Phantom Draft GETGAFF MOCK DRAFT 2018

[Crow till I die]

You would have one of Stocker, RCD and Hately available at that stage I’m pretty certain.

What do you think about Clark at first pick?

I don't know enough about him other tgan reading others opinions on him. I would be expecting the crows will take one of caldwell, smith or ben king at 8 and i think all 3 are higher rated than clark

 

[getgaff]

TOP 30 UPDATED

1. CARLTON: Sam Walsh
2. GOLD COAST: Jack Lukosius
3. GOLD COAST: Izak Rankine
4. ST. KILDA: Max King
5. PORT ADELAIDE: Connor Rozee
6. GOLD COAST: Jye Caldwell
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: Bailey Smith
8. ADELAIDE: Jordan Clark
9. GWS: Jackson Hately
10. SYDNEY ACADEMY: Nick Blakely
11. PORT ADELAIDE: Ben King

12. GWS: Xavier Durrsma
13. NORTH NGA: Tarryn Thomas
14:. GELEONG: Riley Collier - Dawkins
15. ADELAIDE - Liam Stocker
16. FREMANTLE - Ian Hill
17. PORT ADELAIDE: Zac Butters
18. ADELAIDE: Sam Sturt
19. WESTERN BULLDOGS F/S: Rhylee West
20. RICHMOND: Xavier O'Halloran
21. BRISBANE: Chayce Jones
22. COLLINGWOOD NGA: Isaac Quaynor
23. GWS: Curtis Taylor
24. WEST COAST: Ely Smith

ENDS FIRST ROUND

25. ADELAIDE: Luke Valente
26. WEST COAST: Jez McLennan
27. MELBOURNE: Bailey Williams
28. GOLD COAST: Jacob Koschitzke
29. GWS: Sydney Stack
30. MELBOURNE: Ned McHenry

 

[Clems Knee]

TOP 30 UPDATED

1. CARLTON: Sam Walsh
2. GOLD COAST: Jack Lukosius
3. GOLD COAST: Izak Rankine
4. ST. KILDA: Max King
5. PORT ADELAIDE: Connor Rozee
6. GOLD COAST: Jye Caldwell
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: Bailey Smith
8. ADELAIDE: Jordan Clark
9. GWS: Jackson Hately
10. SYDNEY ACADEMY: Nick Blakely
11. PORT ADELAIDE: Ben King

12. GWS: Xavier Durrsma
13. NORTH NGA: Tarryn Thomas
14:. GELEONG: Riley Collier - Dawkins
15. ADELAIDE - Liam Stocker
16. FREMANTLE - Ian Hill
17. PORT ADELAIDE: Zac Butters
18. ADELAIDE: Sam Sturt
19. WESTERN BULLDOGS F/S: Rhylee West
20. RICHMOND: Xavier O'Halloran
21. BRISBANE: Chayce Jones
22. COLLINGWOOD NGA: Isaac Quaynor
23. GWS: Curtis Taylor
24. WEST COAST: Ely Smith

ENDS FIRST ROUND

25. ADELAIDE: Luke Valente
26. WEST COAST: Jez McLennan
27. MELBOURNE: Bailey Williams
28. GOLD COAST: Jacob Koschitzke
29. GWS: Sydney Stack
30. MELBOURNE: Ned McHenry

You’ve made a few changes since 28/10. Any reasons for Freo picking Hill, compared to then?have you heard anything?
Ben King has also dropped out of the top ten. is that because you’ve rethought Gold Coast’s choices or another reason?

Thanks for continuing to publish your lists. One of the posters whose knowledge I respect on this board.

 

[getgaff]

You’ve made a few changes since 28/10. Any reasons for Freo picking Hill, compared to then?have you heard anything?

Appreciate the feedback mate.

Hill has been harder to pick than a busted nose for me.

Always anticipated that he’d be late first to early second round, anywhere in the range from Adelaide and GWS’s picks up until Melbourne’s second pick but didn’t see the Dees passing on him their if available.

Hearing about a fortnight ago that he wasn’t on the initial invite list to attend the draft further assured me.

