Enough is enough guys!

[mike91]

The fact that I even have to make this thread is sad, seriously guys come on, we have brain cells, we aren't wet toast e girl supporters.

I'm sick of everyone saying drop Dawson, WE ALL WANT HIM DROPPED, obviously he should be dropped, but was he ever dropped at St Kilda? No? Well what makes you think Ross is going to drop hes love child? He is the reason why Silvagni is learning tro play as a forward. No one wants Silvagni in the team more than me, I don't want him in the forward line, I want him back in the backline, but it doesn't look like happening any time soon. Stop saying drop Dawson, we get the f***ing point, fact of the matter is he wont be dropped.

Bottom line = We all want him dropped, but it wont happen, so stop putting in threads for weekly changes saying 'Out - Dawson' when it wont happen.

 

[believe_it]

Maybe we should picket the Freo shop - lets make change happen.

 

[willoblue]

My preference would be for all of our players to be given a "fair go"

The amount of negativity towards Hill for example beggars belief.

How about a week off from bagging our own? Heck, let's make it an official Freo Big Footy idea? Perhaps next week?

Just an idea.

 

[mike91]

My preference would be for all of our players to be given a "fair go"

The amount of negativity towards Hill for example beggars belief.

How about a week off from bagging our own? Heck, let's make it an official Freo Big Footy idea? Perhaps next week?

Just an idea.

Lol, we should actually try that, actually show positives towards the team instead of people always looking at the negitives.

 

[Admiral Byng]

My preference would be for all of our players to be given a "fair go"

The amount of negativity towards Hill for example beggars belief.

How about a week off from bagging our own? Heck, let's make it an official Freo Big Footy idea? Perhaps next week?

Just an idea.

Hello Willo, and welcome to Big Footy....

 

[BeinPurplenGreen]

Thank you for your contribution Mike, spoken like a true twenty one year old.

Many of us will continue to call for Dawson's dropping, simply because he deserves to be dropped as he is just not as good as Silvagni.

The fact you don't like reading it won't stop it happening. Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it.

Fairly odd approach from a generation Zer to try to stop healthy debate.

But that is what you get when you want to be like mike...

 

[Nickos66]

We should drop Dawson this week.

 

[Arcassius]

We should drop Pavlich this week

 

[Randomizor]

Thank you for your contribution Mike, spoken like a true twenty one year old.

Many of us will continue to call for Dawson's dropping, simply because he deserves to be dropped as he is just not as good as Silvagni.

The fact you don't like reading it won't stop it happening. Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it.

Fairly odd approach from a generation Zer to try to stop healthy debate.

But that is what you get when you want to be like mike...

I agree with what you're saying to a degree, but invalidating anybody's opinion because of their age is a little naiive.

An Ad Hominem does not a good argument make.

In saying that, I agree that healthy debate should continue. There will be those that call for Dawson to be dropped, and those who will defend his position (personally, not sure why).

Mike's opinion happens to be that we should stop talking about it. I can respect that, even if I don't agree with it.

 

[mike91]

Thank you for your contribution Mike, spoken like a true twenty one year old.

Many of us will continue to call for Dawson's dropping, simply because he deserves to be dropped as he is just not as good as Silvagni.

The fact you don't like reading it won't stop it happening. Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it.

Fairly odd approach from a generation Zer to try to stop healthy debate.

But that is what you get when you want to be like mike...

Really? Wow, your actually using this card? I made this thread not because I'm in your words immature or ball less, which if you knew me you wouldnt be saying, but because this debate will go on all year and we all agree that Silvagni should be in, but dumbasses like you keep saying drop Dawson when it seems highly likely that he wont be dropped. If anything I'm just trying to save peoples time and end a useless debate now instead of it going on for thole whole year. If anything, I think you have made yourself look immature with that idiotic comment.

 

[Purple Jesus]

Dawson is shit and Pavlich is vastly overrated. I have not once seen him win his own ball vs two or not. Also, no second efforts, thinks he's done his job after a token effort. Yes you're double teamed but have been for years, at least contribute, make a contest or unleash another player.

 

[BeinPurplenGreen]

I agree with what you're saying to a degree, but invalidating anybody's opinion because of their age is a little naiive.

An Ad Hominem does not a good argument make.

In saying that, I agree that healthy debate should continue. There will be those that call for Dawson to be dropped, and those who will defend his position (personally, not sure why).

Mike's opinion happens to be that we should stop talking about it. I can respect that, even if I don't agree with it.

Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it

 

[Randomizor]

Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it

Excuse me? That addressed a grand total of 0 points in my post.

