Remove this Banner Ad

News Eddie responds to Steele Sidebottom’s actions and suspension

Is Sidebottom’s 4 week suspension fair?

  • Yes 4 weeks is spot on

    Votes: 135 56.5%
  • No, 2 weeks would have been fair

    Votes: 37 15.5%
  • He should only have gotten one week

    Votes: 8 3.3%
  • He should lose the vice captaincy

    Votes: 29 12.1%
  • He should have got 5+ weeks

    Votes: 50 20.9%
  • He’s been made an unfair example of, we should have sympathy for players in the current enviro

    Votes: 5 2.1%

  • Total voters
    239

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Agree with the earlier post. 3 weeks would have sufficed. But Eddie saying they’re proud of him for coming clean and copping a four week ban on the chin is laughable. All because he got so pissed he didn’t know what he was doing. How about not getting blind drunk. He’s a leader of the club and knows better.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I'm somewhat surprised by the poll results that people think 4 weeks or 5+ weeks is the correct punishment, putting it on par or worse than Lachie Hunter breaking quarantine, crashing his car, and running away.

I would've also liked Eddie to say more about how this is very disappointing from Steele though.
 


Does anyone else think this is just a bizzare interview?
McGuire was okay in this instance. Defending his player, but not his actions... saying it's a pretty harsh suspension and well done to Sidebottom for copping it sweet. What's wrong with that? Seems okay to me. Not sure why people are getting stuck in. The reason why Collingwood and my club Hawthorn are great clubs is because they support their players. They don't publicly shit all over them like some other loser clubs do.

Tony Jones, on the other hand... What a bellend! How does that tool have such a prominent job in the media?
There isn't a person who meets him who doesn't come away thinking "F**k this guy!"
 
McGuire was okay in this instance. Defending his player, but not his actions... saying it's a pretty harsh suspension and well done to Sidebottom for copping it sweet. What's wrong with that? Seems okay to me. Not sure why people are getting stuck in. The reason why Collingwood and my club Hawthorn are great clubs is because they support their players. They don't publicly sh*t all over them like some other loser clubs do.

Tony Jones, on the other hand... What a bellend! How does that tool have such a prominent job in the media?
There isn't a person who meets him who doesn't come away thinking "F**k this guy!"
Screen Shot 2020-07-01 at 8.18.51 pm.png
Chompers reckons it was a go !
 
Considering the crisis emerging in Melbourne this is a baffling position to
publicly take.

If you want to challenge the 4 weeks that is your right as a footy club. But to come out and say you’re proud of your vice captain? For getting on the piss with a teammate about to endure surgery then months of physical rehab? For breaching quarantine rules and getting so pissed he needed the cops to take him home? If he found his own way home would he have reported it to the club? I doubt it.

Surely nobody with a brain respects this idiotic, racist dimwit? Eddie has so many conflicts of interest he’s lost any shred of journalistic integrity he ever actually had. How does he back this position up tomorrow when he puts his radio hat back on?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Lol at Maguire trying to explain how Sidebottom has no clear recollection of events, can’t recall his movements, was disorientated etc etc because of the effects of drinking too much of something that he hasn’t been used to. Can’t wait for real action to hit our screens in the next few hours/days.
 
McGuire was okay in this instance. Defending his player, but not his actions... saying it's a pretty harsh suspension and well done to Sidebottom for copping it sweet. What's wrong with that? Seems okay to me. Not sure why people are getting stuck in. The reason why Collingwood and my club Hawthorn are great clubs is because they support their players. They don't publicly sh*t all over them like some other loser clubs do.

Tony Jones, on the other hand... What a bellend! How does that tool have such a prominent job in the media?
There isn't a person who meets him who doesn't come away thinking "F**k this guy!"
Nedward is effectively saying Collingwood are above the rules of the game and the country because he doesn’t feel anything he did is wrong. It is simply deflection from their other issues. The average joe wouldn’t be able to justify if they did somehting like this. Nedward using his dictatorship to prove the moronity of Collingwood. Good on tony jones for calling him out, everyone else is too scared to do so
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Seriously - the guy put the entire AFL season in jeapardy. Victoria is currently experiencing a surge, and whole suburbs have been locked down. Other states are already having major hesitations about giving exemptions to the very strict quarantine laws for travelling between states and breaches by senior players puts those exemptions at extreme risk .... and Eddie is proud of him !!!!!

WTF ???

he is lucky I am not on the panel - he would have been out for a lot longer than 4 weeks.
 
Park the covid issue and consider this. Vice captain of a club was found off his chops during the season on an early Sunday morning half dressed and had to to be driven home by the police. I just don’t know where to start with that one alone let alone digest that McGuire doesn’t seem to have an issue with it. Must be some major cultural issues at Collingwood.
 
Eddie and Collingwood are showing how far removed from reality they are. Given what Victoria is going through this wasn't the right approach today.

I used to like Eddie but I think he has turned into what John Elliott was towards the end at Carlton. Living in his own world and no one taking him seriously.
 
My interpretation from Eddie is.... so if you go somewhere with the best intentions, have a few to many then you are excused for any poor behaviours that follow.

Just think of all the assaults and domestic violence that have occurred under the same rationale that Ed is giving a free pass to Sidebottom for.

In saying that, what i think Ed is really thinking is that the covid measures are a load of sh*t and i support my player fully.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

News Eddie responds to Steele Sidebottom’s actions and suspension

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top