Since than he seems to have got a invite to attend the draft in Melbourne lending me to think that he is in the Dockers sights.

Outside game suits playing at Optus Stadium perfectly also.

 

[getgaff]

Ben King has also dropped out of the top ten. is that because you’ve rethought Gold Coast’s choices or another reason?

Always thought King would fall somewhere between Gold Coast’s 6 and Port’s 10 which has become 11.

Gold Coast’s list management strategy of de-listing mature mids in Lyons, Barlow and Rischitelli (re rookie) is crazy if you ask me but lends to think that they want to rebuild the midfield from the bottom up, again, so I’ve gone with Jye Caldwell as a point of difference at 6.

The Suns are said to be showing interest in Jacob Koschitzke, also a key defender but slightly shorter than King, in the second round also which gave me more freedom to go colder on King at 6 also.

 

[Brizzys Squizzy]

TOP 30 UPDATED

1. CARLTON: Sam Walsh
2. GOLD COAST: Jack Lukosius
3. GOLD COAST: Izak Rankine
4. ST. KILDA: Max King
5. PORT ADELAIDE: Connor Rozee
6. GOLD COAST: Jye Caldwell
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: Bailey Smith
8. ADELAIDE: Jordan Clark
9. GWS: Jackson Hately
10. SYDNEY ACADEMY: Nick Blakely
11. PORT ADELAIDE: Ben King

12. GWS: Xavier Durrsma
13. NORTH NGA: Tarryn Thomas
14:. GELEONG: Riley Collier - Dawkins
15. ADELAIDE - Liam Stocker
16. FREMANTLE - Ian Hill
17. PORT ADELAIDE: Zac Butters
18. ADELAIDE: Sam Sturt
19. WESTERN BULLDOGS F/S: Rhylee West
20. RICHMOND: Xavier O'Halloran
21. BRISBANE: Chayce Jones
22. COLLINGWOOD NGA: Isaac Quaynor
23. GWS: Curtis Taylor
24. WEST COAST: Ely Smith

ENDS FIRST ROUND

25. ADELAIDE: Luke Valente
26. WEST COAST: Jez McLennan
27. MELBOURNE: Bailey Williams
28. GOLD COAST: Jacob Koschitzke
29. GWS: Sydney Stack
30. MELBOURNE: Ned McHenry

Would love Ely Smith at Brisbane

 

[getgaff]

FIRST 2 ROUNDS UPDATED - BID MATCH PICKS HAVE BEEN CHANGED E.G.: WITH THE WEST BID ON THE CURRENT ORDER 27 BECAME 31 & 32 BECAME 36

PICK 1. CARLTON: SAM WALSH
PICK 2. GOLD COAST: JACK LUKOSIUS
PICK 3. GOLD COAST: IZAK RANKINE
4. ST. KILDA: MAX KING
5. PORT ADELAIDE: CONNOR ROZEE
6. GOLD COAST: JYE CALDWELL
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: BAILEY SMITH
8. SYDNEY ACADEMY: NICK BLAKEY (LOSE 3 SECOND ROUND PICK PICKS - PICK 38 BECOMES 51)
9. ADELAIDE: BEN KING
10. GWS: JACKSON HATELY

11. PORT ADELAIDE: JORDAN CLARK
12. GWS: CHAYCE JONES
13. NORTH MELBOURNE NGA: TARRYN THOMAS (LOSE 4 X 3RD ROUND PICKS - 49 BECOMES 65)
14. GEELONG: RILEY COLLIER DAWKINS
15. ADELAIDE: ZAK BUTTERS
16. FREMANTLE: IAN HILL
17. PORT ADELAIDE: XAVIER DURRSMA
18. COLLINGWOOD NGA: ISAAC QUAYNOR (LOSE ALL THIRD ROUND PICKS - 4 POINT DEFICIT IN 2019)
19. ADELAIDE: LIAM STOCKER
20. WESTERN BULLDOGS: RHYLEE WEST (LOSE CURRENT PICKS 31 AND 36, PICK 36 BECOMES 43)
21. RICHMOND: XAVIER O'HALLORAN
22. BRISBANE: ELY SMITH
23. GWS: SAM STURT
24. WEST COAST: CURTIS TAYLOR

