Draftees Compared to Players on Pies List

[ant22]

No need for Stupidity here - Would like Serious Posts

Seriously Dave, how can you expect all serious answers when you are asking people to compare players before most people have seen them play(besides a3 minute youtube clip)

 

[Skade]

^^Well ant, he's just trying to get some discussion going. Most of us don't know these guy's very well like you said. Bit of uneducated guessing/fun. Plus Dave needs another 17 threads this week to reach hie quoter.

It would be good to bump this thread after a season, and see how the comparisons look then. Hopefully not too many would have dived south.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Well Rounds was likened to Boak by Gary Hocking

I have a feeling it was by Turner, who is from memory the regional development manager down there or something. I don't think it was Buddha Hocking who made that comparison.

Either way, it may be a fair comparison but I haven't seen much of Boak this season, primarily because he plays for Port who no-one watches!

 

[King Woodie]

Sampler, I agree with your Blight comparison... I think he is much more like Goddard than Kennelly (who is far poorer in arial contests) and Cox (who is far softer).

On our current list, Goldsack would be the closest comparison from what I see, as with Scott Reed.

Not sure we have nailed Sidebottom yet, seems far more skilled than the Bartel type for mine, and not as prolific.