Remove this Banner Ad

Fev at Collingwood ?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

  • Thread starter
  • Banned
  • #3
Considering the scoreline, we need him desperately.

But,
if he continues to drop hi head when things aren't going his way, then we may need to look at trading him for someone else.

Saying that.. there isn't much at Collingwood that would be worth picking up anyway
 
surpstar said:
Considering the scoreline, we need him desperately.

But,
if he continues to drop hi head when things aren't going his way, then we may need to look at trading him for someone else.

Saying that.. there isn't much at Collingwood that would be worth picking up anyway
Click to expand...
They're priority picks will be worth a bit!
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

gandaal said:
I'd ask for two first round picks, including one in the top 5 and Jason Cloke in exchange for Fevola and one of Prendergast, Davies, McGrath, Norman or Morrell.
Click to expand...
i think you have your clokes mixed up, travis is the one you want.
jason is a spud, we don't want a repeat of the cameron croad debacle.
 
bibi01 said:
i think you have your clokes mixed up, travis is the one you want.
jason is a spud, we don't want a repeat of the cameron croad debacle.
Click to expand...
Cameron Cloke debacle? :confused:

Collingwood will never give up Travis Cloke and I wouldn't blame them. You've got to be realistic about this sort of thing.

Jason Cloke is a potential Gorrilla who has decent skills. If Collingwood are stupid enough to trade him I'd love to see him at Carlton. He'd have to be better than Morrell and Norman surely? He might just be a diamond in the rough.
 
Gandaal... Jason Cloke is small and crap. Surely you mean Cameron...

I'd take Cam Cloke, but you'd be mad to think they'd want Morrell. Norman is young and may yet get his act together, but Diggers? Nah.


Also, Cameron Croad is Trent's younger, less interested brother who took our pay for two years before deciding he'd rather be a bum.
 
bluechampion said:
Gandaal... Jason Cloke is small and crap. Surely you mean Cameron...

I'd take Cam Cloke, but you'd be mad to think they'd want Morrell. Norman is young and may yet get his act together, but Diggers? Nah.


Also, Cameron Croad is Trent's younger, less interested brother who took our pay for two years before deciding he'd rather be a bum.
Click to expand...
Took our pay? What the hell are you talking about? Besides they wouldn't trade Cameron either.

Jason Cloke- 189 cms
Mal Michaels- 190 cms

You don't need to be 195cm+ to be a good defender. If we can beef him up he'd make a excellent second or third defender. He towelled Hamill up when Collingwood played St Kilda.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Regarding Fev and his recent comments regarding him finding out what he's worth on the market,does anyone smell another Hamill incident?
If he is entertaining thoughts of going to the highest bidder,he can ******** off as far as I'm concerned.
And as for a swap with Collingwood,I don't see anyone on their list that would be more than a stop-gap replacement!!
 
Turbocat said:
Would you guys consider doing a Richmond or Hawthorn, trading a top player for a couple First round picks. Id think he'd be worth at least what Thompson was worth and maybe what Ottens was worth, eg P12 & P16.
Click to expand...

He'd be worth a lot more than both of them based on the past couple of years. A FF as good as him who will kick 60+ for your side a year, an opportunity like this doesn't come every day. But that said, short term and long term, Fev is important for this club.

Then he'll dominated at Collingwood and wouldn't that make you sick? No way. Consistent or not, along with Thornton and Stevens he is one of our most valuable players. Sure, trade him for a pick and we might get a good young future backman. But who will kick the goals? Fevola, along with Kouta is a marketing tool as well. Why don't we wait until the end of the season and see where he is at then rather than now? Season isn't ove yet last tme I checked - plenty of time to make a stamp.
 
In terms of our top grade players we have
Stevens and Fevola... Possibly Kouta & Lappin but thats it..
We need Fevola, It would be a huge step backwards to let him go. We need to get in better (accountable) 2nd tier players to help them out. Kouta, Campo and Whitnall need to do what's right for the club and restructure their contracts so we can keep Fevola, Waite and Thornton, They could all earn far more if they decided to test the market.... What if we lose all of them?
 
Two things - what are we going to get for him from Collingwood?

Also - Do Collingwood really need him? They really need to rebuild, rather than potentially overpay a high priced recruit and therefore sacrifice building from the ground up.

Having said that, Carlton need him. We don't need his attitude, but we need a potential matchwinner.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I cannot see Fevola leaving the Blues. Maybe I'm being overly optomistic, but I just can't see it happening.

I can imagine the Blues will pay him a pretty big contract, but in the midst of Jonathon Brown staying with the Lions and Del Santo indicating he may stick with the Saints, it appears club loyalty is no longer a thing of the past.

If he's traded, it would devastate the Blues. We'd need massive compensation, as he's arguably our MVP. Top draft picks and a tall defender would be on the cards I'd suggest.

As silly as it sounds, and this will sound silly, Carlton could do with a Jason Cloke at the moment (yes I said Jason Cloke). He would slip into our back half with ease at the moment, as we are in desparate need of tall defenders.

I wouldn't be surprised if Carlton offer Collingwood a draft pick for him at the end of this year as he seems to be out of favour at Collingwood.
 
IMO, I think what may happen is that Campo and Whitnall will have to take on reduced contracts at the end of the year. Neither of them are worth anywhere near what they are being paid. Subsequently, this should free up some cash for Fevola and Waite.

I really can't see Fevola leaving.
 
HugeBluesFan said:
IMO, I think what may happen is that Campo and Whitnall will have to take on reduced contracts at the end of the year. .
Click to expand...
Campo will be on the veteran list next year. Only half the salary is counted in the salary cap.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Fev at Collingwood ?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top