END FIRST ROUND


PICK 25. ADELAIDE: LUKE VALENTE
PICK 26. WEST COAST: JEZ McLENNAN
PICK 27. MELBOURNE: BAILEY WILLIAMS
28. GOLD COAST: JACOB KOSCHITZKE
29. GWS: SYDNEY STACK
30. MELBOURNE: NED McHENRY
31. GOLD COAST: MITCH MAGUIRE
32. NORTH MELBOURNE F/S: BAILEY SCOTT (LOSE PICKS 59, 62 - 106 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)
33. BRISBANE: JACOB KENNERLEY
34. FREMANTLE: LUKE FOLEY
35. BRISBANE ACADEMY: CONNOR McFADYEN (LOSE 2ND ROUND PICK - 223 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)
36. ESSENDON: JACK BYTEL
37. GWS ACADEMY: KIEREN BRIGGS (LOSE 3RD ROUND PICK - GO INTO 2019 DEFICIT)
38. ST. KILDA: ZAC FOOT
39. RICHMOND: JAMES ROWBOTTOM
40. SYDNEY: FRASER TURNER

 

[Johnny Bananas]

22. BRISBANE: ELY SMITH
33. BRISBANE: JACOB KENNERLEY
35. BRISBANE ACADEMY: CONNOR McFADYEN (LOSE 2ND ROUND PICK - 223 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)

Don't mind Ely. Kennerley seems a little high but he addresses a need for sure.

Also how is it we go into a deficit when pick 35 pre-draft (which I think is pick 38 in this) should easily cover the points required?

 

[getgaff]

Don't mind Ely. Kennerley seems a little high but he addresses a need for sure.

Also how is it we go into a deficit when pick 35 pre-draft (which I think is pick 38 in this) should easily cover the points required?

Yeh my maths is stuffed on that. There’s definitely no deficit.

It’s just using that current pick you got from the Hawks and that gets pushed out.

Am working my way through it all again because a number of things don’t match up it seems.

 

[getgaff]

Don't mind Ely. Kennerley seems a little high but he addresses a need for sure.

Also how is it we go into a deficit when pick 35 pre-draft (which I think is pick 38 in this) should easily cover the points required?

That deficit belongs to GWS for Briggs if I remember correct.

 

[Eastcoasteagle]

FIRST 2 ROUNDS UPDATED - BID MATCH PICKS HAVE BEEN CHANGED E.G.: WITH THE WEST BID ON THE CURRENT ORDER 27 BECAME 31 & 32 BECAME 36

PICK 1. CARLTON: SAM WALSH
PICK 2. GOLD COAST: JACK LUKOSIUS
PICK 3. GOLD COAST: IZAK RANKINE
4. ST. KILDA: MAX KING
5. PORT ADELAIDE: CONNOR ROZEE
6. GOLD COAST: JYE CALDWELL
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: BAILEY SMITH
8. SYDNEY ACADEMY: NICK BLAKEY (LOSE 3 SECOND ROUND PICK PICKS - PICK 38 BECOMES 51)
9. ADELAIDE: BEN KING
10. GWS: JACKSON HATELY

11. PORT ADELAIDE: JORDAN CLARK
12. GWS: CHAYCE JONES
13. NORTH MELBOURNE NGA: TARRYN THOMAS (LOSE 4 X 3RD ROUND PICKS - 49 BECOMES 65)
14. GEELONG: RILEY COLLIER DAWKINS
15. ADELAIDE: ZAK BUTTERS
16. FREMANTLE: IAN HILL
17. PORT ADELAIDE: XAVIER DURRSMA
18. COLLINGWOOD NGA: ISAAC QUAYNOR (LOSE ALL THIRD ROUND PICKS - 4 POINT DEFICIT IN 2019)
19. ADELAIDE: LIAM STOCKER
20. WESTERN BULLDOGS: RHYLEE WEST (LOSE CURRENT PICKS 31 AND 36, PICK 36 BECOMES 43)
21. RICHMOND: XAVIER O'HALLORAN
22. BRISBANE: ELY SMITH
23. GWS: SAM STURT
24. WEST COAST: CURTIS TAYLOR