Also, I was actually agreeing with you.

 

[Sman-21]

First you are wrong
It was reported a day or 2 ago that Lyon thinks Silvagni is a good defender there trying him down forward to help his development of his defensive game.
Not trying to turn him into a forward.

2nd He was prob never dropped at Saints because they had noone else.

3rd he cant be too important to our defense an must be getting close to being dropped, as the last 2 games not long after yet another terrible turnover, under no pressure, he has been put up forward to see if he can do anything there.

And finally sports "journos" read these forums an will see how frustrated we all are getting at Dawson, sooner or later one might ask the question to Lyon about Dawsons performance and any chance of him being dropped for Silvagni.

If i see an area we can improve upon by dropping certain players, Im going to mention it.
I will always look at how we can keep improving.

Dont care if we are winning every game by 50 points if i see a small weakness that could be improved by player X im going to say it.

Its the same reason people keep going on about how we need to draft some key forwards.
It hasnt happened an doesnt look like it will happen.
We see it as a weakness an position we are lacking in, so we keep bringing it up.

 

[Arcassius]

Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it

I just wanted to have that line in the thread again - in case anyone missed it.

 

[Nickos66]

Either don't read the threads or grow a pair, build a bridge and get over it

I just wanted to have that line in the thread again - in case anyone missed it.

Delicious irony isn't it.

 

[mike91]

First you are wrong
It was reported a day or 2 ago that Lyon thinks Silvagni is a good defender there trying him down forward to help his development of his defensive game.
Not trying to turn him into a forward.

2nd He was prob never dropped at Saints because they had noone else.

3rd he cant be too important to our defense an must be getting close to being dropped, as the last 2 games not long after yet another terrible turnover, under no pressure, he has been put up forward to see if he can do anything there.

And finally sports "journos" read these forums an will see how frustrated we all are getting at Dawson, sooner or later one might ask the question to Lyon about Dawsons performance and any chance of him being dropped for Silvagni.

If i see an area we can improve upon by dropping certain players, Im going to mention it.
I will always look at how we can keep improving.

Dont care if we are winning every game by 50 points if i see a small weakness that could be improved by player X im going to say it.

Its the same reason people keep going on about how we need to draft some key forwards.
It hasnt happened an doesnt look like it will happen.
We see it as a weakness an position we are lacking in, so we keep bringing it up.

The name Max Hudghton ring a bell to you? You know, the played Lyon kept out of the team for Dawson? And omg I know Silvagni is better than Dawson, if you've been paying even the slightest bit of attention you'd know that.

 

[IAMJUNGLEMUFFIN]

Is OP trolling?

 

[Arcassius]

Delicious irony isn't it.

I loved it

 

[BeinPurplenGreen]

Is OP trolling?

Sadly no, OP is serious. Very, very, very serious.

Bridge, cojones, over it.

 

[Arcassius]

Bridge, cojones, over it.

Are you inferring that you've built said bridge and crossed?

 

[BeinPurplenGreen]

Are you inferring that you've built said bridge and crossed?

Not a journey I need to take, rather one that certain young BF jedis in training need to go through.

As Yoda would say "Always with you, what cannot be done". Mike seems to like telling people what not to do.

Telling people to stop talking on Big Footy is like trying to work out what Paris Hilton will do when she isn't famous - utterly pointless.

Though, if I did have to build a bridge, I'd definitely go for one of those single strand downhill cable bridges that you see in the Mekong Delta - grab the flying fox, throw the old pushbike over the shoulder, and glide on down in a one way descent into the great unknown - with no brakes...

 

[Reginald Perrin]

First you are wrong
It was reported a day or 2 ago that Lyon thinks Silvagni is a good defender there trying him down forward to help his development of his defensive game.

Ha ha. Another naive person believing what Rossco says to the media rather than what his actions demonstrate.

As he walked past our section at half time, I was only one of many that yelled out to Ross to bring Silvagni back. It raised a wry smile from the coach.

 

[Arcassius]

Ha ha. Another naive person believing what Rossco says to the media rather than what his actions demonstrate.

As he walked past our section at half time, I was only one of many that yelled out to Ross to bring Silvagni back. It raised a wry smile from the coach.

Ha ha. Another naive person believing that the demonstrating of an emotive fickle rabble will affect how the coach and club do their jobs.

 

[paccraig]

The fact that I even have to make this thread is sad,.

Seriously, who the ____ do you think you are?. You have been on this board 2 minutes. Listen to the blokes that add value before you start every 3rd thread