Dud's for the Dee's

[Demon Errol]

We have picked up our fair share of let me say players that have not lived up to their expectations. Let me start Phil Carmen, Troy Longmuir, and some guy Collins from Adelaide in early 2000 ?

 

[Bartram_Class]

Matty Collins, played in the 2000 GF with a broken arm didnt he?

Also, Grgic, The Cockatoo-Collins Boys, Cammy Hunter

 

[Demon Errol]

That's him Yze.. What about the awsome foursome rower "peaches mango Peach's " Aarrrggg ! James Tomkin.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Some more i can think of....

James Cook - Started like a gem too

Craig Smoker - What happened to him?

Gary Moorcroft - We wont go there

 

[Demon Errol]

Some more i can think of....

James Cook - Started like a gem too

Craig Smoker - What happened to him?

Gary Moorcroft - We wont go there

Think James Cook got eaten by cannibals and Smoker I think is still doing well with Tassie in the VFL.

 

[Demon Errol]

No it's Benny Beams that's with Tassie thinks Smokes went back to WA.

The Gasper brother comes to mind.....

 

[Bartram_Class]

No it's Benny Beams that's with Tassie thinks Smokes went back to WA.

The Gasper brother comes to mind.....

The Gasper was a shocker, who was that big ruckman we used to have around 1998, wore no.40 i think?

Cant have been Jamar, i might have to get Hotter Than Hell out

 

[melbournemartin]

Mark Brady?

i remember playing AFL 99 and using him all the time because, for some reason, he has tremendous speed stats so noone could catch him

 

[Bartram_Class]

Mark Brady?

i remember playing AFL 99 and using him all the time because, for some reason, he has tremendous speed stats so noone could catch him

Thats the one

 

[w00dy]

Matty Collins, played in the 2000 GF with a broken arm didnt he?

he played pretty much as our 3rd tall down back that season and did an awesome job... was unlucky to be delisted

 

[goDees22]

The "dud" brothers we got stuck with

Luke Ottens - Brad
Damien Gaspar - Darren
Both of the crap cockatoo-collins'

cant believe no-one has made mention of luke williams yet
theres too many to name really

 

[Bartram_Class]

The "dud" brothers we got stuck with

Luke Ottens - Brad
Damien Gaspar - Darren
Both of the crap cockatoo-collins'

cant believe no-one has made mention of luke williams yet
theres too many to name really

That Williams dud managed to play 60 odd games.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Newton! "Mutant" Molloy the ugliest man ever!!! I remember even our fans used to hang ******** on him during games.

 

[Demon Errol]

Hamster. The Juice had un-tapped potential and could have been great but for injuries. I think he's still onboard as a coach ?

Come to think of it, I think we never got a good player from Collingwood. Danny Seow Ewww.... Henry Coles in the late 70's was a fair Rover but...

at least they got Woey from us he had a good first year there.

 

[Brock Machine]

The Juice had un-tapped potential and could have been great but for injuries. I think he's still onboard as a coach ?

Think he's now the media manager, doing a good job too IMHO.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Hamster. The Juice had un-tapped potential and could have been great but for injuries. I think he's still onboard as a coach ?

Come to think of it, I think we never got a good player from Collingwood. Danny Seow Ewww.... Henry Coles in the late 70's was a fair Rover but...

at least they got Woey from us he had a good first year there.

Player welfare or something like that. Also I raise you a Steven Pitt and a Robert Pyman.

 

[Demon Errol]

Hampster I raise you again with Carlton Dud's Vin Cattaggio and Micheal Young. Vin had a nice affro though lol.

 

[BT]

Nick Pesch (Gee thanx Crows!)
Martin Heppell (Garbage)
David Grant (Past it well before he got here)
Wayne "Moose" Henwood (1 MFC game too many)

I could go on...

 

[Demon Errol]

Do's any one remember tassies finest ruckman Graham Hunnibell.. lol sheesh

 

[Supermercado]

Matthew Collins was a tank. Getting rid of him was one of the stupidest things we ever did, given the general creampuff status of our backline over the next couple of years when Shanahan/Ingerson/Seecamp went.

What about Scott Chisholm anyone? Absolute rubbish. Had pace but no idea how to use it, we may as well have signed Matt Shirvington.

 

[cannons]

Well, this could cause a slight argument, but it shouldn't.
Steven Armstrong. Had the potential but never really found a spot in the side. Good VFL player, but that form never game out in the big league. I don't think he got as much of a go as he shoud've, but I think he still fits into this category.

 

[goDees22]

Well, this could cause a slight argument, but it shouldn't.
Steven Armstrong. Had the potential but never really found a spot in the side. Good VFL player, but that form never game out in the big league. I don't think he got as much of a go as he shoud've, but I think he still fits into this category.

not a dud at all.

 

[cannons]

For what reason?

 

[Demon Errol]

Cannons. We all wanted Armo to be the next Steven Tingay. Probably could of have more game time but diden't show enough to warrent a start in our best 22.

 

[Demon Errol]

Matthew Collins was a tank. Getting rid of him was one of the stupidest things we ever did, given the general creampuff status of our backline over the next couple of years when Shanahan/Ingerson/Seecamp went.

What about Scott Chisholm anyone? Absolute rubbish. Had pace but no idea how to use it, we may as well have signed Matt Shirvington.

Super. Re Matty Collins Can I have some of whatever your on. He was soft lightly built but yes he did play with injury give him that.

The Scotty Chisholm comment couldent agree with you more.