END FIRST ROUND


PICK 25. ADELAIDE: LUKE VALENTE
PICK 26. WEST COAST: JEZ McLENNAN
PICK 27. MELBOURNE: BAILEY WILLIAMS
28. GOLD COAST: JACOB KOSCHITZKE
29. GWS: SYDNEY STACK
30. MELBOURNE: NED McHENRY
31. GOLD COAST: MITCH MAGUIRE
32. NORTH MELBOURNE F/S: BAILEY SCOTT (LOSE PICKS 59, 62 - 106 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)
33. BRISBANE: JACOB KENNERLEY
34. FREMANTLE: LUKE FOLEY
35. BRISBANE ACADEMY: CONNOR McFADYEN (LOSE 2ND ROUND PICK - 223 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)
36. ESSENDON: JACK BYTEL
37. GWS ACADEMY: KIEREN BRIGGS (LOSE 3RD ROUND PICK - GO INTO 2019 DEFICIT)
38. ST. KILDA: ZAC FOOT
39. RICHMOND: JAMES ROWBOTTOM
40. SYDNEY: FRASER TURNER

Oh man, this would be hard to take on draft night. HFF and a HBF, even with Lecca leaving I think we are very well stocked for anything in the fwd half. Especially if we land Cameron. My slight tweak would be take Valente over Taylor. Work out nicely if we landed two SA boys in Valente and McLennan.

 

[Footywizard]

So I thought I’d try my best to simplify my rationale on bids in one post.

Think with my spreadsheet before and cutting and pasting different things the points system stuffed up.

In the first two rounds I anticipate bids on Blakey, Thomas, Quaynor, West, Scott, McFadyen and Briggs.

Here’s the breakdown and note that picks out column won’t match the current draft order as of 17/11 due to points being gained and lost with bids.


Nick Blakey / SYD owe 1240 pts
OUT: Picks 30, 38, 45
IN: Blakey, Pick 56 (c/o points from 45)

Tarryn Thomas / NMK owe 969 pts
OUT: Picks 49, 54 - 56, 62
IN: Thomas, Pick 68 (c/o from Pick 62)

Isaac Quaynor / COLL owe 788 pts
OUT: Picks 48, 51, 64, 66, 67
IN: Quaynor, Pick 72 as c/o from 67

Rhylee West / WB owe 715 pts
OUT: Picks 31, 37
IN: West and Pick 44 as c/o

Bailey Scott / NMK owe 345 pts
OUT: 65 and 68 (Thomas l/o points)
IN: Scott

DEFICIT OF 194 PTS IN 2019 DRAFT.

Connor McFadyen / BL owe 249 pts
OUT: Pick 41
IN: McFadyen, Pick 59 as c/o

Kieran Briggs / GWS owe 198 pts
OUT: Pick 59
IN: Briggs

DEFECIT OF 40 PTS IN 2019 DRAFT.


Hope it’s as clear as mud. Much prefer the method when Isaac Heeney was drafted personally

Your north picks are way off.

North have pick 42, 47 48 49 55 58.

Plus Sydney will have a few picks used before ours in a bid for blakey.

We will not go Into deficit

 

[getgaff]

Oh man, this would be hard to take on draft night. HFF and a HBF, even with Lecca leaving I think we are very well stocked for anything in the fwd half. Especially if we land Cameron. My slight tweak would be take Valente over Taylor. Work out nicely if we landed two SA boys in Valente and McLennan.

Agree.

Not sure what caused me to pick a fwd and a back when I’ve said we want more depth in the middle.

Will change it up today at some stage.

 

[getgaff]

Your north picks are way off.

North have pick 42, 47 48 49 55 58.

Plus Sydney will have a few picks used before ours in a bid for blakey.

