eth-dog's 2011 Phantom

[eth-dog]

I've been on this board, critiquing peoples phantoms, well this is the one I think will end up happening. I'll add my descriptions later, I've got cricket soon. I'll do the first 2 rounds, and feel free to ask questions:

ROUND ONE

1. GWS- Jonathon Patton
2. GWS- Stephen Coniglio
3. GWS- Dom Tyson
4. GWS- Will Hoskin-Elliot
5. GWS- Billy Longer
6. Port Adelaide- Chad Wingard
7. GWS- Adam Tomlinson
8. Brisbane- Liam Sumner
9. GWS- Taylor Adams
10. GWS- Matt Buntine
11. GWS- Fraser McInness
12. Brisbane- Myles Bolger
13. GWS- Shane Kersten
14. GWS- Zyrus Manson
15. Richmond- Elliot Kavanagh
16. Fremantle- Todd Elton
17. Western Bulldogs- Brandon Ellis
18. North Melbourne- Brad McKenzie
19. Essendon- Toby Greene
20. Fremantle- Mitchell Grigg
21. Sydney- Tom Mitchell (F/S)
22. Carlton- Jackson Paine
23. West Coast- Hayden Crozier
24. Gold Coast- Sam Docherty
25. St. Kilda- Julian Dobosz
26. Richmond- Daniel Markworth
27. Adelaide- Alex Forster
28. West Coast- Murray Newman
29. Fremantle- Clay Smith
30. Brisbane- Cam Ellis-Yolmen

ROUND TWO

31. Essendon- Devon Smith
32. Geelong- Andrew Boseley
33. Hawthorn- Jordan Lockyer
34. Geelong- Alex Woodward
35. St. Kilda- Shane Nelson
36. Melbourne- Jackson Merrett
37. St. Kilda- Seb Ross
38. Hawthorn- Josh Waldhunter
39. Western Bulldogs- Sam Frost
40. North Melbourne- Tom Sheridan
41. Adelaide- Adam Kennedy
42. St. Kilda- Michael Bussey
43. Sydney- Sam Kerridge
44. Carlton- Brody Mihocek
45. Port Adelaide- Michael Talia
46. Adelaide- Marley Williams
47. Brisbane- Jack Newnes
48. Geelong- Jai Sheahan
49. Western Bulldogs- Josh Tynan

 

[Rowie6]

I've been on this board, critiquing peoples phantoms, well this is the one I think will end up happening. I'll add my descriptions later, I've got cricket soon. I'll do the first 2 rounds, and feel free to ask questions:

ROUND ONE

1. GWS- Jonathon Patton
2. GWS- Stephen Coniglio
3. GWS- Dom Tyson
4. GWS- Will Hoskin-Elliot
5. GWS- Billy Longer
6. Port Adelaide- Chad Wingard
7. GWS- Adam Tomlinson
8. Brisbane- Liam Sumner
9. GWS- Taylor Adams
10. GWS- Matt Buntine
11. GWS- Fraser McInness
12. Brisbane- Myles Bolger
13. GWS- Shane Kersten
14. GWS- Zyrus Manson
15. Richmond- Elliot Kavanagh
16. Fremantle- Todd Elton
17. Western Bulldogs- Brandon Ellis
18. North Melbourne- Brad McKenzie
19. Essendon- Toby Greene
20. Fremantle- Mitchell Grigg
21. Sydney- Tom Mitchell (F/S)
22. Carlton- Jackson Paine
23. West Coast- Hayden Crozier
24. Gold Coast- Sam Docherty
25. St. Kilda- Julian Dobosz
26. Richmond- Daniel Markworth
27. Adelaide- Alex Forster
28. West Coast- Murray Newman
29. Fremantle- Clay Smith
30. Brisbane- Cam Ellis-Yolmen

