniel McConnell, Chad Morrison, Kane Munro, Adam Selwood, David Wirrpunda, Aaron Edwards # (West Coast).

Basically we aren't going to try and get those established at their clubs (Stuart Maxfield, Nigel Lappin etc) but we need to poach a young star who currently is not in his team's best 22.

Therefore - I am starting the campaign.

GET SALOPEK AT COLLINGWOOD

Mark McGough
Matthew Lokan
First round draft pick [edit]I realised we are getting a good pick this year so change this to 2nd round[/edit]

Enjoy your new home.

 

[browa02]

im not sure anyone will want tristan walker. cant get rid of kinnear cos of contract. agree with williams hopefully get a good trade with him. mate salopek aint that good. we will get a much better player for mcgough and lokan. but we wont trade lokan. we better have some good trades this year as last years was absolutely pathetic.

 

[Pedro]

Originally posted by browa02
mate salopek aint that good. we will get a much better player for mcgough and lokan.

Judd, Brown, who? Names please.

 

[Murray]

Originally posted by understudy
Who knows. I've heard the club played pretty hard ball with BJ but then I hear numbers like this for Kinnear and J Cloke.

Is it the Balme factor, stuffing up contracts just like trades?

Either way time his position is reviewed and the club has a good hard look at his performance, that of the recruitment department and whole football department for that matter.

As I understand it BJ's contract is backloaded from 150k to 250k but there is a great deal of performance stuff in it.
Not that it is that much different to a heap of players on our list most have a performance component.

 

[shuveradda]

Originally posted by browa02
mate salopek aint that good. we will get a much better player for mcgough and lokan

Salopek will Start to Blossom Soon. He was a Number 6 Pick and will show his worth.

Would much rather have Salopek Developing his game slowy. Than Lokan Who is not improving and having no impact on the game whatsoever.

We wouldn't get much for Lokan. Goughy but not Lokan.

 

[jefffff34]

Originally posted by browa02
mate salopek aint that good. we will get a much better player for mcgough and lokan. but we wont trade lokan. we better have some good trades this year as last years was absolutely pathetic.

Salopek is a star in the waiting.

Look at Guerra this year.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by browa02
im not sure anyone will want tristan walker. cant get rid of kinnear cos of contract. agree with williams hopefully get a good trade with him. mate salopek aint that good. we will get a much better player for mcgough and lokan. but we wont trade lokan. we better have some good trades this year as last years was absolutely pathetic.

Why come on this forum when you know nothing about football, I can't believe you would think that we shouldn't go after Salopek. If he is so **** why is on a $200K A YEAR.

He is a star and if you watch football you would know.

Your posts on this forum are to no value to anybody who reads them. If you want to go on a forum, go onto a little nerds forum where you might no something, but don't write useless **** on this one. It is garbage.

 

[jefffff34]

Originally posted by Lonie_from_50
Why come on this forum when you know nothing about football, I can't believe you would think that we shouldn't go after Salopek. If he is so **** why is on a $200K A YEAR.

First contracts are $50,000 a year and go for two years - Salopek is on his second year. Hence out of contract.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by Hoggy
First contracts are $50,000 a year and go for two years - Salopek is on his second year. Hence out of contract.

I heard from someone that he was on alot of money for a first year player, but you never know. browa02 wouldn't even know what $200K is anyway so it doesn't matter.

I said about a month or two ago that Salopek is coming back to Victoria but everyone disagreed. Looks like you are finally agreeing with me Hoggy.

 

[The Scarecrow]

Originally posted by leonmagic
Delistings
McKee
Kinnear

Trade bait, if not delist
Davis
Williams
R.Shaw

I think Shaw and Williams would most likely be delisted, wouldn't think we'd get anything good for them. I'm not sure about trading Davis, unless we can trade him and a pick to a WA team for a home sick player.

 

[yikes]

Will Port we willing to trade with us? I think not. If Selopek is going to come back to Melbourne pretty much every club will be after him and i don't think that Port will trade him to us and the pakage that Hoggy put together probably won't tickle Ports fancy.

 

[The Scarecrow]

Only chance we have, is if Port let him go without trading him like they have with Stevens and Guerra, and then we offer him a decent deal to come to Collingwood. If he was to leave Port that is.

 

[Pedro]

Originally posted by The Scarecrow
Only chance we have, is if Port let him go without trading him like they have with Stevens and Guerra, and then we offer him a decent deal to come to Collingwood. If he was to leave Port that is.

I'm pretty sure Port traded a 30 something draft pick for Guerra. I guess it just depends on whether or not Salopek wants to leave. I can't see them trading him unless he dead set wants out.

 

[shuveradda]

It's Gonna Be Tough to get him here. No Matter how bad he wants to Come. Port will not Deal with us.