Do you think Carr will come to Dockerland now?

[PowerKop]

I am astounded u think Matt is better than Josh. Fairdinkum u guys need to c past the purple haze and think about the ******** u are saying.

 

[voodoo_86]

Who said he was better? (you'll probably find a quote, i havent read this whole thread)

Everything i've read however states Josh is the better player, but you lot are underrating Matt, he was injured pretty much all season, missed the last half etc. Last year he was very good and probably the better of the 2.

 

[BB gun]

I am astounded u think Matt is better than Josh. Fairdinkum u guys need to c past the purple haze and think about the ******** u are saying.

M Carr stats
http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/players/M/Matthew_Carr.html
J Carr
http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/players/J/Josh_Carr.html

The stats show that J Carr is a bit better than his brother. But what the stats don't show is the injury that M Carr has had, that has not stopped him playing, but has affected his performance. eg his eyes last year, stress fractures this year

 

[raffrox]

I am astounded u think Matt is better than Josh. Fairdinkum u guys need to c past the purple haze and think about the ******** u are saying.

I''ve said this before some where on BF but hey.

Last year the WAFC picked WA's official satate of origin team. Matthew made it and Josh didn't. Simple as that. So obviously its not just crazy Freo people who think Matt is better than Josh.

Matty was injured this year so its not a fair indication of his worth especially stats-wise.

They are both good players but I'd say Josh is a touch over rated and Matty is a touch under rated. Josh is most probably slighty better but not by much at all.

 

[Thierry Henry]

Josh Carr is the better play. 100 people out of 100 will tell you that.

 

[voodoo_86]

Noone is arguing that point, are you stupid?

Where do these idiots come from..

 

[The_Juddanaut]

Freo fans are idiots - they generally have no idea

Only reason Carr wants to come to Freo is because his brother is there - nothing else in appealing - the place smells of wet dogs

 

[raffrox]

Josh Carr is the better play. 100 people out of 100 will tell you that.

Nothing like bull**** one line generalisations when your proven you just might not be right.

I even agreed with you but its not by the margin you think.

 

[crazy_big_al]

I am still unsure i think he may stay at power

 

[Thierry Henry]

Nothing like bull**** one line generalisations when your proven you just might not be right.

I even agreed with you but its not by the margin you think.

I do agree maybe not 100 out of 100 however a large margin would belive that Josh is the better player