ROUND TWO

31. Essendon- Devon Smith
32. Geelong- Andrew Boseley
33. Hawthorn- Jordan Lockyer
34. Geelong- Alex Woodward
35. St. Kilda- Shane Nelson
36. Melbourne- Jackson Merrett
37. St. Kilda- Seb Ross
38. Hawthorn- Josh Waldhunter
39. Western Bulldogs- Sam Frost
40. North Melbourne- Tom Sheridan
41. Adelaide- Adam Kennedy
42. St. Kilda- Michael Bussey
43. Sydney- Sam Kerridge
44. Carlton- Brody Mihocek
45. Port Adelaide- Michael Talia
46. Adelaide- Marley Williams
47. Brisbane- Jack Newnes
48. Geelong- Jai Sheahan
49. Western Bulldogs- Josh Tynan

Your kidding yourself if you think Toby Greene (19) and Devon Smith (31) will slide to these draft picks.Greene (12) and Smith (20) at the latest.

 

[theGav56]

Damn pity the Dockers could not find a KPP in their first 3 picks.

 

[stkildathunda]

Your kidding yourself if you think Toby Greene (19) and Devon Smith (31) will slide to these draft picks.Greene (12) and Smith (20) at the latest.

If Michael Talia gets past 4 of StKilda's picks i will go down to Linen House and burn the place down

 

[_Maximus_12]

If Michael Talia gets past 4 of StKilda's picks i will go down to Linen House and burn the place down

Do not want Michael Tahlia. He's too robotic.

 

[morebeer]

Will Greene last until pick 19? I was of the understanding Essendon needed outside mids, why would they pick an inside mid?

 

[Monocle]

Whilst I appreciate your effort.

Your Phantom lacks credibility because you have dealt your team Green @ 19 and then Devon Smith @ 31.

lol

 

[eth-dog]

Your kidding yourself if you think Toby Greene (19) and Devon Smith (31) will slide to these draft picks.Greene (12) and Smith (20) at the latest.

I disagree. Brisbane need talls, GWS want a mixture so mids will slide, and IMO one of them will be Greene. As for Smith, don't rate him as much as others, just a second round pick IMO

Damn pity the Dockers could not find a KPP in their first 3 picks.

Elton is a KPP

If Michael Talia gets past 4 of StKilda's picks i will go down to Linen House and burn the place down

Don't think you need him.

Will Greene last until pick 19? I was of the understanding Essendon needed outside mids, why would they pick an inside mid?

Essendon need inside/outside mids, that's how I see Greene. I think we'll take an outside mid with 59

 

[stkildathunda]

Don't think you need him.

We dont need a tall defender??

Tom Simpkin
Sam Fisher
Jackson Ferguson (rookie)

They are our only tall defenders on our list.. Sorry but ask any Saints supporter (and most other supporters) and they'll tell you we need 3 things. Backup ruckman and tall defenders and tall forwards..

 

[eth-dog]

We dont need a tall defender??

Tom Simpkin
Sam Fisher
Jackson Ferguson (rookie)

They are our only tall defenders on our list.. Sorry but ask any Saints supporter (and most other supporters) and they'll tell you we need 3 things. Backup ruckman and tall defenders and tall forwards..

Doesn't Stanley play in defence too? I probably miscalculated with the Saints. Amatuers like me make these mistakes a lot

 

[theGav56]

Elton is a KPP

If he is rated as the best KPP at that selection by you, then fair enough.

Most of the Phantoms rate him as a ruck/KPP which we don't need with Clarke, Bradley, MJ, and Griffin all making reasonable 2nd ruck claims, and our eye on Moeller next year who is also KPF/Ruck.

 

[stkildathunda]

Doesn't Stanley play in defence too? I probably miscalculated with the Saints. Amatuers like me make these mistakes a lot

Nah he doesnt. He is a wannabe ruckman/forward... Archer has played couple games down back for Sandringham but nothing special. Def need a couple of talls..

Kudos for trying though, its not a easy task at all

 

[scooter600x]

Fairly sure Adelaide won't draft Adam Kennedy

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

I'd be happy if this was real!!

 

[Mad Fan of AFL]

How could Adelaide draft Adam Kennedy? I thought GWS signed him up?