Rumour Gaff back for prelim

[Aussie_boy]

More chance of a Freo vs Gold Coast grand final

 

[Tom_Thumb]

I still see Gaff in a Carlton Guernsey for some reason.

 

[2006_Eagles]

This is Bay 13?

 

[ABSOLUTE MADMAN]

In the extremely unlikely event that this is true, on what grounds would he even take this to court?

Sexism. Because no AFLW player has been suspended for the same amount of games. /s

 

[blue harvest]

Lol no, but Daniel Chick is due for another surprise appearance.

 

[Tom_Thumb]

What I find interesting is that the full details of Brayshaws injuries were not made public, if these injuries were grossly exaggerated by Freo then I believe Gaff has grounds for an appeal. The images I saw of Brayshaw was one tooth gone and there is mention of a Jaw Fracture not a hairline crack.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Mods should we just merge all of the Gaff threads into one mega-thread?

Most of them sound bogus

 

[Allikat]

What I find interesting is that the full details of Brayshaws injuries were not made public, if these injuries were grossly exaggerated by Freo then I believe Gaff has grounds for an appeal. The images I saw of Brayshaw was one tooth gone and there is mention of a Jaw Fracture not a hairline crack.

From Brayshaw's own mangled mouth

 

[Tom_Thumb]

From Brayshaw's own mangled mouth

No disrespect here but I have known a few guys over the years with broken jaws wired up and they couldn't speak like Andrew did there, just mumble through it without moving their mouth.

 

[Monument Hills]

This is gold, need to get some Freo responses to this.

more chance of both McGoverns coming to Freo

 

[Allikat]

No disrespect here but I have known a few guys over the years with broken jaws wired up and they couldn't speak like Andrew did there, just mumble through it without moving their mouth.

k so the likely story here is that our doctor made it up, his dentist made it up, all the medical appointments/surgery were fake, and Andy's putting on a show in the interview? Just to spite Gaff? Got it.

 

[StevenwellerHFC]

Gaff is a flipping legend, I hope Hawks can get him.

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Wow I didn't know kaiserchief13 was a journo

 

[ChesterTreasure]

if true why would you wait? not to open old wounds?

Maybe a situation has arisen in his life during the last few weeks that makes him desperate to play at least one more game this year.
Not saying that taking an appeal to a court of law is right - but it might just be a valid enough reason for him and the club to at least contemplate it.

 

[telsor]

Going to court rather than keeping it to the AFL tribunal in a case that would run the risk of criminal assault charges.

To quote Yes Minister, That would be a very courageous move.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Of course I don’t know for sure but by the way Gaff responded after the incident I couldn’t see him disrespecting the Brayshaw Family by trying to get the sentence reduced.

How is challenging the ban being disrespectful to anyone? The guy made a mistake and just wants to have his punishment reduced so he can do what he loves. Seems to me like fans like pulling the disrespectful move are because they don't want him to play so it weakens WC

 

[00Stinger]

No disrespect here but I have known a few guys over the years with broken jaws wired up and they couldn't speak like Andrew did there, just mumble through it without moving their mouth.

You are a dickhead

 

[00Stinger]

From Brayshaw's own mangled mouth

After watching this it makes you feel 8 weeks was not enough.

And to think Gaff had a sook about how this had been affecting him

 

[Taylor]

How is challenging the ban being disrespectful to anyone? The guy made a mistake and just wants to have his punishment reduced so he can do what he loves. Seems to me like fans like pulling the disrespectful move are because they don't want him to play so it weakens WC

It's the same sort of defense those rich white college boys mount against their sexual assault cases. It would seriously impact their ability to work later in life.

 

[Tom_Thumb]

After watching this it makes you feel 8 weeks was not enough.

And to think Gaff had a sook about how this had been affecting him

Moron, as if you get to penalise a guy for an obvious mistake. Barry Hall did worse and got to play in a GF which cost us a flag so the AFL owes us this small payback.

 

[00Stinger]

Moron, as if you get to penalise a guy for an obvious mistake. Barry Hall did worse and got to play in a GF which cost us a flag so the AFL owes us this small payback.

Maybe re read your post and that will tell you who the moron is champ!

He accidentally punched him? please give it a spell

That's a bit like a cheating wife saying she accidentally slipped and feel on his dick

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Moron, as if you get to penalise a guy for an obvious mistake. Barry Hall did worse and got to play in a GF which cost us a flag so the AFL owes us this small payback.

Yeah nah, I'm no Barry Hall fan and I agree he should've been rubbed out of that GF but in no way was him punching Maguire in the guts worse than Gaff breaking Brayshaw's jaw.

 

[kaiserchief13]

It's the same sort of defense those rich white college boys mount against their sexual assault cases. It would seriously impact their ability to work later in life.

What?

 

[astro1212]

k so the likely story here is that our doctor made it up, his dentist made it up, all the medical appointments/surgery were fake, and Andy's putting on a show in the interview? Just to spite Gaff? Got it.

Not to spite Gaff. They all lied to create a distraction for Ross Lyon's coaching failures. True story.

 

[ziad]

Not to spite Gaff. They all lied to create a distraction for Ross Lyon's coaching failures. True story.

they need to step up a bit more if thats the case