We will not go Into deficit

Yeh i can see where there are flaws in it again now. Will strip it back again today.

That’s the problem with me not figuring out points owed straight away and doing 2 rounds of a mock first

 

[Footywizard]

Yeh i can see where there are flaws in it again now. Will strip it back again today.

That’s the problem with me not figuring out points owed straight away and doing 2 rounds of a mock first

All good brother you've done a good job like you do every year. It's hard to do all the points stuff. Makes things all that bit messy

 

[SumTingWong]

You seem pretty adamant that we want Xavier O'Halloran. Heard something as the word seems to be around McHenry?

 

[maverick001]

FIRST 2 ROUNDS UPDATED - BID MATCH PICKS HAVE BEEN CHANGED E.G.: WITH THE WEST BID ON THE CURRENT ORDER 27 BECAME 31 & 32 BECAME 36

PICK 1. CARLTON: SAM WALSH
PICK 2. GOLD COAST: JACK LUKOSIUS
PICK 3. GOLD COAST: IZAK RANKINE
4. ST. KILDA: MAX KING
5. PORT ADELAIDE: CONNOR ROZEE
6. GOLD COAST: JYE CALDWELL
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: BAILEY SMITH
8. SYDNEY ACADEMY: NICK BLAKEY (LOSE 3 SECOND ROUND PICK PICKS - PICK 38 BECOMES 51)
9. ADELAIDE: BEN KING
10. GWS: JACKSON HATELY

11. PORT ADELAIDE: JORDAN CLARK
12. GWS: CHAYCE JONES
13. NORTH MELBOURNE NGA: TARRYN THOMAS (LOSE 4 X 3RD ROUND PICKS - 49 BECOMES 65)
14. GEELONG: RILEY COLLIER DAWKINS
15. ADELAIDE: ZAK BUTTERS
16. FREMANTLE: IAN HILL
17. PORT ADELAIDE: XAVIER DURRSMA
18. COLLINGWOOD NGA: ISAAC QUAYNOR (LOSE ALL THIRD ROUND PICKS - 4 POINT DEFICIT IN 2019)
19. ADELAIDE: LIAM STOCKER
20. WESTERN BULLDOGS: RHYLEE WEST (LOSE CURRENT PICKS 31 AND 36, PICK 36 BECOMES 43)
21. RICHMOND: XAVIER O'HALLORAN
22. BRISBANE: ELY SMITH
23. GWS: SAM STURT
24. WEST COAST: CURTIS TAYLOR

END FIRST ROUND


PICK 25. ADELAIDE: LUKE VALENTE
PICK 26. WEST COAST: JEZ McLENNAN
PICK 27. MELBOURNE: BAILEY WILLIAMS
28. GOLD COAST: JACOB KOSCHITZKE
29. GWS: SYDNEY STACK
30. MELBOURNE: NED McHENRY
31. GOLD COAST: MITCH MAGUIRE
32. NORTH MELBOURNE F/S: BAILEY SCOTT (LOSE PICKS 59, 62 - 106 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)
33. BRISBANE: JACOB KENNERLEY
34. FREMANTLE: LUKE FOLEY
35. BRISBANE ACADEMY: CONNOR McFADYEN (LOSE 2ND ROUND PICK - 223 PT DEFECIT IN 2019)
36. ESSENDON: JACK BYTEL
37. GWS ACADEMY: KIEREN BRIGGS (LOSE 3RD ROUND PICK - GO INTO 2019 DEFICIT)
38. ST. KILDA: ZAC FOOT
39. RICHMOND: JAMES ROWBOTTOM
40. SYDNEY: FRASER TURNER

Gee if we don't take at least one mid with picks 20&22 come Thursday/Friday there is going to be a melt

 

[getgaff]

You seem pretty adamant that we want Xavier O'Halloran. Heard something as the word seems to be around McHenry?

Always been of the belief that they need a clearance specialist midfielder there. Whether it be O'Halloran, Stocker, RCD, Caldwell etc.

McHenry is a top up of what they already have, you can argue Higgins was the same in 2017 but theirtalents are poles apart in my opinion.

 

[getgaff]

BID EQUATIONS

Nick Blakey - SYD owe 1240 pts
OUT: Picks 26 & 33
IN: Blakey & 52 pts/ Pick 69.

Tarryn Thomas -NMK owe 969 pts
OUT: Picks 44, 49 - 51
IN: Thomas & 212 pts/ Pick 55.

Isaac Quaynor - COLL owe 788 pts
OUT: Picks 44, 47 & 60
IN: Quaynor & 36 pts/ Pick 71.

Rhylee West - WB owe 715 pts
OUT: Picks 31 & 36
IN: West & 393 pts/ Pick 43

Bailey Scott - NM owe 393 pts
OUT: 212 pts (residual Thomas bid) & Pick 57
IN: Scott & 7 pts/ Pick 74

Connor McFadyen - BL owe 345 pts
OUT: Pick 37
IN: McFadyen & 138 pts/ Pick 61

Keiran Briggs - GWS owe 286 pts
OUT: Pick 49 (initially 52)
IN: Briggs & 1 point/ Pick 74

Will Kelly - COLL owe 198 pts
OUT: On the current draft order without pick shuffling Collingwood's 2 x early 4th round picks would cover it.

 

[getgaff]

PICK 1. CARLTON: SAM WALSH
PICK 2. GOLD COAST: JACK LUKOSIUS
PICK 3. GOLD COAST: IZAK RANKINE
4. ST. KILDA: MAX KING
5. PORT ADELAIDE: CONNOR ROZEE
6. GOLD COAST: JYE CALDWELL
7. WESTERN BULLDOGS: BAILEY SMITH
8. SYDNEY ACADEMY: NICK BLAKEY
9. ADELAIDE: BEN KING
10. GWS: JACKSON HATELY

11. PORT ADELAIDE: JORDAN CLARK
12. GWS: ZAK BUTTERS
13. NORTH MELBOURNE NGA: TARRYN THOMAS
14. GEELONG: RILEY COLLIER DAWKINS
15. ADELAIDE: CHAYCE JONES
16. FREMANTLE: IAN HILL
17. PORT ADELAIDE: XAVIER DURRSMA
18. COLLINGWOOD NGA: ISAAC QUAYNOR
19. ADELAIDE: LUKE VALENTE
20. WESTERN BULLDOGS: RHYLEE WEST
21. RICHMOND: LIAM STOCKER
22. BRISBANE: ELY SMITH
23. GWS: SAM STURT
24. WEST COAST: XAVIER O'HALLORAN

END FIRST ROUND


PICK 25. ADELAIDE: CURTIS TAYLOR/ ED McHENRY
PICK 26. WEST COAST: JEZ McLENNAN
PICK 27. MELBOURNE: ED McHENRY
28. GOLD COAST: JACOB KOSCHITZKE
29. GWS: SYDNEY STACK
30. MELBOURNE: BAILEY WILLIAMS
31. GOLD COAST: MITCH MAGUIRE
32. NORTH MELBOURNE F/S: BAILEY SCOTT
33. BRISBANE: FRASER TURNER
34. BRISBANE ACADEMY: CONNOR McFADYEN
35. FREMANTLE: LUKE FOLEY
36. ESSENDON: JACK BYTEL
37. GWS ACADEMY: KIERAN BRIGGS
38. ST. KILDA: ZAC FOOT
39. RICHMOND: JAMES ROWBOTTOM
40. SYDNEY: JACOB KENNERLEY
41. SYDNEY: WILL GOLDS

END SECOND ROUND

 

[serial_thrilla]

getgaff just a heads up that you have Valente listed twice in your OP (19 & 25). I see that Taylor should be pick 25.

 

[getgaff]

getgaff just a heads up that you have Valente listed twice in your OP (19 & 24). I see that Taylor should be pick 24.

Thanks Serial. Spot on

2 rounds will probably have to do me this year as well folks. Going to be busy with work today and tomorrow.

Might be able to drag it out to pick 50 as I’ve got a scratchy third round on paper including bids for Cameron and Bedford.